The United State of Europe slogan
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-08-01Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 14 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 14
In SO 490 the lead article explained why socialists should be in favour of closer European political union, even in its present form ie. a bourgeois United States of Europe. The central point made was that the capitalist ruling class, though still competing internally, had also long outgrown the confines of the nation-state (witness the world wars), and that the only response workers can take to this is to strengthen international links and solidarity.
This position follows consistently from Socialist Organiser's traditional opposition to both pro-capitalist reformism and the other tide of anti-European chauvinism in the British labour movement. However, some readers will not necessarily be familiar with Trotsky's position in favour of the slogan during the First World War, or why Lenin eventually decided against it. Therefore an historical survey of their debate should help to explain why only calling for a "Socialist United States of Europi' is to evade the immediate practical demands for abstract propaganda.
Right at the outbreak of the war, and against a tide of chauvinism, it was in fact Lenin who first raised the slogan in his article "The Tasks of Revolutionary Social Democracy in the European War" (September 1914):
*Secondly, as an immediate slogan, propaganda for republics in Germany, Poland, Russia and other countries, and for the transforming of all the separate states of Europe into a republican United States of Europe"
In November 1914, Trotsky produced an excellent series of articles which have become known as "War and the International". He followed the same slogan but gave it a different justification "In these historical Like much of the left, Socialist Outlook was divided about its attitude to Militant's candidacy in the Walton by-election. The paper backed Labour, rather shamefacedly. But some Outlook supporters were unhappy with this it seems. The solution? Attack Socialist Organiser for being too vehement in its support for Labour condemnation of Mahmood!
John O'Mahony s ent them this letter, w nich they did not print.
(le. world economy, war, imperialism) it is not the business of the European proletariat to defend the outlived national 'Fatherland" which has become the main brake on economic progress, but rather to create a new and more stable fatherland - the republican United States of Europe as the transition to the united states of the world."
In this powerful internationalist manifesto Trotsky also set out the immediate programme for Marxists. His demands were: 'An immediate cessation of the war; no annexations; no reparations; the right of every nation to self-determination; the United States of Europe - without monarchies, without standing armies, without feudal castes, without secret diplomacy'. Throughout the war Trotsky emphasised the democratic aspect of the slogan.
However, in February-March 1915, the Bolshevik Party (abroad) held a conference in Bern in Switzerland, at which a fierce debate occurred around the applicability of the slogan 'United States of Europe' . For example, G.L.Shklovsky argued against it on three grounds: • The slogan implied a* democracy which under perialism was impossible • It was impossible because of the conflict of interests between European countries • If constituted, a united states of Europe would be formed only for the purpose of attacking the USA (ie. it is reactionary).
At that time Lenin continued to be in favour of the slogan, arguing that many of the democratic demands made by socialists were 'unrealistic' under capitalism, yet we retain the fight for reforms within our programme. Lenin also claimed that the opponents of the slogan had ignored the economic side of the question - that the bourgeoisie had already established a world system. However, because a number European socialists, such as Rosa Luxembourg, remained opposed to the slogan, Lenin suggested opening a debate in the Social Demokrat newspaper to clarify the matter.
n yes or no terms, denuded of waffle, you had exactly the same position on the Walton by-election as Socialist.
Organiser had: you supported the Labour candidate, you opposed Lesley Mahmood.
Yet in Outlook No.5 you attack us sharply, while hav ing no explicit criticism for the SWP and others who backed Mahmood, and hardly any for Militant.
The mealy-mouthed waffle you chose to wrap your pro-Labour position in -perhaps to hide yourselves in - is no virtue amongst Marxists. Very much the op: posite, I think.
Covering up your position with hints and half-thoughts as you did, you rendered yourselves inaudible and invisible as between us and the pro-Mahmood sectarians. true* imrevolution."
"Of course temporary post thee (Urgansmon EL There was in reality no half-way ground. One eithe joined the sectarian crusadi around Walton (a Militant candidate backed by the SWP, WRP, WP, ete) or came out clearly against it, saying why.
It is in the nature of wrap-it-in-cottonwool language to endorse the prevailing lies half truths.
Evidently you feel a bit ashamed for not backing the sectarians.
We argued it in terms of the political situation now and the forces involved, not, as you suggest, in terms of principle.J It is in the nature of wrap-it-in-cotton-wool. -In the course of the five months discussion, Lenin became convinced that he was wrong and in August 1915 he publically rejected the slogan in an article 'On the Slogan for a United States of Europe' What is interesting from our point of view is the reasons why he rejected it:
"It would be quite wrong to object to such a presentation of the question within the limits of a political appraisal of this slogan — eg. to argue that it obscures or weakens etc.
the slogan of the socialist revolution. Political changes of a truly democratic nature and especially political revolutions can under no circumstances whatsoever either obscure or weaken the slogan of a socialist avalatian 1 And ne aid not rule out possibility of a united states capitalists and between states.
8 pamphlets for just E5 -Norkers Liberty; Eastern Europe: towards Complete run of Workers' iberty Nos.iN 4-- 115, post 11-1 offend-no-one language to endorse the prevailing lies and half truths. Thus you write about "the Broad Left candidate" and so forth.
But it was a Militant candidacy, run by. Militant with Broad Left independents pushed aside; and the Broad Left is anyway an "invitation-only" appendage of Militant, with Tony Mulhearn as chair.
Militant's ridiculous lies that Mahmood was chosen by Walton Labour Party and Kilfoyle "imposed by London were undermined from the beginning by their simultaneous emphasis on her Militant identity. (By th way, your meaningless, placating formula that you blame the Labour Party leaders for the split translates easily into an endorsement of that lie).
A strong current in Militant has long been itching t try a bit of electioneering.
They almost did it in rstly: to the appress Europe is possible as an agreement between European capitalists... but to what end? Only for the purpose of jointly suppressing socialism in Europe, of jointly protecting colonial booty against Japan and America"
In other words he felt the slogar as reactionary for two reasons "A United States of Europe is tantamount to an agreement on the partition of the colonies"
"Compared with the USA, Europe as a whole denotes economic stagnation. On the present economic basis, ie. under capitalism, a United States of Europe would signity an organisation or reaction to retard America's more rapid 7.13 - £5, post free Other uNication:
Write to PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA. Cheques payable to SO.
Scotland last year. That, not #pressure from the Broad Left" , determined Militant's stand in Walton.
Mahmood was the candidate of the deservedly discredited ousted Hatton machine; she trailed the failures, fiascos, and betrayals of Militant's running of Liverpool City Council behind her like noisy tin cans. Betrayals? Yes. In. 1984 Militant made a deal with the Tories - who were then concentrating on defeating the miners — which postponed the crunch in Liverpool for a year.
They should have gone for fight alongside the miners.
The Walton candidacy was a sectarian stunt, a diversion from fighting to kick the Tories out and — because it is an excuse for a big new purge of the Labou left - the very opposite of serious fight against Kinnockism in the Labour Party. European economic integration, where the position has always been, neither for nor against. As to Lenin's reservations, at least his first claim is no longer applicable.
In the second case — of a European unit simply being a bulwark of reaction against the USA or Japan, it is no longer the case of stagnant Europe versus dvnamic America. though a relative case could be made for Japan. The point though is that the economic drive behind political union, whilst implying a greater integration amongst the European bourgeoisie, also opens up the possibility of European working class struggle, for example around the levelling up of welfare benefits etc. Lenin's objection then is not so much wrong in this context, but one-sidea.
unree quarters or a century since Lenin and Trotsky raised the A mail order service for socialist and abour movement books 4NA. Cheques payable to Alliance for It can only have depressed and damaged the fight with the council over jobs.
In essence you agree with us. But because we argue the case sharply and clearly, you denounce our coverage as close to "witch-hunting" Militant! This at a time when SO supporters are facing witch-hunts ourselves in four constituencies.
You come across as people who want to ingratiate yourself with the sectarians, and make them dislike you less, by abusing SO as the really nasty ones, those who acted and talked as if we believed in the position we had in common with you! You conclude by writing that you reject our typical Tesponse of the hopeless and mindless sectarians. We prefer to reserve our hostility for the Kinnockite witchhunters". Really? All right, you have convinced us.
From now on we'll do it your way!
Scan page 15
Socialist Organiser N