Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Rotten from the top down

Socialist Organiser no. 493, 1 August 1991 · scan p. 13 · Steven Holt · about 887 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 13 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 13

The Communards.

ilms giving a positive view of revolution are rare, and so Irish director, Ken McMullen's latest film should be of interest to socialists. 1871 has been bitterly attacked by the right in France, but its impact in Britain will be limited by its ghettoisation in nonmainstream cinemas.

McMullen's earlier films include characters change under the pressure of experience (the atrocities of the French army in Mexico 1867, the defeat by Prussia in the 1870/71 war) from loyal subjects of Napoleon III (acted by Dominique Pinon) to revolutionaries.

The scene in which a very nervous and shifty Napoleon III, while posing for a painting of himself dressed as Caesar, is haunted by Karl Marx (acted by the Mauritanian director Med Hondo, whose photo was mistaken for that of Marx in China some years ago!) is both very funny and allows acute political comment.

The Commune isn't idealised, either. Marx's criticism of the leadership for not seizing the assets of the banks is given, and we are shown internal bickering within the leadership.

I can highly recommend it as viewing for all those who are fed-up with the fairy tales, false sentimentality or glorified individual violence of Hollywood and the 'Victorian values' and complacency predominant in British culture. Television By Kevin Feintuck Things are rotten and they're rotten from the top down... until finally the poison seeps down to the likes of us and then we get a taste of it."

This sentence from Laura Nelson (Dearbhla Molloy) in the final episode sums up much of the message at the heart of "GBH".

The seven episodes have shown Bleasdale's two central characters, Jim Nelson and Michael Murray, reduced to puppets being controlled by an all-powerful Secret Service. The manipulating boss politician has been totally set up and trapped while the violence-hating middle-class teacher has given the MIS man a severe beating with a tennis racket.

The series climaxed with massive riots enveloping Murray's city and ultimately his Town Hall. These riots are sparked by MIS-organised attacks on black people and have, apparently, been engineered by the ruling-class conspirators to destroy Murray's fiefdom.

What do these two strands Bleasdale's two souls of Labourism (Murray v. Nelson) and the conspiracy which can manipulate whole layers whilst remaining hidden to the. masses - tell us about the author's view of the world?

Looking at the conspiracy theory first, no-one who watched the series can doubt the extent of the conspiracy. The sinister political grouping around the university professor is no more than an extension of the state spook service. The pickets in the day of action have been heavily infiltrated and, in some cases, are actually in the pay of the Secret Service. The well-meaning junior police officer seems convinced that the real perpetrators of violence are genuine left-wing supporters of Murray.

Conspiracy theories are not new and come in many varieties. They range from the poisons of fascism and their "Protocols of the Learned series of class struggles.

The particularly pernicious feature of Bleasdale's conspiracy theory is that the viewer is often not allowed to differentiate between the conspirators and genuine Labour movement activists. This was particularly marked in the scenes at the school "picket" in the first scene but was subsequently repeated, for example at the meeting of Sloan's political organisation.

The ultimate irony for Bleasdale's conspiracy emerges with his riot scenes. The writer has been around for long enough to remember the real riots which broke out in the real Britain (including the real Liverpool) ten years ago. Although the scenes were clearly modelled on reality, the plot only allowed for riots to be triggered by MIS conniving. This mock "explanation" goes no way to explaining the real problems of multiple deprivation and racial harrassment which can trigger rioting across many parts of the globe. Certainly a world in which working class political activity is a product of rul. ng class plots can offer no better way forward than random rioting.

As for the two central protagonists, they teach the viewer very little about how individuals intermesh with the Labour movement or are corrupted by the prevailing class society.

Here again "GBH" portrayed the individuals' political activities as being a result of psychological make-up and interactions rather than being moulded and driven by the social forces around them. If this was really the case, society and social movements can only be interpreted as a long-running psychodrama with neither a meaningful plot or any hope of a satisfying conclusion.

As regards the author's preferred soul for the Labour movement, it is clear that his sympathies lie with the middle-class teacher rather than a socialism based on working-class activity. Jim Nelson's (and I suspect Alan Bleasdale's) contempt for the organised working class is dismissed with the disdainful lions led by donkey-jackets"

During his speech to the local socialism is the redistribution not Nelson proclaims, only of wealth but of care and concern and equality and decency and belief in humankind." There's plenty in that statement with which socialists would agree.

The problem is that no amount of good, honest Jim Nelsons could create that better world. Only the organised working class is capable of eliminating the corruption and manipulation which permeates capitalist society and the Labour bureaucracy which exists within it. Alan Bleasdale's drama tragically missed that point.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 493

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →