Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Redemption Son

Socialist Organiser no. 493, 1 August 1991 · scan pp. 13–14 · Bertolt Brecht · about 826 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 13 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 13

Ghost Dance, also concerned with the memory of the Paris Commune (featuring deconstructionist philosopher Jacques Derrida as one of the cast!) and Zina, about Trotsky's daughter in Germany and Trotsky's exile on an island off Turkey.

Ken McMullen says of his new film: "I believe people move to a political position out of circumstances. The accumulated experiences of their lives lead them in a certain direction. A film has to work at the same level. Our film is an entertainment, full of music, song, spectacle, eroticism and comedy. The audience must be involved... the film guides them to support the Commune."

The plot opens in Paris, 1867, at the -time of the Universal Exposition, Napoleon's great showcase, with a visit to the theatre by the Prince of Wales (who is presented in such a way as to delight antimonarchists) and Lord Grafton (Roshan Seth).

We are then shown the other characters in the film, the actresses Séverine (Ana Padrao) and Maria (Maria de Medeiros) and the exiled Irish revolutionary O'Brien (John Lynch). The Prince of Wales flirts with Séverine after the show, whilst her lover O'Brien, is accosted by Cluseret (Jack Klaff), who attempts to harness his nationalism to the cause of world revolution: "Beware of nationalism! It speaks to our hearts, but it turns governments into greedy killers". (All too true as we are now seeing in Yugoslavia and elsewhere.

And so the film goes on, Television nti-black racism is alive A and well even in the West Indies, according to Redemption Song (BBC). Blacks are lazy, say some of the Indian communities of Guyana and Trinidad. Indians see themselves as hard-working, while many blacks dismiss them as "coolies" because they take on low paid work in the canefields.

But many Indians have no choice: that is the only work they can get. All would like a better life — a house, not a shack, work that wasn't backbreaking and low-paid - but opportunities are scarce.

These so-called "East Indian" communities are descended from Indians brought to the islands as in-dentured servants, a form of ultra cheap labour used in the canefields after slavery was abolished. The indenture system was little more than slavery under another name; workers could not change plantations, pay and accommodation were miserable. Few could save enough from their contracts to gc home again.

Many of their descendants have done little better. Rashid, a canecutter, had to travel two hours by barge before his paid day's work began. In a good season, he could earn 20 pounds a week; more often, it was six. Even this pitiful wage was often in jeopardy. The foreman, under instructions trom the boss to keep wages down, would deflect complaints about the pay by attacking the quality of the work.

Some Indians had clawed their way up to become exploiters themselves. One family had grown rich by growing rice. Their vast holdings allowed them to sell their rice cheaper than the smallholders, many of whom were going broke. The government subsidised the rich planter, but gave nothing to the poor ones.

Ray, a prospector, panned for gold in the virgin forest region of Guyana. He was unconcerned about his employees' safety. Two workers had been crushed to death while diving for gold, but Ray shrugged it off. He was equally blasé about environmental damage.

"It's been here for years; no-one wants it," he said, waving nonchalantly at the forest he was wrecking with his bulldozers.

The most depressing thing about Redemption Song was the way the two communities - black and Indian - blamed each other for their problems, instead of fighting back together. Elders of Zion" to the bizarre ramblings of the various sects to have emerged from the collapse of Gerry Healy's former Trotskyism.

What these theories have in common is the ability of a group of organised individuals to rise above the real motor forces of history and to control and direct these forces without ever needing to reveal either their identities or real motives. This view of history as series of plots and manipulations is diametrically opposed to a Marxist view of history as a developing By Bertolt Brecht You tell us it looks bad for our cause, The darkness gets deeper. The powers get Now, after we worked for so many years We are in a more difficult position than at the But the enemy stands there, stronger than ever before His powers appear to have grown. He has taken on a invincibility.

We however have made mistakes; there Our numbers are dwindling.

Our slogans are in disarray. The enemy Part of our words beyond recognition. What is now false of what we said:

Some or all?

Whom do we still count on? Are we ju Of the living stream? Shall we remain !

Understanding no one and understood Have we got to be lucky?

This you ask. Expect No other answer than

Scan page 14

Socialist Organiser No. 493 pa!

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 493

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →