Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

No socialism without democracy! Heoneretely at how the

Socialist Organiser no. 493, 1 August 1991 · scan pp. 11–12 · Richard Lane · about 2,419 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 11

The one-party system was proclaimd as the true working class lemocracy, universally applicable. The basic programmatic norms of evolutionary socialism were being sulped and destroyed. Democratic deals and goals that had been cenral to radical thought since the French Revolution or even since the English revolutions of the 17th cenury, were replaced - though the ild democratic labels were still used - by realities which concentrated n themselves the statism and uthoritarianism which different mbodiments of the left had been ighting against for hundreds of ears! Mystification and confusion nevitably followed.

Meanwhile, in the hands of the ight wing the international hings in the British labour movenent, it is important to be clear that oviets are a "parliamentary" ystem. • Being independent of the exiting bureaucratic/military system • which capitalist rule is tied, they re — to go by experience so far — ne best form of organisation for a forkers' movement that is seriously etting about transforming society gainst the will of the ruling class. • That they are more appropriate nan any other known form of emocracy for the socialist rule of ne working class, in so far as it inolves a qualitative expansion of he direct exercise of democracy. • That they can and will remerge at intensive levels of mass orking class action, when the labour movement, the commitment to perfecting the democratic institutions of capitalist society became a commitment to the bourgeoisie against the revolutionary workers and their soviets. In German the 1918 revolution created a bourgeois democratic regime, realising most of the "democratic" demands of the old revolutionary workers' movement, but as part of a landlord-bourgeois counterrevolution against the workers! The right wing socialists allied with the Junkers against the revolutionary workers!

This prostitution by the right wing socialists of the old socialist ideals of enlarging democracy convinced revolutionary workers that only soviet democracy could serve struggle overflows the channels of the existing system. We may have come close to it in Britain in 1972.This is why workers' councils are a central part of the programme of revolutionary Marxism.

The word "soviet" has been utterly debased by association with the totalitarian bureaucracy of the USSR - which, as the sour old joke has it, contains four lies in its name: it is not a union, there are no soviets, it is not socialist, and it is not a republic. But Marxists remain committed to soviet democracy. We continue the old socialist commitment to expanding democracy in a qualitative way. We explain the limits of existing democracy and the possibilities of la different democracy.

Andrew socialist ends. It also softened them up to receive the Stalinist revelations that all the old talk of democracy meant nothing but bourgeois lies. It helped ease them into acceptance of the one-party Stalinist totalitarian state as the true proletarian democracy. The result was to banish concern with democracy and to falsify the very language and concepts in which both the old pre-world war socialist movement, and the early communist movement, had understood democracy.

In the mid-'30s the Stalinists dropped soviets from their programme and, pursuing alliances with the right of the labour movements and with Liberals to serve Russian foreign policy interests, became hypocritical worshippers of the existing parliaments. At the same time they pushed the debilitating lie that Stalinist totalitarianism was a form of "workers" democracy. This senseless assertion became an article of faith for two generations of revolutionary workers.

The basic idea that socialists must continue to struggle for human liberty and freedom was expunged from the programme of "communism". "Democracy" - like "socialism" — became a cynical catch-cry, shot through with double-think about the "democracy" of the society where the Stalinist bureaucrats ruled.

Trotsky noted the corrupting etfect of this on the labour movement itself when he commented on the Norwegian Labour Party: "I soon had occasion to become convinced, by experience, that the old bourgeois functionaries sometimes have a broader viewpoint and a more profound sense of dignity than Messrs"Socialist" Ministers...

Now might soviets emerge in concretely at how the existing British parliamentary system might be displaced by workers' councils, the difference between Marxist democrats and the Kinnockites becomes clear. The difference between what we really stand for and the lies they tell about lus become clear..

Propaganda by Marxists will not by itself win enough workers to support for workers' councils ("soviets") to threaten the parliamentary system. The relevant historical experience on which the proposal is based is too remote. Propaganda alone could not win the mass of workers away from commitment to the existing parliamentary system.

Soviets have most often emerged in conditions where parliamentary democracy did not exist, or was severely limited. The precondition for soviets in Britain to move from the realm of propaganda and accounts of history to the realm of practical working class politics would be - obviously - mass struggle, but also and centrally a major erosion of belief that parliament is an accessible democratic institution. But belief in the parliamentary system is still very deep and powertul in the British people and in the labour movement. And the system still has a lot of flexibility.

Councils of Action having many points in common with soviets came into existence in Britain in- 1920. Something like an incipient soviet emerged in Durham during the 1926 General Strike. But even if a vast network of Councils of Action were now to emerge in a general strike, it is unlikely that they would starkly counterpose themselves to the existing parliament, as an alternative system of democratic rule - unless there had been a serious erosion of belief in parliament as the natural democratic system.

How will such an erosion of belief in Westminster occur? Even if a large revolutionary Marxist party existed, it could not occur, I repeat, as a result of propaganda alone. It will only occur when the ruling class — in response to the exigencies of the struggle against the working class to keep or exert control - is forced to begin to abrogate its own system, to downgrade it, and thereby, over time, to rob its processes of credibility.

Thus the existing system would have to be undermined from two sides - by growing self-confidence, self-organisation, and disillusionment with parliament among the working class, and by growing impatience or desperation among the ruling class.

This is what Marxists such as Trotsky teach us on this question. I have already quoted Trotsky's call to the social reformist workers of France to defend parliamentary democracy (1934). In the same vein he warned Marxists not to make a religion of soviets. This advice has one hundred times greater force today, when the experience of the initial liberating Russian soviets is so far back in history. "Soviets'? now are, and can only be, a matter of propaganda: and the socialist who would counterpose such propaganda to the necessary working class struggle, which must include struggles around the existing parliamentary system, is a sectarian fool, incapable of learning either from life or „from Trotsky's approach in France Now, if the Marxist expectation that the ruling class will not be bound by its own parliamentary rules is wrong, then very probably "soviets" will remain a matter of propaganda by Marxists who favour soviets as a different, better system of democracy. In that case, the right and the soft left, who now witch-hunt those who advocate a different form of democracy as enemies of democracy, have little to worry about.

It is not our propaganda for a different sort democracy, soviets, that worries the right, nor is it only that we lack respect for "Parliament". It is not even entirely a matter of grabbing a convenient demarcation line to serve an organisational purpose now. What is it then that worries them? What is the dividing line between them and us? The dividing line is extraparliamentary struggle now. They are using the witch-hunt against the allegedly anti-democratic Trotskyists as a means of frightening the less determined section of the left out of any will that Labour and the unions should fight the Tories now, using extra-parliamentary action where appropriate.

Their rallying cry, "democracy", is a double lie because they will not fight back against the Tories even to defend the democracy they now hide behind against the criticism of the Marxists. It is the "antidemocratic" Marxists who want to defend trade union rights and democracy against Thatcher, not the professional democrats!

We will defend democratic rights tooth and nail, and with guns. Most of the right wing "professional democrats" won't. The German Social Democrats helped the Junker army to massacre revolutionary workers in 1919 under the banner of preserving parliamentary democracy: they meekly surrendered it to Hitler in 1933. The Party leader in the Reichstag, Otto Wels, meekly offered his and his party's collaboration to Hitler, who didn't need it then.

A collection of articles from Socialist Organisı Price £2 plus 38 pence p&p. Make cheques payable to Socialist Organiser. Available PO Box 823, Londo 4NA

Scan page 12

Debate: "Politically Correct" movement Wi-e- sionist anast yorad Lom.. read it when unity to run into your A split has occured in my newspaper here in Kan- oarty and their new press is Cuba? I'm also curious to sas City and I find it in- 3:5O Saciran teresting. OFge DiSa hit-te Tam a member of the US Cont The US Socialist pild sns 10-0a Organizer is is Lambers What is your opinion of the tionary Communist Party to your organisation, I will con- Organiser is a welcome and I resigned from the revi- papt: MEN S55I Socialist Organiser No. 493 page 12 he Australian TLabor The Le pitiful. The Left has more influence than ever (45 of 101 delegates to National Conference), but are more incorporated than ever. Unemployment is 10%, Australia has just fought an imperialist war, but the Left is able to have unity with the Right on economic and foreign policy at the National Conference.

Sub-factional brawls in the Victoria Socialist Left [the left faction of the Victoria Australian Labor Party] have reached new depths over pre-selection. A number of 'Hard Left" unions broke Socialist Left decisions and ran their own candidates. These were elected due to a deal with the Right! The Socialist Left responded by expelling these candidates. Very little debate about the political differences - just numbercrunching.

I was a delegate to March State Conference (from my union) and was able to attack Robert Ray — Defence Minister - over the Gulf War: 'This ALP today is a party of war... This government and this man have Robin Templeton and • Allison Roche (SO 492) criticise Jim Denham's attack (SO 488) on the "politically correct" movement on US campuses.

But a recent article in the New York Review of Books inclines me to think that Jim is right to object to the rise of the *as a..." approach (speaking *as a woman... , "as a black person.." , "as a Jew... ", etc) in academic life.

The article is about Germany not the US, and about another oppressed group, disabled people; but it highlights the basic Peter Singer is a professor of philosophy in Melbourne, Australia. Best known in the English-speaking world for his writings in favour of animal liberation", he also argues, as he explains in the NYRB article, *that the parents of severely disabled newborn infants should be able to decide, together with their physician, whether their Socialist Action subscribe to nearly every oriented.

other left newspaper from the ultra-left Maoist the reformist democratic Communist Party. infant should live or die.

"If the parents and their medical adviser are in agreement that the infant's life will be so miserable or so devoid of minimal satisfactions that it would be inhumane or futile to prolong life, then they should be able to ensure that death comes about speedily and without suffering."

He makes clear that he has in mind babies with such conditions as anencephaly, who have no prospect of ever gaining consciousness, not Down's syndrome and the like. "My views cannot be a threat to anyone who is capable of wanting to go on living, or even of understanding that his or her life might be threatened."

I don't know how far 1 agree with Singer, but there must be room for debate over his ideas;

very few people, after all, would never, ever switch off a life support machine.

Over the last two years, however, Singer has been mobbed off academic platforms in Germany. Others who share his joined Socialist Action.

save scea political disagreements with tinue to read it. because O the extremely high subscription rate i cannor get

AALSOU

LEBEN Anti-abortion demonstrations in Munich, 1991.

live", "Yes, you should live".

views have been treated similarly.

And, Singer reports, the "opposition comes not, as it would in English-speaking) countries, she's done with it.

is your opinion on COGISEAGOn cese mirw Socialist tcaio.nxtt press collection. from right-wing conservative and religious groups, but from the left." It is led by the "Crip ples Movement" , and supporte! by feminist, anarchist, and other leftist groups, arguing that Singer's views resemble Nazi treatment of unfit people. (In fact Singer is a leftist, and three of his grandparents died in Nazi concentration camps).

Singer's article also indicates how attempts to confine debate within bounds of acceptability to set prejudices (the left's or anyone else's) can condemn themselves by leading to self-contradiction. Singer comments that German feminists have been led to the idea "that a woman should have the right to an abortion, but not to an abortion based on accurate information about the future lifeprospects of the fetus she is car rying"

Only a stage further is the tivists and disabled activists tempting to ban each other in e same way as anti-Zionists id Zionists have tried to ban ich other in the British student ovement.

Doubtless Singer's article will Fused by US right-wingers hose opposition is not really , "politically correct" censorlip and academic ghettonilding but to serious attempts • broaden traditional Angloentric syllabuses in the umanities. But on the basic sue socialists must surely ave common ground with all onsistent democrats and berals.

The right to think and voice outrageous" ideas — inuding ideas which outrage the ft — is vital for the working ass if it is to liberate itself om the ideas of the ruling lass.

Colin Foster Islington

----- pull-quotes -----

Socialists Democracy

he right to be outrageous

prospect of feminist pro-choice DU SOLLST TEBEN

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 493

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →