Who are the
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-08-01Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
In the British labour movement today the use the charge that Marxists are against a cudgel against Labour Party socialists.
The Communist Manifesto of Marx and Engels socialism as a matter of "winning the battle of democracy". But for decades after 1917 democracy socialism seemed to have parted company. The "democrats" in the labour movement were mainly pro-capitalist; the Stalin-poisoned revolutionary movements wanted one-party dictatorships. Those in the Trotskyist tradition who still said "He who is not a democrat is not a socialist" were an isolated handful.
In this except from the SO pamphlet, "Socialists an Democracy", ", John O'Mahony surveys the ideas about democracy which have influenced the socialist movements.
There are two distinct but interwoven strands in the attitudes the labour movement has taken -to parliamentary democracy..
The first was and is ardent championing of parliamentiry democracy and democratic liberties. In varying alliances with sections of the middle class, early labour movements fought to extend the suffrage and enlarge the power of parliament — often by revolutionary means.
The first mass political labour movement, Chartism, in the 1830s and '40s, took shape around demands for the reshaping of the existing parliamentary system so as to admit the working class to the suffrage and make it possible for workers to be MPs. In Britain, as late as 1917, the Workers' Socialist Federation, led by Sylvia Pankhurst (emerging out of the Workers' Suf.
responsive system of democratic selfmasses. frage Federation, which in turn came out of the left wing of the suffragette movement in the East End) based themselves on an extremely radical programme of democratic reform, attempting to graft on to the British parliament features of the workers council system that had just emerged in Russia.
In 1934 Trotsky suggested a united front with reformist workers in France for a similar programme.
*As long as the majority of the working class continues on the basis of bourgeois democracy, we are ready to defend it with all our forces against violent attacks from the Bonapartist and fascist bourgeoisie.!
However, we demand from our class brothers who adhere to "democratic' socialism that they be faithful to their ideas, that they draw inspiration from the ideas and methods not of the Third Republic but of the Convention of 1793. Down with the Senate, which is elected by limited suffrage, and which renders the power of universal suffrage a mere illusion! Down with the presidency of the republic,
Kinnockites
democracy as They are as which serves as a hidden point militarism and reaction, forces of munarism ana reaction. A single assembly must combine the legislative and executive powers. Members would be elected for two years, by universal suffrage at eighteen years of age, with по discrimination of sex or nationality. Deputies would be elected on the basis of local assemblies, constantly revocable by their constituents, and would receive the salary of a skilled worker. This is the only measure that would lead the masses forward instead of pushing them backward. A more generous democracy would facilitate the struggle for workers' We want to attain our objective not by armed conflicts between the various groups of toilers, but by real workers' democracy, by propaganda and loyal criticism, by the voluntary regrouping of the great majority of the proletariat under the flag of true communism. Workers adhering to democratic socialism must further understand that it is not enough to defend democracy; democracy must be regained The moving of the political centre of gravity from parliament towards the cabinet, from the cabinet towards the oligarchy of finance capital, generals, police, is an accomplished fact. Neither the present parliament nor the new elections can change this.
We can defend the whole sorry remains of democracy, and especially we can enlarge the democratic arena for the activity of the masses, only by annihilating the armed fascist forces that, on 6 February 1934, started moving the Kinnock poses for the media. Photo: John Smith (Profile) direct control of the legislature — delegates could be recalled and replaced, easily and repeatedly.
The soviet network showed itself to be a uniquely flexible and responsive system of democratic self-organisation and, increasingly, of self-rule by the Russian masses. Whereas even the most democratic parliamentary system was tied. to the bourgeois military/bureaucratic structure, the soviets were radically counterposed to the surviving Tsarist military/bureaucratic state.
In 1917 the Congress of Soviets (with the Bolshevik Party as its driving, force) seized state power. Thereafter the drive to reform and develop the existing parliaments gave place, for millions of revolutionary workers throughout the world, to a commitment to soviets as the highest torm or democracy. Everywhere on earth, revolutionary-minded people recognised the soviet as the working class form of democracy.
Commitment to soviets became a central part of the programme of evolutionary socialism. Sounds within which there oviet" meant, then, workers' would be a plurality of "soviet" parties. Nobody in the communist movement advocated the idea that soviets would be ruling organs of state in a one-party system. Through most of the civil war in Russia and the wars of intervention, non-Bolshevik parties loyal to the workers' state - J. Martov's Menshevik Interna" tionalists, for example - were legally active in the soviets.
When, in March 1921, at the end of the civil war, the Bolsheviks banned all other Soviet parties, it was a temporary measure, not the norm of working class rule. Not long after the Stalinists seized control: one party rule became the norm. Inevitably this Russian reality confused many communists as to exactly what soviet rule would be.
In consequence, "communism" had, partly through confusion and incoherence, arising out of antisocial democratic-polemic, an antidemocratic bias, even before full-blown Stalinism.
After the full-scale Stalinist counter-revolution in the late '20s,
----- pull-quotes -----
Labour ignorant as they are demagogic!
"The soviet network showed itself to be a uniquely flexible and
organisation and, increasingly, of self- rule by the Russian