John Mcllroy reviews the new Tory Green Paper on trade union lav Tightening the fetters
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-08-01Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 5
"Industrial Relations in the 1990s"
This was almost a year to the day he announced that there would be a long pause in the marathon legal blitzkrieg. Comments on the Green Paper must be in by October 23. Howard stated that there will be no opportunity to turn these proposals into legislation prior to a general They will thus form Tory manifesto.
Industrial action he Green Paper proposals tighten the limits put on workers' action by laws about ballotting.
• Hitherto postal ballots — as against workplace ballots - have not been required for industrial action. Now it is proposed that they should be mandatory when 50 or more members are involved in the action. Moreover the conduct of ballots will be removed from the union into the hands of independent scrutineers such as the Electoral Reform Society. industrial action • Having gone through the labyrinth of the existing balloting provisions, unions will now, in addition, have to give their employers seven days notice of industrial action before ensuing action is protected by the law.
• As part of the Citizen's Charter consumers are to be given a new right to take legal action against unions who strike in the public services in breach of the law.
Apart from the intrinsic difficulties - and additional expense we face with postal ballots - they are more disrupting when applied to strikes than to internal union elections where the time scale is tighter. Postal balloting before strikes will lead to longer delays. Seven days notice, running from the date of the nina from the date of the ballot declaration, in a situation where speed is often of the essence can only place another high card in the pack of the gaffer.
These provisions will make industrial action generally that little bit harder to organise.
Specifically, the requirement of seven days notice will reduce unions' room for manoeuvre in relation to one-day strikes and shorter stoppages which are intended to contain elements of surprise.
Seven days notice will have to be given before each one-day strike, or each one-hour stoppage. dealing with poaching actions of unions like the EETPU Collective agreements he Green Paper proposes that the courts would assume collective agreements between bosses and unions to be legally binding unless specifically states otherwise.
Until now, neither bosses nor unions have ever been able to sue the other for breaking agreements.
The object of legal enforceability has always been the procedure agreement. If you have a procedure which states "no industrial action until procedure is exhausted" then industrial action prior to this could be the subject of injunction if the agreement is legally enforceable.
However, just at the moment -Special Introductowy -Service Consen/ative derend Mhae radestunions that it is voluntarily agreed to, indeed often encouraged by the gafters, it has attracted the anger of the Tories. How, the cabinet marvels, can supine employers limbo quite so low as to guarantee the unions' finances for them?
The Green Paper now proposes that union members must agree in writing to deductions at source at least annually but also when there is an increase in union dues. The aspiration here is clearly to undermine union finances.
The Tories aim to exploit the degree to which unions themselves have become slack, bureaucratic organisations divorced from sections of the membership, and taking them for granted.
Many ordinary members may well ask why should we continue to pay good ackers for garbage? An annual audit of activity workplace and District level carried out by shop stewards in the context of a campaign to maintain and extend membership certainly has attractions for socialist trade membership Tal workers should have a rin he Green Paper suggests to belong to whichever union they choose, "where more than one union can genuinely claim to be able to represent an employee's interests."
Once more the Tories are attempting to take advantage of trade union complacency and inefficienc
in order to mobilise disgruntled members for the purpose of disrupting union activities, particularly
abide by a Bridlington award after poaching members from other unions.
Michael Howard's new proposals would make it extremely difficult for the TUC to operate this disputes procedure which, whilst bureaucratically deformed in practice, is essentially progressive.
For example, if NUPE were instructed by the TUC to return members it had poached to NALGO, then the individuals involved could probably, under the new proposals, get a court order stopping NUPE returning the members to NALGO.
"In this campaign [to elect a Labour government] and after we draw a lint between ourselvesOther measures The colication officer: he rest of the Green Paper is The certification officer, smarting from his recent reverse at the hands of the NUM, Will be given increased powers to interfere in union affairs and bring prosecutions. If these are successful, they will carry heavier penalties for trades Union members will be given additional rights to inspect union accounts. Unions will have to provide all members with more detailed information about financial matters including the salaries of officials.
And trade unionists and independent scrutineers will have new rights to inspect the register of members. Each of these in itself is pretty innocuous. Added together they all make a small contribution to a union-hostile environment.
In response Norman Willis has roundly condemned the new proposals, citing MORI polls showing large majorities opposing further anti-union legislation.
Tony Blair has followed suit. Their rhetoric means little and matters less. They condemned in similar fashion each previous round of legislation, including key provisions they now find eminently desirable.
Whilst continuing to fight the legislation on the ground we must realise that the only way to stop Howard's proposals and rid ourselves root and branch of their predecessors is through the election of a Labour government In this campaign and after we draw a line between ourselves and Willis and Blair, fighting to com pletely replace the Tory laws with a charter of positive rights. Omly this can provide basis for
----- pull-quotes -----
"Having gone through the labyrinth of the existing balloting provisions, unions will now, in addition, have to give their employers seven days notice o
before ensuing action is protected by the law."
Offer-froma Norkens' Liberty Bopb
Jbhn Milky-the Permenenta Rew olutone
WA SOGAT PICKE
and Willis and Blair, fighting to completely replace the Tory laws with charter of positive rights."