A girls' own fantasy
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-07-18Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 13 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 13
from, and dances with, a predator. takes place.
When they step out for some fresh Thelma befriends a young hitair he attempts to rape her and is khiker, spends the night with him only prevented by Louise holding a and is transformed. Incredibly, this .38 to his ear. After a brief verbal feminist tale asks us to believe that A rather severe response, - girlish, scatterbrained suburban thought, but it is no accident and is housewife with a confident, asserOklahoma hotel for some money to turns up unexpectedly with the come through their metamorphosis money and even more unexpectedly Tony Brown, reviews Thelma and Louise and warns that the storyline is given away..
ollywood has maintained -its movie making pre-eminence largely because of its ability to reshape and retell a number of stock stories.
To be successful they require updating or a new twist. In the past few years we've seen plenty of amples of reworked genres in Dances with Wolves (Western), Presumed Innocent (murder mystery), Pretty Woman (Cinderella fantasies), and Class Action justice achieved through the courts). Now add to this list Thelma and Louise as a modern road movie.
Building on the common thread of past road movies Thelma and Louise adds a new, feminist, dimension. It also pays homage to two other genres, the older hunted outlaw on the run, and the more recent (male) buddy films.
All this might sound too conscious, too crafted, too didactic, but that's exactly what it is. Writer Callie Khouri, and director Ridley Scott have set out to put feminism before a mass audience. They have taken an old, successful formula and used it to put across their story.
It's a worthwhile goal and much of it works. There is an emotional appeal that will register with many female viewers, like the two women behind me who cheered each act of revenge on the witless males on screen. But its conclusions are crude, outdated, contradictory and deeply pessimistic.
The fantasy of Hollywood makes life cheap and personal, violent, revenge an all too easy option.
The road has stood as a spiritual and physical metaphor for enlightenment through journey. Generally the characters are either outlaws or outside of conventional society. They must embrace an alternative moral code to the dominant one. We judge them by their code and how they follow it.
Thelma (Geena Davis) and Louise (Susan Sarandon) set out for a short holiday to get away from the men in their lives. Thelma's husband is oblivious to her, except when he is being rude and being ted, and is off screwing arounc while she waits patiently for him at home.
Louise's boyfriend Jimmy is less rude but equally thoughtless. He won't make any commitments to her.
Three crucial events change their At their first stop, at a bar, Thelma naively accepts a few drinks Susan Sarandon as Louise and Geena Davis as Thelma exchange Louise shoots him.
portrayed as justifiable.
The attack triggers off something from Louise's past that we are not let in on. That's deliberate, we are left to guess whether she has been raped in the past, or abused, or subjected to some other horror. Her secret is held up as something shared, or potentially shared, by all women. The attempted rape is an attack on all women and the retribution is a form of gender revenge.
From here on Thelma and Louise are on the run, hunted by the local Detective Slocumbe (Harvey Keitel) and the FBI.
Completely disorientea and alone they begin to plan their escape to Mexico. While waiting in an one good fuck has replaced the tive woman. "But Thelma and Louise have crossed a divide. They are not prepared to re-enter society and the cops are bent on destroying them. Rather than surrender they hold hands and fly away. To freedom? It's all a bit of a girls' own fantasy."
Meanwhile, Louise's boyfriend with an engagement ring.
She turns him down. The murder has opened her eyes to something in men that she will no longer collaborate with.
Their attitude is further hardened when they realise that the hitchhiker has stolen Louise's life savings -not even a good lover can be trusted.
As their position becomes more desperate, their bond is strengthened. This is one of the film's strong points, their time together in the spectacular desert allows some reflection and calm before the climax.
Louise progressively strips off all her feminine adornments, her make up, earrings, jewellery. Thelma tells her that her only regret is that she didn't shoot her attacker herself.
To cement their break from male society they confront the tanker driver who has harassed them repeatedly on the road. They lure him into stopping and demand an apology which they don't get. Here the script lets them down badly. Revenge is the point but blowing up the truck is neither very imaginative nor ecological.
They are finally trapped between