Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

The testament of a shameless careerist

Socialist Organiser no. 492, 18 July 1991 · scan pp. 12–13 · about 857 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 12

Ruth Cockroft looks at what is already almost a classic shameless climbing to posi tion on the backs of the working class - Derek Hatton's Inside Left.

Derek Hatton's Inside Left, Dalthough written in 1985, is once again becoming very topical. Hatton's "story so far" is a thinly disguised PR job; a heavily edited and rather light coverage of events which surrounded Liverpool Council between 1983 and 1986Hatton's self-satisfaction and his breathtaking arrogance slap you in the face from every page, but what is more illuminating is the insight that Hatton allows into the Militant Tendency's political world.

Hatton makes little mention of being a socialist in his early "political career" and admits to becould become part of the mainstream of politics, but at the same time be part of revolutionary change."

Hatton speaks of the Militant's religious devotion to politics; the "spreading of the gospel" and the *shared political faith". It is interesting that Hatton rejects the Protestant church in his youth but almost consciously takes on board the Militant's politics as a new religion.

Hatton makes it clear that the Militant had a significant influence over events which occurred in Liverpool. He signals out Mulhearn, Peter Taaffe and Ted Grant, "the long-standing inspirational figure of Trotskyism in Britain. Yet, as the tragedy of mistakes and incompetence unfolds it becomes clear that the strategy was at all times to stay within the law and to delay setting an illegal budget that would confront the Tories head on.

From the beginning the Council was prepared to raise the rates to "bridge the gap between providing services and underfunding from central government. Rather than implement an illegal budget and face surcharge and disqualification, the Council instead took the option of the infamous showdown with the Council's workforce when they issued 30,000 redundancy notices.

Hatton's reaction to the hostility received for his so-called "tacDerek Hatton tical withdrawal" enlightens us of the Militant's own concept of capturing power and institutionalising socialism through the state. "If government recognises its responsibility then all notices will be withdrawn" , said a letter signed by Hatton to 31,000 workers, making it clear that this was not a question of rank and file activity and grass roots organisation, but one of deals in which people's livelihoods were being barterea.

Hatton complained that shop stewards "actually took over and brought work to a standstill Because the trade unions were unprepared to follow Hatton and the Militant in their attempt to use power within the framework of Tory legislation, ie. to make redundancies, Hatton categorically states, "I despise and hate them for what they did... The greatest obstacle to socialism is the leadership of the trade union movement."

Hatton is clearly a creature of the Militant, but it becomes obvious from the book that there were tensions between Militant and Hatton; the Militant complained of Hatton "playing a personality game". Hatton makes clear that life on the breadline because of commitment to ideas "is something I would never do myself". Instead Hatton lists his home, his "attractive wife" , his holidays, his nice car, good clothes and good food as his priorities.

Hatton was in conflict with shop stewards in Militant during the redundancy period. Finally, Hatton gives us an account of a discussion with Peter Taffe when he gave his decision to resign as Deputy Leader, in which Hatton seems almost unaware of the relief he describes in Taffe's words: "for the sake of the labour movement and the sake of socialism in the future he said it was important that the Labour Party was not denuded of good quality lefts to continue the fight".

And what of socialism as we think of it? As a democratic movement of the oppressed and exploited for liberation? The Sam Bond affair throws the most appalling light on such a notion. Bond was appointed as Race Relations Officer because "he took the Militant view of race relations" and Hatton glibly states that "those who accepted views without question" were promoted.

In Today (1 July) Hatton said *There is no real alternative to the Tories... Whether I would be physically able to pick up a pencil and put a cross against a Tory name, I'm not sure. But in principle, that's what I'd have to say."

Having decided that the labour movement won't give him more fame and fortune, he looks elsewhere.

Hatton's history tells us as much about Militant as about Hatton himself. Militant has still not denounced him, and it has chosen to defend Hatton against police proceedings for corruption since he left Labour (and Militant) politics. Maybe Hatton still gives Militant money - I don't know.

Throughout 1983-6, Militant rallied behind Hatton, defended him, and denounced all criticism of him. They let their better judgement - which conflicted with Hatton — be swamped by the desire for position and prestige. They shared one crucial idea with Hatton - the programme of socialism from above, or socialism by decree of benevolent administrators.

Scan page 13

Organiser

----- pull-quotes -----

ing "fired with political ambition" Then made me realise that I

"The strategy to stay within law and to delay."

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 492

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →