Marxism versus "hit or miss
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-07-18Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 12
Jill Mountford look classic of our move men James P. Cannon's Let from Prison n 1941 28 American erade unionists were charged with disrupting the war effort and later imprisoned for between 12 and 16 months.
Among those jailed were the leaders of the American Socialist Workers Party (SWP: no relation to the British SWP), and militants from the Teamsters (truck drivers') Union.
The trial lasted six months. SWP leader James P Cannon used his evidence for the defence to explain the Marxist view on the war, socialism and democracy. His speech was later reproduced in book form under the title socialism on Trial and still serves as a useful text for revolutionaries today.
After two years of appeals, our American comrades started their sentences on 1 January 1944.
Letters from Prison is a record of Cannon's time at Sandstone Jail and, more importantly, a living dialogue with the party outside on the tasks of building a revolutionary organisation.
At the forefront of Cannon's mind was the overall project of the revolutionary party. Not losing sight of this, he developed straightforward solutions to organisational questions in his letters to Rose Karsner, his comrade and partner.
The letters also describe how Cannon tried to use his time in jail. He set himself a rigorous and gruelling regime.
He was not a professional intellectual, and had little formal education; but he set about learning three languages and systematically worked his way through Greek and French philosophy!
Cannon's greatest contribution to our revolutionary movement was his ability to work through and elaborate the organisational side of the Leninist party. Hoduction, pian for the pany s is letters called for an extensive membership:
"It is the historic task of the parly to bring the element of consciousness into the spontaneous labour movement. The party, that is, the continuing organisation of the vanguard, grows up to this task to the extent that it succeeds in introducing consciousness and plan into all phases of its own work.
*This takes place not automatically, but slowiy and painfully as the party grows and learns from its mistakes and difficulties and gradually, in a long process of work and struggle, throws up a leadership which understands its tasks and knows how to plan and organise their study and execution."
Cannon stresses the importance of training and developing comrades as opposed to some *hit or miss method" . He says it is "to make a revolutionary step forward by systematically planning and organising the continuing education of the party membership as a whole, from the newest recruit to the members of the leading committees.
...The plan, viewed as a whole, contemplates not a single school but rather a system of schools and study courses - a communist university."
Cannon's letters aim to convince, to create an atmosphere and an attitude in the party that would inspire young comrades to take their studies seriously.
He seems conscious, too, of the usefulness of his letters for future revolutionaries.
His letters are still inspiring today, impressing on our minds the necessity of a Marxist education, encouraging us, tempting us, reminding us why we need a radically different education to the bourgeois education forced upon us.
He deliberately leads the reader to the conclusion that to be without a Marxist education is to be unarmed, unprepared and unable to take the working class forward. Cio the role of the revolutione annon also gave much thought Mary newspaper. The Militant James P. Cannon (the paper of the SWP — no relation to the British Militant) started out as a "cadre organ" . It was theoretically heavy and limited to a small audience of advanced Marxists.
As the war dragged to its end, however, the SWP's position as the only group clearly championing working-class struggle was winning it much wider support. The Militant could take on a new role.
Cannon saw the revolutionary paper as a tool, and not as a static tool, always serving the same purpose. It was a tool that not only helped to change and clarity the consciousness of workers, but can itself be changed and clarified. Cannon redefined the paper as a "combination tool". He explained:
"We can only afford to publish our paper. And we must address ourselves to the politically educated as well as to the uninitiated... We must publish a paper for them all.
"Most important of all, we must bear in mind that the new reader does not remain a new reader all his life. The average intelligent worker quickly absorbs the few simple ideas which attracted him to the paper in the first place. Then he begins to feel the need of more substantial food."
In his last letter (no.182) sums up simply and wholly a task of all revolutionaries: "Our great-mission, I take it, is to popularise unadulterated Marxism." One of the most important ways of doing this is through the revolutionary newspaper. The "combination tool" is designed to reach the widest possible audience, and to help that audience learn, change and develop.
n one of his letters Cannon talks of the need for heroes in our movement. "The young relate the word to the deed. They are moved and inspired by example. That is why the young demand heroes; nobody can talk them out of it."
For us today, Cannon himself is one such hero. For him, revolutionary politics was no hobby or passing phase, but a way of life, one he stuck to from a teenager untii his death in 1974 at the age of 84, despite all the disappointments and sebacks along the road.
Ironically, I want to give the last word to Jack Barnes. Ironically, because since writing the introduction to Letters from Prison Barnes (the central leader of the American SWP today has become a renegade, unforgiveably subordinating the SWP to stalinist torces such as the North Korean government, unable to stick to "unadulterated Marxism" in face of the apparent power of the Stalinist world. But when he wrote his introduction Barnes knew how to explain the task that he would later shirk:
"Giants and geniuses in the short history of the modern revolutionary movement are rare, but the march of history does not require each of us to be one, nor to wait for one to come along. Letters from Prison does not challenge each of us to be a Marx, a Lenin or a Trotsky.
*We are simply challenged to be ourselves, to study what went on before and to apply the discoveries of our predecessors to the problems of our time. By standing on the shoulders of earlier working class fighters...Marxists as a team of revolutionaries can accomplish the task before them."