Smokescreens and scarecrows
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-07-18Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →
6 Nov 2026, after a reader report: printed under the strap 'Debate on the US "Politically Correct" movement'. No 'By' line is printed; the standfirst names the writer, US activist Robin Templeton. The machine reading had run in the boxed article beside it, Castro, si! Lenin and Trotsky, no!, and credited its by-line to this one. Transcribed from the scan of page 11; the pull-quote is left out. 'federalise virtue”..' and 'underly' are as printed.
Proofed text: read against the scan word by word; spelling, punctuation and wording are as printed.
Scan page 11
US university campuses are torn with battles over what has been tagged “Political Correctness”. Some say that what’s involved is a drive to broaden academic courses and counter racism and sexism; others, that it involves efforts to regulate language which are ludicrous or counter-productive, stifling real debate. Two articles continue the debate — one from Allison Roche (below) and this one from US activist Robin Templeton.
George Bush began slithering down his 1992 presidential campaign trail this spring in a series of commencement speeches that were designed to bash civil rights and promote free enterprise.
On 4 May at the University of Michigan, for example, Bush praised America’s “egalitarian system”, “built upon the foundations of private property” and attacked supporters of affirmative action and welfare programmes, saying that “when governments try to improve on freedom — they fail” because “we cannot federalise virtue”..
In the same address, Bush fired his rhetoric at the “notion of political correctness”, complaining that while “the [PC] movement arises from the laudable desire to sweep away the debris of racism and sexism and hatred”, it has resulted in “political extremists roam[ing] the land, abusing the privilege of free speech, setting citizens against one another on the basis of class and race”.
The notions that racism and sexism are mere “debris” and that free speech is a “privilege” underly Bush’s unfounded assertion that a so-called “PC movement” currently poses a threat to free speech (or free enterprise, the President often uses the terms interchangeably) in the United States. Bush’s attack on the so-called “PC movement” is part of a right-wing backlash against real struggles for equal rights and justice in the US, which are otherwise referred to by the right as anti-Americanism.
In his commencement address, Bush joins with political pundits who have for months now been saturating the mainstream media with harrowing accounts of “political correctness”, also labelled “Marxism without the economics”, “liberal fascism”, “thought policing” and “left McCarthyism”. Such caricatures of college campuses and the left in general are drawn as a smokescreen to hide real and deep rooted social, economic and educational problems that are a direct result of ten years of Reagan/Bush policy.
Demystification of “political correctness” is in order. Socialist Organiser’s Jim Denham, for instance, describes the supposed US “PC movement” as “linguistic Stalinism” (SO 488) without addressing the pertinent political issues behind the PC hype.
According to Denham, PC involves “reducing multi-culturalism to an absolute ‘relativism’...purging reading lists, limiting free speech, and hounding ‘incorrect academics’.” These claims, however, presume that those who are being most deliberately and relentlessly hit with the PC charge hold institutional power.
PC is used by Bush and the right as a codeword to discredit the civil rights community in attempt to render it effectively powerless. While it is true that certain segments of the academic establishment deserve PC-bashing because of their post-modern, deconstructionist theories that are forever divorced from practice, the attack on PC is really aimed at those who demand real cultural diversity and equality.
Historically, those who have fought hardest for multi-culturalism are people of colour, women, lesbians and gays; it is we who have been excluded from the curriculum and essentially written out of history. The movement for multi-culturalism grew out of the Civil Rights and Vietnam anti-war eras and it is the potential for such a movement to join forces with present day civil rights and anti-war struggles that has those in power dedicated to eliminating the “PC enemy”.
It is no coincidence that the attack on PC developed in conjunction with the Gulf War, when campuses nationwide were decrying US militarism abroad and calling attention to domestic problems of poverty and racism.
Because Denham quotes the former radical social critic Eugene Genovese’s attack on PC, I am compelled to do likewise. In a recent issue of the New Republic, Genovese refers to student activists who demonstrate for multi-cultural programmes as “terrorists” and “stormtroopers” and he encourages university administrators not to negotiate with them. Genovese, a former Marxist, condemns “sensitivity” when it comes to approaching issues of race and gender and suggests to his readers that, “like loving parents, we must accept the disagreeable duty to inflict excruciating pain on ourselves by whipping our errant children for their own good” and he urges an “all out counter-attack” against activists.
As for Denham’s assertion that “the highest achievements of art, literature, science, history and philosophy that we have on record [sic] tend to be the work of DWEMs”, this is true only in that the “records” have been written and controlled by dead white European males.
Multi-culturalism calls for the inclusion of perspectives and voices formerly excluded from the curriculum and barred from full participation in the power structure. The extent to which such inclusion poses a threat to Bush and company’s new world order is the extent to which multi-culturalism is branded “political correctness” and attacked by the right.