Marxists and democracy
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-07-18Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
*The Au 13e in sooner and not fater because: "The majority of the programme of the vanguard party Petrograd" elections Borough people is with us. This has been proven by the long can be realised I only with the support of the majoriDumas in Moscow in September"... "The new and difficult read from Mav 19 to Amoust 12 and ty. The party's basic task, while it remains in the Peasants" Soviets" who had "expressed their op capitals is the result of the people's progress to our jority". tIMn people are following and will follow the Bolsheviks The prosecution at the Minneapolis trial attemp& poe main disasto wing vier and Kamenere in munist Current. exist conspiracy is Blancuism t it is not refuted this accusation, and the indictment cover- aution situation in general and the international situation this absurd charge against our small party was our in particular; if the party in question does not en- exposition of the democratic basis of the pro- of proclaiming 25-27 Lenin called upon the responding obligation, while it remains in the ter, addressed to "the Central Committee, the In making this exposition we had a legal pur- malistic and rigid in their thinking on general Social-Democratic Labour Partv . Lenin, with the with all the testimony, it was designed primarily to thus parted company with Trotsky. note and tirea mece explain and simplify our views and aims to political sentence: obtained a maiority in the published court record.
thought a restatement of the Marxist Blanguism was an early form of revolutionary the Bolheriks can and must take power position in this respect would not be wasted on the 'no revolution ever waits for this" But he was question only proves that we were more correct in for the workers. From centre pages coalition"... The "Finally, the revolt of the peasantry"
his polemic against Zinovier and Kamenev:
organisers have not reckoned with the political joy the sympathy of the majority of the people, as prover o deste aoss Bolsehvik party to take power. In this famous letPetrograd and Moscow Committees of the Russian states his premise and his conclusion in the first Soviets of Workers and Soldiers' Deputies of both He was t worried about a "formal" majority: sure of the real majority. He insisted upon the revolution "right now", as he expressed it, of the September 25: the majority in the Soviets in the vacillation the Mensheviks. and the елин TEETELCE proof of the same thing." ed to convict us, as charged in the indictment, of torce ama volencend we success u majority to realise is programme, and its cor would be future readers of Socialism is a democratic movement and its proSocialist- rejudices of the jury; it is the teaching of Mar Grandizo Munis was a Spanish Trotskyist who Oehlerites were an ex-trotskyist faction in the os leu Dy augo vener. ey made & principie matter how small its numbers and support, and of counterposing it as a supposedly finished in everything else. Essentially To se who were extremerto political questions as well as on the party, and ancestors of organisations like the WRP and nspiratorial minority who would seize power off as utterly "pro-imperialist" and "Zionist" • So they are, in SWP terms! The SWP have written off a whole people, believing that they are capable of no progressive action, and that they deserve nothing but subjugation.
The Israeli Jews are a bad people and the SWP pick on them as the only people in the world unworthy of a state. What is this if not a form of anti-semitism?
The national conflicts in the Middle East. demand a democratic resolution, which recognises the rights of both Israeli Jews and the Palestinians. The Palestinians have been terribly oppressed. They have a right to a state of their own. Socialists support them in this demand and back them in their strug gle against anti-Arab discrimination within Israel itself.
But it makes no sense to achieve an end to the national oppression of the Palestinians by depriving Israeli Jews of their national rights and thus creating a new oppressed nationality in the Middle East or in an Israeli diaspora.
Two states is not an alternative to socialism. It is a way to help break down national antagonisms in the Middle East and lay the basis for joint struggles between Israeli and Arab workers. Without that socialism cannot be achieved in the Middle East. All the rest is demagogic populist waffle.
Scan page 11
Socialist Organiser No. 492