Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Smash Israel?

Socialist Organiser no. 492, 18 July 1991 · scan p. 10 · about 1,269 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

Sopressed Pale rio people, ocialist Organiser supports | the we support the PLO's policy of a two-state solution to the current. Israeli-Palestinian conflict. The Jews, too, have rights. Two peoples, two states!

Recognition of the national rights of both the Palestinians and the Israeli Jews is a precondition for working class unity in the area. It is a bedrock part of any socialist policy.

It is the only way forward now; it would still be the only way forward if the working class ruled in the Middle East.

You don't have to have been around long on the left to know that we are widely detested and reviled for this policy. This year, once again, our position on this question was made the excuse for excluding Socialist Organiser supporters from the SWP's annual jamboree. "Marxism '91" they call it! An old Russian proverb said it well: "Paper is patient, it will let anything at all be written on it!"

Most conventional "left" wisdoms about Zionism have little or nothing to do with historical reality.

«"The 'democratic secular state' slogan... implies a new bloody Middle East war, plays into the hands of the Israeli right, aligns Palestinians with states such as Saddam's Iraq".

Historical Zionism is equated with the politics of Herzl and Jabotinsky (the prophet of Israel's present-day right wing), rather than recognised as the very broad movement of millions of oppressed Jews that it was. The left-wing currents in it, such as Ber Borochov, Poale Zion or the Russian Zionists who fought with the Red Army at the time of the Russian revolution are ignored, dismissed or lied about. gnoring and denying the record of those Zionists who actively fought the Nazis in the 1930s and 1940s, most of the far left in Britain now increasingly adheres to the poisonous myth of systematic Zionist-Nazi collaboration. Zionists and Nazis are often depicted now as twins. The origin of this idea in Stalinist USSR propaganda does not deter the "Trotskyist" left from purveying this nonsense. Zionists are portrayed as cunning and cold-hearted conspirators, ready to sacrifice six million Jews if it helped achieve a Jewish state in the Middle East. How killing two thirds of the Jews of Europe could help them achieve Israel is one of the great mysteries at the heart of this crazy rigmarole.

The Israeli Jewish Hebrew speaking people are a distinct group on a distinct territory. They are a nation and like any other nation are entitled to self-determination. The equation which most of the "left" make between the Israeli Jews and the white South Africans is absurd.

The equation between the white South Africans and the Israeli Jews is an ideological lie constructed by the pseudo-left to justify the "smashing" of Israel. South African whites do not exist as a majority on a particular piece of land. South African whites are a small elite who are privileged because of exploitation of a much larger black working class. The Arab labour force in Israel is smaller than the Jewish. The analogy falls Socialist Organiser is opposed to the Israeli government's oppressing of the Palestinians. But Israeli government policy - however horrible - does not and cannot cancel out the Israeli people's national rights. Just like any other nation the Israeli Jews will rightly fight to keep their right to self-determination.

The call for a so-called single "democratic secular state" means forcibly depriving the Israeli Jews of their national rights. Since Israel will not dissolve itself into an Arab state, the "democratic secular state" must mean the conquest (presumably by Arab armies) of Israel. So the policy of — for example — the SWP implies a new bloody Middle East war which will result in the replacement of Palestinian oppression with the denial of national rights and oppression of the Jews! This is not "democratic" and the resulting Arab state is unlikely to be secular.

In the existing relations of military power in the region, it is simply crazy. The insistence of the Palestinian leadership on nothing less than the end of Israel has been one factor in their impotence for so long. It plays into the hands of the expansionist Israeli right and it aligns the Palestinians with such an awful Middle East militarist state as Saddam Hussein's Iraqsrael was not "set up by imperialism".

The big impulse behind the growth of the Zionist movement and the creation of Israel itself was Hitler's Holocaust of six million Jews. The Zionist movement took Israeli troops in the West Bank help from wherever it could. They took weapons • from the Stalinist stooge government in Czechoslovakia, for instance.

Nor is the Israeli government simply a "watch dog" or "out post" of imperialism. The Israeli government has its own interests which sometimes bring it into conflict with the US.

'Often the left uses 'Zionism' to finger Jews. 'Zionist is inserted where the word 'Jew would be seen for what it is, a form of anti-semitism. The left hides behind the transparent fiction, 'we're not anti-semitic, we're anti-Zionist. Fiction? The result is the same: comprehensive hostility Jews."

Not the least of the crimes of professional muddleheads like the SWP is that they lose sight of the fact that it is the Arab bourgeoisie which is the real prop of imperialism in the region — the bourgeoisie which they would support if it had the power to destroy the Jewish state!

Whether "Zionism" today has any meaning is open to debate - the Zionist project and its defining feature was to achieve a Jewish national homeland. That project was accomplished over 40 years ago.

However, most of the far left use the expression as a negative buzz word and general term of abuse for political opponents who support national rights for Israeli Jews. The left's conception of Zionism today is inseparable from its ahistorical analysis of Zionism, and its refusal to support național rights for Israeli Jews today.

Often the left uses "Zionism" to finger Jews. "Zionist" is inserted where the word "Jew" would be seen for what it is, a form of anti-semitism. The left hides behind the transparent fiction, "we're not anti-semitic, we are anti-Zionist". Fiction? The result is the same: comprehensive hostility to Jews.

Anti-semitism has had many forms, from A the "Jews killed Christ" Christianinfluenced anti-semitism, to Hitler's zoological racism, to the "anti-Zionist" campaigns of Stalin.

Yet, some anti-semitic themes keep recurring: Jewish "conspiracy" , for example. The left has developed its own version of a Zionist conspiracy theory of the creation of Israel: (Or, rather, taken over the Stalinist "theory").

In all anti-semitisms there is the comprehensive hatred of Jews. Sometimes it is implacable, blood-lusting hatred; sometimes conditional: like the Christians who "only" wanted to convert the Jews, "left wing" antisemitism "only" wants Jews - whose modern identity has been reformed after Hitler around Israel - to support the destruction of Israel. This, of course, is not racism. No...

"Zionism" and the "Zionists" are now a special category of people to loathe. So because most Jews are Zionist, the left finds itself loathing almost all Jews. There is no separation of the identification with Israel and the rights of the Jews (Zionism) and support for Israeli government policies.

For instance, after the Lebanon war of 1982 the Israeli army did not stop the murder of Palestinians by Lebanon's Christian army in the Sabra and Chatila refugee camps on the outskirts of Beirut. Inside Israel the peace movement organised a (perhaps) 400,000 strong demonstration (the British equivalent is something like 6,000,000). Most of these demonstrators the SWP would write

----- pull-quotes -----

LE: POLITICAL FRONT

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 492

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →