Defend and extend de
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-07-18Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 8
to transfer power from one clique to another, but a movement of the majority in the interest of the majority.
In addition, it may as well be said candidly that this testimony was also deliberately designed as an educational shock to such members and sympathisers of our movement as may still, at this late day, be dabThe Marxist authorities have all spoken in one voice on this question. The Communist Manifesto, the first, and the most fundamenta statement of the principles of scientific socialism, defined the proletarian movement of emancipation, in contradistinction to all others in history, as follows:
"All previous historical movements were movements of the minorities, or in the interests of minorities. The proletarian movement is the self-conscious, independent movement of the immense majority, in the interest of the imLeon Trotsky insisted that the fight for democracy was essential to the fight-for socialism. This excerpt is from 'An Action Programme for France', 1934 s long as the majority of A the working class continues on the basis of bourgeois democracy, we are ready to defend it with all our forces against violent attacks from the Bonapartist and fascist bourgeoisie.
However, we demand from our class brothers who adhere to "democratic" socialism that they be faithful to their ideas, that they draw inspiration from the ideas and methods not of the Third Republic but of the Convention of 1793.
Down with the Senate, which is elected by limited suffrage, and which renders the power of universal suffrage a mere illusion!
Down with the presidency of the republic, which serves as a hidden point of concentration for the forces of militarism and reaction!
A single assembly must combine the legislative and executive powers Members would be elected for two years, by universal suffrage at eighteen years of age, with m discrimination of sex or nationality: Deputies would be elected on th basis of local assemblies, s revocable by their constituents, would receive the salary of arti worker.
This is the only meas would lead the masses fam stead of pushing them ba more generous democra
Scan page 9
democracy "action" only when they felt assured of the support of the majority.
What did they do in the meantime? They "submitted to the majority". What else could they do? Lenin explained it a hundred times, precisely in those months and days when the Bolsheviks were consciously preparing the struggle for power. In his April Theses on The Tasks of the Proletariat in the Present Revolution, published in Pravda on April 20, 1917, a few days after his return to Russia, Lenin wrote: "As long as we are in the minority we carry on the work of criticising and exposing errors and at the same time advocate the necessity of transferring the entire power of state to the Soviets of ocracy in Trotsky •sitate the struggle for le want to attain our by armed conflicts be Workers' Deputies, so that the masses may by experience overcome their mistakes." -A few days later, he returned to this question, explaining the reason for this attitude, the reason being that "we are not Blanquists, we are Marxists". On April 22 he wrote: "In order to obtain the power of state the class conscious workers must win the majority to their side. As long as no violence is used against the masses, there is no other road to power. We are not Blanquists, we are not in favour of the seizure of power by a minority. We are Marxists, we stand for a proletarian class struggle against chauvinist defencism, phrases and dependence on the bourgeoisie."
Not once or twice, but repeatedly various groups of toilers, but by real workers' democracy, by propaganda and loyal criticism, by the voluntary regrouping of the great majority of the proletariat under the flag of true communism.
Workers adhering to democratic socialism must further understand that it is not enough to defend democracy; democracy must be regained.
The moving of the political centre of gravity from parliament towards the cabinet, from the cabinet towards the oligarchy of finance capital, generals, police, is an accomplished fact. Neither the present parliament nor the new elections can change this.
We can defend the sorry remains of democracy, and especially we can enlarge the democratic arena for the activity of the masses, only by annihilating the armed fascist forces that, on 6 February 1934, started moving the axis of the state and are still doing so. and almost continually, so that neither friend nor foe could possibly misunderstand him, in the months directly preceding the October Revolution, Lenin limited the Bolshevik task to the propaganda work of "criticising" "exposing errors", ; "advocating" in order to "win the majority to their side" This was not camouflage for the enemy but education for the workers' vanguard. He explained it theoretically as we, following him, tried to explain it in popular language at the trial.
Again, in April 1917, refuting the accusations of Plekhanov and others who accused the Bolsheviks of "anarchism, Blanquism and so forth" , Lenin once again explained the question, for the benefit, as he said, of "those who really want to think and learn". Into a few paragraphs he compresses a profound thesis which every member of the workers' vanguard ought to learn by heart. He wrote: "1 abSeptember 16, 1973. President Allende of Chile leaves the presidential palace — machine gun in hand - to face his executioners. The Daily Telegraph commented at the time: "President Allende of Chile, the world's first democratically elected Marxist head of state, solutely insured myself in my theses against skipping over the still existing peasant movement, or the petty bourgeois movement in general, against any playing at "seizure of power' by a workers' government, against any kind of Blanquist adventurism; for l dırectly referred to the experience of the Paris Commune. And this experience, as we know, and as was shown in detail by Marx in 1871 and by Engels in 1891, absolutely excluded Blanquism, absolutely ensured the direct, immediate, and unconditional rule of the maiority and the activity of the masses, but only to the extent of the conscious and intelligent action of the majority itself.
*In the theses I definitely reduced the question to one of a struggle for influence within the Soviets of Workers', Agricultural Labourers', Soldiers' and Peasants' Deputies. In order to leave no trace of doubt in this respect, 1 twice emphasised in the theses the necessity for patient and persistent "explanatory' work 'adapted to the practical needs of the masses'. Ignorant persons or renegades from Marxism, such as Mr Plekhanov, may cry anarchism, Blanquism, and so forth. But those who really want to think and learn cannot fail to understand that Blanquism means the seizure of power by a minority, Agricultural Labourers', Soldiers' whereas the Soviet of Workers' and Peasants' Deputies and admittedly the direct and immediate organisation of the majority of the people.
Work confined to a struggle for influence within these Soviets cannot, absolutely cannot, blunder into the swamp of Blanquism. Nor can it blunder into the swamp of anarchism, for anarchism denies the necessity for a state and for state power in the period of transition from the rule of the bourgoisie to the rule of the proletariat, whereas I, with a precision that excludes all possibility of misunderstanding, insist on the necessity for a state in this period, although, in accordance with Marx and the experience of the Paris Commune, not the usual parliamentary bourgeois state, but a state without a standing army, without a police opposed to the people, without an officialdom placed above the people"
Again explaining wherein "Marxism differs from Blanquism" - he obviously considered it absolutely necessary for the advanced workers to understand this so as to be sure of their ground at every step — he wrote in a ietter to the Centrai Committee of the September 26-27, 1917:
*To be successful, the uprising must be based not on a conspiracy, not on a party, but on the advanced class. This is the first point. The uprising must be based on the revolutionary upsurge of the people. This is the second point. The uprising must be based on the crucial point in the history of the maturing revolution, when the activity of the vanguard of the people is at its height, when the vacillations in the ranks of the enemies, and in the ranks of the weak, half-hearted, undecided friends of the revolution are at their highest point. This is the third point. It is in pointing out The time of surprise attacks, of revolutions carried through by sma conscious minorities at the head of the unconscious masses past".
these three conditions as the way of approaching the question of an uprising, that Marxism differs from Blanquism."
Naturally, when Lenin, or any other Marxist, spoke of the necessity of the revolutionary party having the support of the majority, he meant the real majority, whose sentiments are ascertainable in various ways besides the ballot box of the bourgeois state. On the eve of the insurrection he wrote his devastating attack on Zinoviev and Kamenev who opposed the insurrection on the ground, among other things, that "we do not enjoy a majority among the people, and in the absence of that condition insurrecton is hopeless"
Lenin, in "A Letter to the Comrades" , written on October 29-30, scornfully dismisses the authors of this statement as "either distorters of the truth or pedants who desire at all costs, without the slightest regard for the true circumstances of the revolution, to have a guarantee in advance that the Bolshevik Party throughout the country has received exactly one half the number of votes plus one". Nevertheless, he took pains to prove the Bolsheviks had the majority by "facts". Turn to page 10 died today during a military coup which overthrew his government. The revolt, led by commandos of the armed forces and the paramilitary police, marked the climax of three years of opposition from the political right and centre to the government." party Engels
Scan page 10
Organiser An "anti-Zionist"' blind alle ERSPECTIVE
----- pull-quotes -----
bling with the idea of a shorter cut tore scription for action" mysterious