Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Marxism and

Socialist Organiser no. 492, 18 July 1991 · scan p. 8 · about 1,089 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 8

Yet again the "soft left" are glossing up a witch-hunt by claiming that they stand for "democratic socialism" against Marxism. The truth is that they adhere to the formalities and limitations of existing Westminster democracy - as a bulwark against working-class action - whereas Marxists advocate the widest democracy, both as part of our struggle for socialism and as part of socialism itself. This article from the 1940s by veteran American Marxist James Socialist Organiser Price £2 plus 38 pence p&p. Make cheques/ postal orders payable to Socialist Organiser Available from PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA.

Comrade Munis! is tions at the trial that "we submit to the majority". The Ochlerites also are scornful of this declaration and represent it as some kind of capitulatory repudiation of our principles in order to impress the jury. All of these assumptions are without foundation.

Our "submission to the majority" was not first revealed at the trial. We said it before the trial and continue to repeat it after the trial. It is a correct statement of our position because it conforms both to reality and necessity. Moreover, our Marxist teachers said it before us; we learned it from them.

What else can we do but "submit to the majority" if we are Marxists and not Blanquists? or anarchist muddle-heads? It is a timely question because we believe any illconsidered talk about some kind of mysterious "action" presumed to be open to us while we remain not only a minority but a very small, numerically insignificant minority, can lead only to a dangerous disorientation of the party!

An exposition of the Marxist position on this question can also be useful as an antidote for any remnants of the half-Blanquist tradition of the early years of the Comintern in America.

The pioneer communists in the United States (and not only here) heard of the Bolshevik victory in Russia long before they learned about the political method and propaganda techniques whereby the Bolsheviks gained the mass support which made the seizure of power possible. Their first impressions were undoubtedly coloured by the capitalist press accounts which represented the revolution as a coup Cannon explains our basic views.

d'etat engineered by a small group.

This distorted conception was epitomised by the title given to the American edition of Trotsky's classic pamphlet, Terrorism and Communism, which was published here by the party's publishing house in 1922 under the completely misleading title Dictatorship versus Democracy. We took the "dictatorship", so to speak, and generously handed over to the bourgeoisie all From James P Cannon's reply to those who criticised his defence speech - when on trial for disrupting the US war effort in World War 2 as capitulation to bourgeois democracy. claim to "democracy".

This was far too big a concession, perhaps pardonable in a young movement lacking adequate knowledge about the democratic essence of the Bolshevik programme, but by far out of date today.

The bourgeoisie have always tried to picture communism as a "criminal conspiracy" in order to alienate workers who are profoundly democratic in their sentiments. That was the aim once again in the Minneapolis trial. It was our task at the trial to go out of our way to refute this misrepresentation and emphasise the democratic basis of our programme; not in order to placate Our enemies and persecutors, as is assumed, but in order to reveal the truth to our friends, the American workers.

We cannot eat our cake and have it too. We must either "submit" to the majority and confine ourselves to propaganda designed to win over the majority — or, we must seize power and break the neck of the party, by minority "action"

Marxist authority is clear and conclusive in choosing between these alternatives. When we took our stand in court regarding "submission" to the majority we were not "folding our arms" and making "opportunistic" statements of "passivity in the face of imperialist war" as we are accused. Nothing of the sort. The testimony states, repeatedly, and with sufficient emphasis, The majorily, - that is, making to minority insurrections or putsches - we are organising, speaking, writing and explaining; in other words, carrying on propaganda with the object of winning over the majority to our programme which is the programme of social revolution.

Neither were we simply trying to "make an honourable impression on the jury without taking into consideration that we should talk for the masses". To be sure, we did not stupidly disregard the jury which held the fate of 28 comrades, not to nention the legality of the party, ir its hands. But we were speaking also, and especially, "for the masses"

We testified primarily for publication. It was our deliberate aim to convince those who would read the testimony in printed form of the truth that the proletarian movement which we aspire to lead is a democratic movement, and not a "conspiracy" as the prosecutor and the whole of the capitalist press would picture it, and as loose talkers would unconsciously aid them to so picture it; not a scheme The Russian revolution: a ma ajority revolution mense majority."

The communist polit ical method and strategy follow ineluctably from this basic premis e. Nowhere and never have the a luthoritative representatives of Ma arxism formulated the question otherwise. The Marxists aim to ma ke the social transformation with th he majority and not for the major ity. The irreconcilable struggle ol f Marx and Engels against the Blanquists revolved around this pi vot.

In 1895, summing up the experience of 50 years, El ngels wrote, in his Introduction to N Marx's Class Struggles in France: *7 The time of surprise attacks, of reso lutions carried through by smal 1 conscious minorities at the head of the unconscious masses is past • Where it is a question of a complete transformation of the social organisation, the masses themselves must also be in it, must themselves already have grasped what is at stake, what they are going in for, body and soul. The history of the last 50 years has taught us that."

The successors of Marx and Engels followed in their footsteps. The experiences of the Russian revolution confirmed in life the basic premises of the founders of scientific socialism. It was precisely because Lenin and Trotsky had assimilated this concept into their flesh and blood that they knew how to concentrate their whole activity on propaganda to win over the majority, biding their time till they gained the majority and resorting to

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 492

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →