Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

[tricians had not prospered since their expulsion from…]

Socialist Organiser no. 492, 18 July 1991 · scan p. 4 · Sean Matgamna · about 1,765 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 4

tricians had not prospered since their expulsion from the TUC in 1988 and the grand designs for a new union confederation had attracted only a pathetic rag-bag of small. managerial and professional bodies. Eric Hammond was making conciliatory noises about "building bridges" back to the TUC. Most importantly of all, Hammond could argue with some justice that his version of business-unionism (no-strike deals and all) more or less It all made sense at the time, especially as Danny Carrigan (an EETPU national official and very much part o the union machine) was opposing Hammond's chosen successor, Paul Gallagher, on an openly pro-TUC platNow, all those straws in the wind seem to have been blown off course, and the electricians' return to the fold looks as unlikely (or at least, far off) as ever. The main reason for this is the electricians' sheer greed for members at the expense of other unions: they can't resist a spot of poaching, especially when it seems to be offere on a plate. So when the building union UCATT was thrown into crisis a couple of months ago, the EETPU had no hesitation in recruiting a dozen or so "rebel" UCATT officials and announcing the creation of an EETPU construction section. This move was bound to antagonise even the electricians' closest allies within the TUC, the AEU, who aren't particularly bothered about UCATT but who are concerned about their own substanSigning no-strike deals and crossing picket lines may be tolerable behaviour within today's go-ahead TUC, but poaching members definitely isn't. The Bridlington agreement remains sacrosanct (or more or less sacrosanct: in the words of AEU general secretary Gavin Laird, "we all of us, at times, poach: but if we are caught we obey the Thus it was that the Confederation of Shipbuilding and Engineering Unions (CSEU) voted last month to expel the EETPU if it does not rejoin the TUC by January 1993. The CSEU is the umbrella organisation representing two million engineering workers; the electricians were allowed to remain members after their expulsion from the TUC, mainly because the CSEU is dominated The anti-EETPU resolution was nominally occasioned by their poaching of GMB members at Vickers in Barrow and was strongly motivated by Roger Lyons of MSF and Charlie Kelly of UCATT. But it would never have been passed but for the abstention of the AEU, whose general secretary Gavin Laird even lectured the electricians about Meanwhile, Hammond's successor, Paul to 31,000 votes in a low poll) recently responded to the suggestion that recruiting UCATT members might further antagonise the TUC, with the memorable words, "Who gives a toss All of which would seem to rather rule out an early rapprochement between the TUC and the electricians. But you never can tell. Talks on amalgamation between the AEU and EETU are going ahead this month despite everything. Hopefully, the AEU rank and file will mobilise to stop any such amalgamation as they did in 1989. But the electricians' leaders have not given, up hope of creeping back into the fold via an amalgamation, despite their belligerent anti-TUC rhetoric. Meanwhile, I've decided to give up making any predictions.

hat leading BOISNI well, Walton was a intellectual, Mr Paul l big success, wasn't "Gazza" Gascoigne THE: UNIONS I it? Success? Yes, once said *I never make Paul Foot is certain of it. predictions and I never It all depends on how will". Wise words indeed. you look at it. I seem to remember that Start by remembering the earlier this year I con- worst socialist election fidently predicted the results imaginable, those of return of the EETPU to the SWP in 1977. Then forget all the special features the TUC fold, in the not- of the Walton by-election too-distant future. and imagine that this result There were good reasons By Sleeper can be achieved evenly for that prediction: the elec- everywhere in Britain.

Twenty-six hundred votes?

No, comrade, half a million!

This is Paul Foot in last week's Socialist Worker: "If the votes are seen as a hard core of people ready to fight the Tories and the Labour council, it looks good 2,600 fighters in Walton became TUC orthodoxy. probably means 15,000 in Liverpool and at least half million across the country.

That's not bad, not bad at. all."

Allright, then, let us preform. tend to believe Foot and talk electoralism, seriously.

If Foot is serious and not just whistling a happy tune to keep his spirits up, then he should think all this through to the logical conclusion: the SWP should start now to campaign for the creation of a left bloc (itself, Militant, and so on) to fight the general election in every constituency, or in some hundreds of constituencies anyway.

If there is this half million tial construction section. to be organised - and if "fighters" out there waiting they can be organised by an election campaign, a nationwide version of Mahmood's campaign - then Foot and his comrades who believe this should attempt to rules"). organise them. It is their socialist duty to try. Such united left campaigns have been done in France, in the *70s.

There are, I believe, an awful lot of people - and I guess they number millions, not Foot's half by the AEU. million — who are embittered at life in the Britain Thatcher built. People frustrated - knowingly, or otherwise — by Kinnock's belly-crawling mimicry of the Tories. A Labour Party willing to fight even for "working class morality". moderate reforms could have mobilised them against the Tories.

The left of the Labour Party could have mobilised them in the early '80s if it had used its local government positions as bases from anyway?" which to fight the Tories.

Militant mobilised a lot of them in Liverpool, only to do the Grand Old Duke of York on them, marching them up to the top of the hill and then down again. is against that record that the number of votes Mahmood got has to be measured.)

Could a left-wing antiETE Labour general election campaign in all constituer cies or in most get throug to such people, organise them, give them a focus, and weld them into a political force against the Tory-Labour-Liberal ly, and was done in Walton, then why not elsewhere?

Why don't the SWP now campaign with Militant and others to prepare a general left-wing slate for the general election. Perhaps the SWP will do this?

I'll give you odds that they won't! In this, as in many other questions, the leaders of the SWP don't believe what they are saying. They say things demagogically, for effect.

Why won't they? Because they know Walton, and Liverpool, are exceptions. Contrary to Foot's picture, political conditions in Walton are highly exceptional, and Foot is just waffling. Despite its record in control of the council, Militant does have a real base of support, and in the current conflicts around control of the council a big political issue.

The bad vote for Mahmood, which so impresses Paul Foot, was, in these comparatively favourable conditions, only achieved by massive canvassing with hundreds of people bussed in by the national Militant organisation. In a general election that effort could not be repeated in more than two or three constituencies, if that. cond choice to Labours either/or.

The SWP knows that call for a general anti-Labour vote in the election would completely destroy them in the trade union movement.

Of the disgruntled constituency a left campaign would appeal to, those who are not too alienated to vote, will in the main vote Labour.

These are the objecive reasons why such a course would not make sense, even if the condition of the far left made it a possibility, though, in fact, it is inconceivable that the organisations of the far left now could unite in such a campaign. (Militant would not even let the SWP canvass for them in Walton! But that is something the readers of the SWP are not mature enough for the manipulative gentry who run the SWP to tell them!)

The SWP might be willing - as in Walton — to accept Militant as good socialists, but it takes two to tango. for a left bloc to Since the existing left will not unite in such a campaign, the only sense in advocating such a campaign would be as a group-building exercise. (I offer the idea as a fraternal gift to Workers' Power and the WRP!

This is a good thing, in my opinion. Such a campaign, a generalised "Walton" , even if it could get Foot's half-million votes would do no good. For the left it would mean shunting itself further into a blind alley of illusion and irgle in the mass working-class movement.

Even if it could be justified as a means of regrouping the left, the regrouped left would be a radically miseducated, deeply sectarian left, selfghettoised. A bigger ghetto, but a ghetto nevertheless.

The recurring pattern in Britain in the last quarter century is a pattern of limited groups becoming. radicalised and cutting themselves off from the working class. The SWP is itself led by people who stopped thinking about real politics back in 1968, believing Labour could be written off (so, a member of the same organisation, did I, for a while). It is one reason why the British left has rendered itself into a grotesque toy town caricature of socialist politics.

The only electioneering the left should organise in the build up to the general election is a powerful independent campaign in support of the mass workers" party, the Labour Party. Unfortunately it is also the party of Kinnock? The best way to change that is to hell it displace the Tories and organise a serious left withir both the Labour Party and the trade unions.

"Socialists for Labour" makes more sense now than *Sectarians for joke candidates and displaced municipal bureaucrats"!

It occurs to me, rereading what I've written, that this is a debate with myself, a dialogue between what I know about the political world I operate in and powerful underlying fantasies and wishes. It is a heart-lifting idea that we might suddenly leap over where the socialist left is now into a different and better world!

But there is no fault wors in politics than to mistake wishes for realities. To change the world revolutionary politics must base itself on the world as it is.

Fantasy politics is passive politics: instead of rearrang

----- pull-quotes -----

AGAINST THE TIDE

"ff Foot is serious the SWP should campaign

stand in every constituency."

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 492

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →