Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Yugoslavia: poisoned by nationalism

Socialist Organiser no. 491, 10 July 1991 · scan p. 16 · Tony Brown · about 1,007 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 16 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 16

yugoslavia today resembles Humpty Dumpty. All the army's tanks and all the army's men won't put the coun try back together again.

Tito's 'socialist' federation established after the Second World War now looks like breaking into two or three pieces. It is most likely that Slovenia will become Europe's newest state and that the battle for Croatia will be fierce and ferocious. Already villages in eastern Croatia, where there are large concentrations of Serbs, are waging battles across fields and streets.

The collective political leadership established by Tito to succeed him, has been pushed aside by the Stalinist (and essentially Serbian) leadership of the Army. In reality the system of a revolving Presidency and balanced representation from each of the republics and autonomous regions reflected the weight of the competing nationalisms of the Balkans. From its inception Yugoslavia was a manufactured state with an uneasy alliance of, at times, hostile national groupings. It was thrown together at the end of the First World War, after the break-up of the Austro-Hungarian empire.

Yugoslavia came into being in 1918 but it was not called Yugoslavia until 1929. In 1941, the Nazis invaded Yugoslavia and were eventually defeated by Tito's partisans in 1945.

Later that year, Slovenia, Croatia, Serbia, Montenegro, Bosnia-Herzogovina and Macedonia formed the new 'federation of socialist republics' But the federation was always a precarious one held together by Tito's reputation and cult status (he was made President for life in 1974). Four constitutions were made between 1945 and 1974 in order to keep the country together.

Croatia and Slovenia, the former parts of the Austro-Hungarian empire, and the most westernised parts of the country, made repeated claims that they were subsidising the poorer southern republics.

When they declared their independence on 25 June this year, this was still foremost in their given reasons for leaving the state.

In fact the motor-force disruption was the upsurge of Serbian nationalism with its increasingly violent rhetoric in the mouth of Slobodan Milosevic. Milosevic aims to create a greater Serbia which would annex parts of eastern Croatia and Kosovo in the south. Kosovo was the scene of fighting two years ago. The early successes of Slovenia's militias and the desertion of troops from the federal army has demonstrated that the army is not reliable for putting down the secessionists. Now the fighting appears to be concentrating on Croatia where Serbs living there fear the consequences if Croatia secedes.

The problem of how different peoples can coexist together, which is destroying Yugoslavia now is, ot course, not only a Yugoslav problem. There are similar problems all over the globe. Yugoslavia, however, can be held up as a testtube example of what the 'national question' is.

The Croats, part of the defeated Austro-Hungarian empire, came under the sway of a state dominated by Serbs who were amongst the victors in World War One. They were oppressed In World War Two, the Germans set up a Croatian state. Within this there was a Serbian minority over a million strong. The Croat fascistnationalists oppressed them, forced them to convert to Catholicism from the Greek Orthodox Church, killing half of the entire Serbian population.

They were oppressed peoples, and they quickly became themselves oppressors. National egotism demands that national territorial claims and national. identity be asserted alike against both strong oppressors and weaker minorities within the claimed territories.

The presently much-abused Russian Bolsheviks addressed this problem — endemic to the Russian territories as to Eastern Europe -almost 80 years ago, and their conclusions provide the best programme yet for resolving general difficult national questions.

In 1913, the Bolshevik Central Committee declared that national peace was only possible "under a consistently and thoroughly democratic republican system of goverpment...' the constitution of which contains a fundamental law that prohibits any privileges whatsoever to any one nation and any encroachment whatsoever upon the rights of a national minority.

This particulary calls for wide regional autonomy and fully democratic local government, with the boundaries of the self-governing and autonomous regions determined by the local inhabitants themselves on the basis of their economic and social conditions, national make-up of the population etc." Where there is national and communal conflict, this is the only basis for peaceful co-existence - it is the only programme around which the workers of all the ethnic groups can unite across the old national antagonisms and despite them.

That this hasn't happened in Yugoslavia only serves to demonstrate that a time-bomb lies ticking away wherever one national grouping oppresses another.

There can be no positive outcome, no genuine move to socialism while worker fights worker on the basis of placing one national grouping's rights above another's.

Last December, ICI was fined £12 million by the European Commission for running a soda ash cartel.

During the last decade, ICI has been busy buying seed companies across the world ICI hopes to change wheat, corn and maize seeds genetically so that they are resistant to insects, fungus and drought. They even hope that the plants will not need artificial fertiliser.

This development could transform agriculture in the Third World. Yields would ncrease even on poor soil with little water. Of course ICI is not doing it to help the starving masses, but to gain a world seed monopoly - so that it can change world monopoly prices!

The fight between Hanson and ICI is not a fight between a bad capitalist and a good one. Both are bad. All capitalists are bad.

ICI is held up as a paragon of capitalist virtue. If it is, then it only goes to show how bad everybody else must be.

The unions are right to fight Hanson, to protect jobs, but their fight shouldn't be against one wolf. It should be against all wolves, ICI included.

E25 for a year; £13 for six months £5 for ten issues Send cheques, payable to SO, 823, London SE15 4NA.

Name..

Address...

Overseas rates (for a year): Europe E30; US $90, Australia A$120. Giro account number: 367 9624

----- pull-quotes -----

Subscribe Socialist Organiser

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 491

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →