Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Labour is not a class

Socialist Organiser no. 491, 10 July 1991 · scan p. 14 · about 1,046 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 14 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 14

Paul McGarry (Letters, SO 490) has made a useful contribution to explaining how SO sees the Labour Party to readers.

More people buy the paper at elections. So we need to make our descriptions of the Labour Party, as a capitalist party with a workers' base, quite clear.

But I think Paul was unclear when he wrote that it is Labour's organic trade union links that makes it a Labour is different from other parliamentary parties. Workers created it through their unions. But their desire for a class party hit up against the pro-capitalist managed to condemn both Liverpool NALGO and the Liverpool Black Caucus. Comrade Venton may well have legitimate criticism of both organisations, but the columns of the bourgeois press hardly seems the best place to air them.

The politics of Militant, however, are not really the key issue in the Walton bypolitics of the union leaders. So Labour was founded to argue a sort of mixture: for a working class government over a state and an economy still run by capitalists.

The Labour Party defends capitalism. Because a party is described by its programme it is a capitalist party; not a workers' party, not a bit of both.

For us Labour is different frem other parties because most thinking workers support Labour as a way of getting a working class government. If that was still the case, our attitude towards the Labour Party would be the same even if it lost its organic links to the trade unions.

Revolutionary Marxists argue that the Labour government will act for the election, as you admit yourself when noting that the decision of the Liverpool Broad Left to oppose Kilfoyle was not originated by Militant. The key issue is whether or not the left is prepared to say enough is enough to Kinnock. To stand up and say that there is a limit to the witchhunting and the pursuance of Tory policies over jobs and services.

Standing up to this kind of thing has a long pedigree for revolutionary socialists. For example, John Palmer stood in the Hull East by-election in 1966 against Wilson's policies and achieved a most respectable result under the circumstances.

The position of party bosses, not for working people. But only when workers experience that and come to support an alternative working class strategy can we end the hold of Labour's capitalist politicians.

Militant and Socialist Worker think their propaganda alone will break many workers from Labour over to tra-left stunts will isolate "Marxism". their them from advanced workers and delay the building of a mass socialist party.

We have to fight alongside advanced workers for a Labour government and to try to turn Labour into a class party. But we must not suggest that Labour already is la class party.

Duncan Chapel Manchester Organiser on Waltoh is a disgrace. It seems to me that by supporting Kilfoyle you are really saying that there are no limits to your support for Kinnock. Even at a tactical level there is surely no need to call for Lesley Mahmood to be "humiliated". The hidden agenda seems to be a sexism all too reminiscent of Militant itself.

There is more to life than Parliamentary Elections and Labour winning the next Election. is not everything. More important for revolutionary socialists surely is the advancement of the class struggle. How will voting for Kilfoyle achieve this?

Charlie Murray, London ahead of us but present, here and now) - has grown over the past few years.

And it is clear that the deplorable state of green affairs is connected with "our" economic system.

Discovery of that fact is not enough: it still has to be taken on board and absorbed in our wider perspectives. We must explicitly acknowledge that social and green issues are inseparable. Capitalism means the exploitation of human beings and of the natural world.

The exploitation of nature leads to longlasting or even irreparable damage that capitalism ignores in favour of its own profit interest. Fundamentals of life are put at risk by nuclear power stations - Sellafield, Chernobyl, Three Mile Island -and by the storage of toxic waste and the rabid exploitation of raw materials.

The ruthless exploitation of people is becoming progressively worse, too. Physical and psychological burdens at the workplace are increasing thanks to the development of technology against the workforce.

On the occasions that workers' jobs survive the introduction of new technology it is introduced regardless of workers' positions or potential, and leads only to increased alienation. Production is concentrated not on people's needs but on those of the capitalist bosses.

So both the ecological balance and the prosperity of the people are sacrificed for economic growth and increased rates of trade and competition. Consequently the absolute contamination and devastation of the very jams, road danger and so on. They propose to enThis has wide support. Clearly, freight, particularly bulk freight like ore, coal, concrete, grain, and oil is safer being transported by rail than by increasing the allowable axle weight on heavy lorries.

And for commuters, rail is a faster means of transport than the current 7mph average speed through London roads, for example. A. passenger on a train also takes up a lot less room than a passenger alone in a car taking up a lotis rood new Should all workers, particularly rail workers, be celebrating this announcement by Transport Secretary Malcolm Rifkind? Sadly, no.

True to their nature, there is to be no extra spending on more efficient locomotives and rolling stock, replacement of dilapidated equipment, or new lines or sidings.

On the contrary, Rifkind's] plan is to open up the railways to greater competition, whereby anyone can have access to the rail system. operating their own rolling stock. They would pay only rent for the track. This is toi "liberate" companies from BR's monopoly.

And, of course, it would liberate such companies also from paying union wage rates. (low as they are) and union. negotiated holidays and conditions of service.

This follows the Tories' whole plan for the railways. carried _out over the last decade, of dividing up the rail system to identify that which is profitable and to ditch, where they can, that which is

----- pull-quotes -----

courage more freight and passengers onto rail.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 491

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →