Cancel the debt! and what then?
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-07-10Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 12
imperialism when you backed Labour in Walton?".
Now on one level this is just silly: and the SWP is mainly after recruits. from Militant. The SWP long ago ceas ed to deal in serious politics where the British labour movement is concerned. But it does express the justified emotional disgust with Kinnockism which many people feel now.
Instead of teaching such people that the only way to defeat Kinnockism is to win the fight for socialism within the trade unions and the Labour Party. the SWP demagogically exploits their lack of knowledge of the history of the labour movement.
The SWP twins with the Kinnockites as a double act: the SWP works to per suade socialists to give up on the only existing working class political mass movement, while the Kinnockites work to force them out.
There was a time when the SWP (then called International Socialists) aspired to be serious Marxists inside the real labour movement. We print here an editorial which appeared in Socialist Worker (then called Labour Worker) in January 1966. It is al reasoned argument against the decision of Richard Gott (now editor of the Agenda page in the Guardian) to stand in the upcoming Hull by-election as a protest against the then Labour government's complicity with US action in the Vietnam war.
Going a bit over the top, it describes Gott as a "scab" for risking letting in the Tory!
The editor of the paper then was a certain Paul Foot.
"But things have changed!" No, essentially, they have not changed. If the left had been better in the '70s an '80s then things might have changed. We might be in a different situation. But we aren't. Serious people have to face that if we are ever going to change it.
Labour remains the only credible labour movement based working class party. As Walton has iust demonstrated, there is no force to Labour's left which can seriously challenge it.
And, even with the millstone of Militant's record when it controlled th council around Mahmood's neck, condi tions in Liverpool were more favourable to the left, probably, than conditions anywhere else in the coun try.
It is still necessary for socialists to work patiently in the existing labour organisations. It is just as stupid now for leftists to mistake their own state of mind for that of the broad working class; just as self-defeating to give way to impatience.
There is no way forward for the working class now except through Labour Editor:
Paul Fost 6/120 Harerslock Hi London NW3 Business manager red Lindop Malvera Road London ES Production edilor: Roger Protz the words Paul Foot directed against Richard Gott. Rhimself with he tory, * Pres ichard Gott has identified convinced", , he told a press conference recently, "that it is right to threaten the government in order to show the world and to history that there are people in the country who are prepared to put principle before loyalty to the Labour Party."
Mr Gott's dreams these days are confined no doubt almost exclusively to the history books. Perhaps he looks forward to the day when the books will speak of that glorious by-election at Hull North in 1966, when Richard Gott, Michael Craft and Pat Arrowsmith took on the whole labour movement in Britain and reduced it to ashes.
Deprived of future historical significance by the recent refusal of the Richmond and Barnes constituency party to select him as prospective Labour candidate, Mr Gott was determined to write himself into history as an independent "Radical Alliance" candidate at Hull North.
One month he is seeking selection as a Labour candidate; the next he is threatening the Labour government. Such political meanderings are, of course, irrelevant to history. And it is with history that Mr Gott and his friends are chiefly concerned.
At the centre of Mr Gott's political philosophy is parliamentary cretinism run riot. For Mr Gott and his friends, all political argument, all decision and the rest take part either in parliament or in elections to parliament. The way, they feel, to take part in public argument and discussion is to take part in elections. The only other group in the left to hold similar parliamentary illusions is the Socialist Party of Great Britain, who, at the time of writing have not yet nominated HIS BOGUS seif with history "I am convinced, " he told a press conference recently. " that RICHARD GOTT has identified himit is right to threaten the government in order to show to the world and to history that there are people in the ciple before loyalty to the Labour country who are prepared to put prinMr Gott's dreams these days are conthe history books. Perhaps he looks fined no doubt almost exclusively to forward to the day when the books will peak of that glorious by-clection at Hull North in 1966, when Richard Goll.
Michael Craft and Pat Arrowsmith look on the whole labour movement in Britain and reduced it to ashes. De. prived of future historical significance by the recent refucal of the Richmond consciousness? Does he take an active part in his trade union? He is never seen, apparently, at branch meetings. Does he play a relevant role in his local Labour party? Is he a delegate to any trades councils or similar organisations? Of course not. What he does is to gang together with a lot of like-minded middle class radicals, and indulge in a form of radical masturbation, far away from the dreary arguments, but nevertheless the only real and relevant arguments, which are going on inside the labour movement.
No doubt the Radical Alliance would argue that all is lost in the Labour Party and trade unions. They are quite wrong. On the issues which matter most - and which, interestingly, to the Radical Alliance matter least — on the issue of wages and incomes, there are signs of profound and coherent resentment against government. policies throughout the movement.
At the last Labour Party conference, only one year after the election of a Labour government, the rank and file nearly threw out the entire government policy, including its attitude to Vietnam; the constituency parties voted three to one against the Immigration White Paper.
The "loyalty" to the Labour Party is dying much quicker than in the 1945-51 government; in fact, in spite of the Labour government, there is more discussion and argument about serious issues in the labour movement now than ever before in the last five years.
If Mr Gott knows anything about the labour movement he would know that nothing irritates more than a scab. A worker may be the purest socialist on earth, but if he refuses to join a trade union he is playing the bosses' game, and his "pure socialism" will, inevitably and rightly be associated with the bosses. Similarly in the Labour Party anyone who deliberately sets out to replace a Labour MP Tory one, he is seen as a scab and his politics are thought of as scab OF RICHARD GOTT AND RADICALS clections. The only other group in the left to hold similar parliamentary ilusions is the Socialist Party of Great Britain, who, at the time of writing have not yet nominaled their candidate for "Hell and history.
What Gott and his friends want is an arena, an arena where they can voice their views on Vietnam, Immigration and the like, many of which correspond with Labour Worker's position over the last four years. They setiously besing, tiny public meetings and clection- lieve that the pathetic round of canvaseering leaflets is a substitute for real argument, a short cut to a society which will behave properly on the issues they care about.
Arrogance since theless the only rcal and ments, which are going labour movement.
No doubt the Radical argue that all is lost in th and trade unions. They s On the issues which me which. interestingly. Alliance matter least-.. wages and incomes, the profound and cohere against governnient poli the movement. At the la: Conference. only one clection of a Labour g rank and file nearly thre guvernment policy, inc tude to Vietnant: th parties voted three to :
migration White Par he " losalty " to th is dying much quicke Martin In 15-17 July, the leaders Dor the word one rich in countries are meeting in London, • and the Saturday before, 13th, demonstrators will demand: "Cancel the Third World Debt!" The protest assembles at the Imperial War Museum in London.
Since Mexico defaulted on its debt payments in 1982, more and more Third World economies have been crippled by rising interest charges on money they borrowed in the 1970s, when oil-boom cash made credit easy.
Often the debt payments take up nearly all the hard currency the country can get from exports, leaving none for essential imports.
To get new loans and escape complete economic paralysis, the governments have to get approval from the International Monetary Fund, a body dominated by the US. The IMF demands - and gets - an end to government subsidies on food and transport prices, cuts in government welfare spending, and the selling-off of state industries.
No wonder that the call has come to cancel the debt. In 1985 the Labour Party conference passed a motion moved by Socialist Organiser supporter Patrick Murphy demanding more aid to the Third World and the cancellation of debts owed by the poorest coun tries.
If the movement built up round the weekend's protest is to continue effectively, however, it will have to tackle some illusions.
Some people see *Cancel the Debt!" as an anti-capitalist or revolutionary slogan in contrast to the traditional liberal call for "More aid to the Third World!"
It is nothing of the sort. The problem with aid to the Third World is that it goes into the hands of selfserving and often corrupt elites; it is often linked to contracts for companies from the aid-giving state; most of the money is spent on weaponry, prestige projects, or high-tech enterprises of little relevance to most people in the aidreceiving countries.
The problem with "Cancel the Debt!" is much the same. The borrowing was done by those same elites, and the money has been spent in the same sort of way, where it has not been siphoned back out again to enable Mexican or Argentine capitalists to acquire property in the US and other rich countries.
Aid, despite everything, can enlarge the room for workers and peasants' movements in the Third World to win improvements; so can "Cancel the Debt!" But cancelling the debt is simply a clumsy sort of aid, not some revolutionary alternative. It would bring more benefit to states like Israel, South Africa, Mexico and Argentina than to Bangladesh or Ethiopia or Mozambique.
The call to cancel the debt has a radical ring because it taps into a long tradition of populist struggles — struggles aiming to unite workers and peasants with smaller or less successful capitalists (the debtors) against the banks (the creditors). Over a hundred years ago Marx and Engels criticised this misidentification of exploitation with moneycapital rather than capital in What would "Cancel the Debt!" mean in practice? Simply wiping Third World loans off the books of the big American and European banks, so that many of them went bust and the world financial system No capitalist government would do that. If the movement to cancel the debt succeeded, it would mean the Western governments covering the losses of the banks involved. That would just be an indirect form of Western government aid to the debtor countries, with the side-effect of the big banks having the dodgy loans on their books replaced by safer government credits.
And then what? Would the debt reappear? Third World states would still want to borrow. So do we demand that the world capitalist system should be run in a noncapitalist way, without interest being charged on loans? (Some Third World countries already get some loans on easy rates, through the World Bank and other; but that is, yet again, just another form of traditional liberal aid).
The cause of poverty and exploitation is capitalism, not lending at interest as a particular form of capitalism. Our struggle should be aimed at linking up with the new workers' movements in the Third World to overthrow capitalism.
Scan page 13
ps hirtysomething bit the - last week, so it will be next year before we see the final series. It's been axed in the States, and deservedly so, in my opinion. I used to like it, but it got religion, and that finally finished it for me.
It's always been a very inward looking show. The characters deal with the world of decaying, often violent, Philadelphia by ignoring it. They focus on friends and family and make that their whole world, often to the point of obses. sion - were relationships in other US shows ever so scrutinised, so discussed?
But in this series, several characters began to feel family and success weren't enough. They wanted something more, and in two cases, Michael's and Elliot's, they turned to religion.
Oddly enough, neither choice was presented as a positive one. Michael turned back to his Jewishness when his son was born. He arranged to have the baby circumcised. This choice, opposed by nearly everyone, was a capitulation. Michael followed tradition because he felt rootless. He wanted to belong to something, no matter what.
Elliot's return to Catholicism was also a cop out, a way of coping with Nancy's cancer by shoving the burden onto a god. I felt squirmy-sick watching him mouthing Christian platitudes; he's always been the rebellious one.
It is tough getting older, feeling your body ageing and your options shrinking. But religion has no answers. It's a dead end for people who've copped out of doing something about the world, who look to some outside force solve their problems.
Grace in LA Law tried some problem solving last week. She defended a young captain being court-martialled for disobeying orders during the US's invasion of Panama. The captain had refused to blow up a civilian target. Grace thought that was enough of a defence. In her world, not killing people generally gets you acquitted.
But the army's topsy-turvy. The stern-jawed officers on the bench agreed it was terrible that Panamanian civilians were killed, tut-tutted about them being shoved in garbage bags and hidden in mass graves. They even found it bad that 50,000 people were made homeless by the army's bombingof civilian neighbourhoods. But the worst offence, they all agreed, was the captain's refusing to obey an order.
There was no irony here. Theyreally meant it. It was as if they'd never heard of Nazis and Nuremburg, and what just obeying orders can lead to. The captain got ten years hard labour.
Sound harsh? The prosecutor came to apologise and delivered the punch line that cleared things up. With 300,000 US troops massed in the Persian Gulf, the Armycouldn't afford not to put the cap tain away for a long, long time. The Army rules, OK.
I like LA Law. It's the voice of liberal America. Makes a change from George Bush and the holy joes on thirtysomething. Tony Brown en Loach's Riff Raff is Keiving a re uma season following its success at this year's Cannes Film Festival. If you missed it first time round, make sure you don't miss it this time.
It's not often that working class characters occupy all the lead roles. Usually workers are either peripheral to the main story, figures of fun or ridicule, or simply nonexistent.
am glad SO resisted the impulse to denounce Alan ¡Bleasdale's GBH after episode one. This included the scene where a crowd of "left wing" thugs danced on the roof of a school for emotionally-disturbed children, terrifying them.
It was characteristic of GBH's vivid, poster-colour comic-book style that the frightened children had their faces painted up, Walt Disney tashion, as cute animals. The scene was deeply disturbing. As many people wrote, it. would be worth a lot of votes for the Tories in an election. (And it cannot have helped Lesley Mahmood!)
But GBH is now revealed as being like those old Guardian TV ads where you saw a man running, seemingly to attack an old man; and then the broader picture put it in context: he was pushing him out from under falling masonry:
After 5 episodes things in GBH loo radically different. The organisers of the left wing thugs' are state agents.
The thugs dancing on the roof were organised by the state and paid for "by public money" to discredit the left, and, in particular, the Labour But Riff Raff is not a stern, serious, 'political' film. On the contrary, it's a very funny movie, set on a building site in 1990s London.
The film opens with Stevie, just down from Glasgow, waking up on the street and setting off for a job as a builder's labourer.
At the site office the rules are laid down by the bitter and cynical old manager. Employment means hard work, lousy, conditions, no insurance and instant dismissal when he feels like it.
The men we meet have been drawn to London over the years from Glasgow, Liverpool, and Bristol by unemployment. Their's is a tenuous existence, always knowParty.
Michael Murray, the Derek Hatton character is manipulated by them. He thinks he is being manipulated by the Militant-like political organisation which is run as a cover for their activities by the state agents. (The waffl ing Ted Grant character, "Mervin" doesn't know either).
From this viewpoint, the scene in which the state-organised and financed thugs dance on the roof of a disturbed children's school is a metaphor for their relationship with the very disturbed Michael Murray, on whose head they have been dancing all through.
I'd formed the strong opinion that lower middle-class snobbery and disdain for workers such as bin-men is an underlying key-note in GBH. I still think so. It overlaps with another strange aspect of a programme dealing with left-wing politics: the working class does not exist in this "Northern City" as any sort of force. Michael Murray seems to strut above a void. He is a petty, local dictator without a base.
At first it seemed that the brutal thug squad run by the agents were meant to represent the working class. Now that you see them for what they are, there is no working class movement!
Reality is a Russian Doll: outside is Murray, "inside" Murray is the Militant group, "inside" that the state.
And who knows what revelations are yet to come?
It is a curiously Gerry Healy-WRP view of reality: all the world is a spy ing that work might stop at any moment and that an accident is just around the corner. Even when Stevie meets Susie and they start to share his squat, they assure each other it's only short-term.
They are a rough lot, ready for a joke, a pint, and a game of cards, and willing to lend a hand for one of their mates. And it is a very masculine culture we enter. There is camaraderie but, as we soon see, no solidarity.
Stevie is quickly set up with a squat which lets Larry tell us that Labour in Liverpool built more houses in the mid-80s than all other local authorities. He gives a speech about homelessness and the waste novel and all the men and women merely dupes and "agents"
Bleasdale's Kinnockite politics, mixed with a WRP view of how things work leads to the strange conclusion that the left only exists (or is manufactured) to... discredit the Labour Party!
But, except for the thugs and a couple of cliché "salt-of-the-earth" "good-old-fashioned" Labour, slowwitted workers, there is not much of Labour Party either!
In fact, GBH is full of clichés and "homages" , played with, turned around, or simply used without ceremony. You notice that the - ver funny — episode where Murray can' stop his hand giving Hitler salutes is straight out of Kubrick's Dr Strangelove; in the next episode someone refers to it as Murray's Dr Strangelove act... Episode 5 ended with a naked man sitting upright -straight out of Monty Python...
The cast, of course, is wonderful, the main source of the strong primar: coloufs. They — with Bleasedale's writing — make it all very vivid: Michael Palin looks like Dan Dare, hero; Dearbhla Molloy, his wife, has wonderfully warm and sympathetic face; Robert Lindsay can make you hate or like him on call; and Lyndsey Duncan is walking cartoon sexuality, as well as being a fine actress.
Michael Murray is catching on, and may yet prove the hero. It is not clear to me how it will all be pulled togethe in the remaining two episodes. But then I am not Alan Bleasdale. Keep watching! that lets sites and bricks lie idle while people live on the street. This is met by gentle rubbishing at his speechifying, but the point is taken.
The conditions they endure are terrible. Rats in the eating area, foul toilets that reduce them to urinating on the floor, and safety *standards' that can only lead to injury.
Loach doesn't set up his characters as angels. Far from it. They are three-dimensional people. Apart from being well-meaning happy-go-lucky lads they also break their word to other workers on the site and engage in a bit of petty theft on the side. The white workers stick together, and so do the black.
The first time that we see any sign of them all thinking about standing up for their rights follows a near accident and the discovery of the rats nest under the eating room floor.
Larry tells them they need to get UCATT down and they should all join up. He goes to the boss and gives him a list of their demands and assures them it will all be fixed up by Thursday. And so it is -Larry gets the sack.
This scene though is hard to believe. Loach is making the point that after twelve years of Thatcher, even basic trade union organisation has broken down in many areas and industries. The need to join a union and win back conditions has to be explained anew.
But the response of Larry is to accept the sack and walk off the site saying he's seen this before in Liverpool. His mates just stand by and watch him leave. They do nothing.
It's not until another bloke is sacked for using the boss's mobile phone, and a black worker actually falls through the unsealed scaffolding that some response is made. But it isn't collective action, it is an individual act of violence. It's hard not to give a cheer, but you realise that it's a futile and destructive act.
Riff Raff is very much an "us versus them" film, workers against the boss, Labour councils against the Tories. There is no real differentiation of Labour or left-wing politics, but the opportunity to see a film where you can identify with "us" is so rare that Riff Raff should not be missed.
Scan page 14
Socialist Organiser No. 491 page 14
----- pull-quotes -----
Our aims Worl