"Alliance for Workers' Liberty summer school A weekend full of ideas
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-07-10Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 7
wing discourse.
veryone — as far as I could see - who attended the summer school in London on 28-30 June went away feeling they had learned something.
Perhaps more important, they went away wanting to learn more, by reading and taking part in struggles, campaigns and discussions, and to take what they had already learned into the labour movement.
350 people came; 14 new people decided to join the Alliance for Workers' Liberty. The biggest sessions included:
• a sparky debate on banning pornography with Avedon Carol, Liz Kelly and Steph Ward;
• socialists and the Tories;
• a meeting on the Walton by-election, in which speakers who had come to "intervene" from the SWP and other groups got a chance to put their argument and had it answered;
• forums on the "New World Order";
• the collapse of Stalinism;
• South Africa today. tional Representation The speakers on South cluded prominent left wing black trade unionists from South Africa, as well as Bob Fine, author of Beyond Apartheid. Adam Keller, editor of The Other Israel magazine in Tel Aviv; Anatoly Voronov from the Socialist Party in Moscow; and Adam Nowak from the Left Alternative in Czechoslovakia, were also among the guest speakers.
Branka Magas addressed a session on Yugoslavia, where civil war had just broken out.
Two sessons on Sunday — Peter Tatchell's "Lesbian and Gay Agenda" and Clive Bradley on "Gay Fiction" - attracted much interest from people who had been on the Lesbian and Gay Pride march the day before.
Sessions on the history of the left attracted large attendances from people interested in discovering the origins of the current divisions and confusion, John O'Mahony spoke on *Trotsky versus Shachtman?" and on the history of the Militant tendency, Jim Denham on the "International Socialists" (forerunners of the SWP) in their heyday of the early 170sItems which were less directly "political"-with-a-capital-P also drew attention — Jim Denham on the press barons, Terry Eagleton on Oscar Wilde, Robin Blackburn on the Black Jacobins, Ruth Cockroft on the "politics of identity" Patrick Murphy on human nature, and others.
An "introductory course of five sessions went through the basic ideas of anti-Stalinist socialism for beginners, and an intensive foursession course by Simon Mohun presented Marxist economics.
People who had previously attended similar events organised by the Socialist Workers' Party or Militant commented on the contrast: instead of rote repetition of a stereotype "line" , and panicky rote denunciation of any criticism, there was genuine debate and willingness to explore ideas._ Unfortunately only one other group — Labour Briefing — would even go so far as to send a speaker to debate left unity (and the Briefing speaker, so it turned out, came mainly to try to justify his group's split from Socialist Organiser in 1980!). That's the state of things on the left at the present.
But this school showed that the Alliance for Workers' Liberty has both the openness for debate, the seriousness in hammering out issues, that left unity will need.
Scan page 8
ahmood's (left) defeat by Kilfoyle (right) flows from Militant's failure of nerve during Liverpool Council's confrontation with the Tories i n Walton Dale That were the voters saying on the doorstep in the Walton by-election? From a left-wing point of view, nothing very encouraging.
Presaging the low turnout on polling day itself, a lot of voters had clearly had more than enough of the by-election well before 4 July. "Not another bloody leaflet," and "I've had that other mob ie. Militant] round half a dozen times already," were the most frequent comments from voters.
The attempts of Mahmood to masquerade as the real Labour candidate provoked sweeping condemnations of Militant and left wing politics in general on the doorstep: Why can't they just be honest and call themselves Marxists?" queried one voter. "Derek Hatton made a laughing stock of this city, and now that woman wants to do the same only a small minority, Mahmood.
Others stuck with Labour. *I'm voting Kilfoyle — but reluctantly" as one of them put it. Some were more enthusiastic: "I'm voting Kilfoyle, and please let Harry Rimmer know that some of us council workers think he is doing a wonderful job", requested another.
Even council workers facing imminent unemployment did not necessarily turn to their selfme to vote Labour? I've just been made redundant by those bastards. I'll not bother voting at all. Or, if I do, 'll vote Liberal" , said one.
Those intending to vote Mahmood generally explained their intentions in terms of an angry dissatisfaction with Kinnock's record as Labour Party leader.
Others were voting Mahmood because they foolishly believed that Militant seriously fought the Tories in 1984/5, or because they thought that Lesley Mahmood had had a rough time.
Kilfoyle's personal record was frequently criticised by Mahmood
----- pull-quotes -----
appointed saviour, Lesley Mahmood. "How can you expect