Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

[Advisory ladimire Dener Ternate Phon Jatin Haria (Labour…]

Socialist Organiser no. 491, 10 July 1991 · scan pp. 3–4 · about 1,073 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 3

Advisory ladimire Dener Ternate Phon Jatin Haria (Labour Party BlackSectional DorothyaMerace «per ki anno John Mellroy John Nicholson Preterate used Members of the Advisory Committee are drawn from a broad cross section of the el wo are opposer to the abour war ty's witch-hunt against Socialist Organiser. Views expressed in articles are he responsibility of the authors and not Taffe's figures are probably wishful thinking: many Walton socialists who voted Labour had a positive animosity to Militant because of its rotten record when it controlled Liverpool council. But for certain it is true that Mahmood had no chance because she did not - and could not - offer a credible alternative to the Tories.

Even if Mahmood did not have the council record of Militant and Hatton behind her like a long noisy string of clattering tin cans, that hard fact of political life would have made an anti-Labour socialist candidacy in Walton nothing more than a propaganda stunt. Politically clued-up socialist workers would have rejected it.

Mahmood did not, and could not, appear betore the voters of Walton as a clean, tresh socialist alternative to the dirty Labour municipal wheeling and dealing.

She was the candidate of the deservedly discredited Hatton machine: a machine discredited by its Tammany Hall jobs-for-theboys corruption; by the stone age council racism it preserved and defended; by its short-sighted deals with the Tories in 1984, when it could, instead, have taken the working class of Liverpool into a confrontation with the Tories side by side with the striking miners; and so on, and so on.

Nor did Militant run a socialist campaign.

In the first place, they ran a stupidly lying campaign which must have repelled and alienated many socialist voters. They pretended that Mahmood won the selection in Walton and that Kilfoyle was imposed by Kinnock, that she was the "Real Labour candidate"

After the returns were in on the night of 4 July, Militant's chair of the Broad Left, Tony Mulhearn, appeared on TV to make the idiotic claim that Peter Kilfoyle was out of line with the leadership of the Labour Party and to argue that, for that reason, Kinnock and Co. had made a mistake in supporting him!

To confuse things even more they claimed that a vote for Lesley Mahmood - against the official Labour candidate - would not only help get a Labour government but a Labour government with socialist politics.

In all these aspects of the campaign Militant behaved as desperate and incoherent people who didn't mind what claims they made, nor care about either truth or consistency. People notice these things. And the voters of Walton are thinking people, not fools.

And Militant offered no socialist politics. Militant's programme in the by-election was just a set of minimal reforms.

As Mahmood's election said:

**Lesley is standing for *4• Equal pay and a national minimum wage of £175 per week *• Return all trust hospitals to the NHS, full funding for all health needs nursery place for every child "o No prosecution of poll tax non-payers, no bailiffs, for a full amnesty."

Fine, as far as it goes. But the "socialist element in the election was a matter of an agreed description: Lesley Mahmood was, it was agreed by Lesley Mahmood, the Labour Party, the press, and by the fantasist sectarian leit, the representative of the left.

More than inis, the people who ran this "campaign for socialism" in Walton came across in the mass media as people with tape recordings in their heads, instead of minds, spouting set routines, mainly in a private language made up of jargon and private points of reference.

Much of what they said was senseless, especially from a socialist point of view; most of it was gobbledeygook from any point of view.

The looming general election; the desperate urge inside the labour movement to focus on getting the Tories out; Militant's record - that of out-bureaucrats and displaced corrupt municipal politicans - and the combination of sectarianism and minimalist agitation with which Militant ran the Walton campaign all made the Walton by-election a very unfavourable set of conditions to test "socialism"

All proportions guarded, Militant standing on its own in a Liverpool constituency was a lot like East German Stalinists standing in Berlin.

In the circumstances, perhaps 2,613 votes was an achievement!

Militant fought Walton for its own narrow factional reasons and no others. From that point of view it may have made short term sense.

For the rest of the left to rally to Militant made no. sense at all.

The SWP is not concerned with national politics, but didn't they know about Militant's record in Liverpool? Or is it that they think the voters of Walton don't know?

Do they really think that the record of Militant's "deformed workers' state" in Liverpool, makes Lesley Mahmood, the candidate of its now derailed municipal machine, a proper representative of socialism?

The truth is that their prime and only concern to be able to posture militantly and, maybe, recruit a few people from Militant. And so they strung themselves with Militant (and Workers' Power, and the WRP, etc) into a preposterous sectarian daisy chain.

If Militant's "left" candidacy in the by-election has any effect on the effort of council workers to defend their jobs, then it can only be a harmful effect. That was entirely predictable.

Socialism was not tested in the walton by-election. Militant was. Militant are the "Trotskyists" who thought in the mid-'80s that they could build their own "socialism in one city" and created a small caricature of a degenerated workers' state instead. Socialism did not fail: Militant did!

Walton will help the left if, as a result of this experience, the central lesson for now is learned from it: the left is the left when it engages in serious class politics; it is a sectarian irrelevance when it cuts across class politics and diverts itself to stunts and gestures.

"The emancipation of the working class is also the emancipation of all human beings without distinction of sex or race."

Karl Marx Socialist Organiser PO Box 823, London SE15-4NA Newsdesk: 071 639 7965 Latest date for reports: Monday Editor: John O'Mahony 01Ж1 BACHELLE LONDON OLI Printed by Tridant Press, Edenbridge Registered as a newspaper at the Post Office Articles do not necessarily reflect the views of Socialist Organiser and are in stated

Scan page 4

Socialist Organiser No. 491 page 4 N PERSPECTIVE

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 491

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →