Rank and file victory at Hull DSS
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-06-20Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 15 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 15
an important victory for rank and file action.
5 strikers at Hull West office returned to work victorious and jubilant on Thursday 6th June having won 20 extra permanent staff and improvements to a return to work agreement they had rejected three days earlier as inadequate.
Grassroots power The nine-week strike has proved the power of grassroots action against the employer, even in the face of an uncooperative rightwing bureaucracy. The Hull strikers got official backing and strike pay, but no leadership whatsoever from the DSS Section Executive Committee (SEC). They could have been left isolated by the SEC's policy of supporting only local disputes. Instead they bravely voted to reject the 10 extra staff offered by local management after a week on strike, and set about winning extra money from the Benefits Agency, for more staff, by building from the bottom up the widespread strike action that was needed.
Thrown out by Ellis Hull strikers spoke at over 70 car park meetings calling for support from other CPSA members and raising demands for a nationally coordinated staffing campaign. They were ejected from CPSA HQ on the orders of General Secretary John Ellis when they went to lobby an SEC meeting which was discussing the national DSS staffing crisis. "How dare he throw us out?" said one striker, "We pay his wages, and our subs bought this building!"
CPSA members in all but one management district within the South Yorkshire and Humberside Area Directorate had either taken strike action or had sought CPSA authority to ballot. Staffing strikes had also broken out in *a wave from the Humber to the Severn' - a phrase coined by Benefits Agency management, who were forced to respond with a £16 million cash injection to be shared out nationally amongst District managers. Although originally intended only for running costs' the pressure of growing strike action persuaded management that it could be spent on extra staff.
Fear of rank and paign Shamefully, the DSS SEC tried to claim the credit which rightly belongs to striking CPSA members by saying that it was their "policy of letting each striking office fight that won the €16 million! This suggestion was laughed at openly by delegates and observers at the CPSA DSS Section Conference on 12th May. They knew that the real reason was that the employer had recognised what the SEC had failed to do - that a national staffing campaign was growing and strikes were being spread largely by the activity and example of the strikers from Hull. The employer feared the potential of a rank and file campaign being run in the Branches rather than from CPSA HQ and chose to try to settle the dispute.
National campaign needed The successful outcome of the Hull strike paves the way for CPSA members in other DSS offices to demand that their share of the £16 million is spent on staff to ease the pressure of work caused by the economic recession and years of systematic job cuts. But in, many areas even that won't be enough to solve the staffing problems. On their return to work the Hull Strikers unselfishly recognised this by carrying a motion calling on the SEC urgently to mount the nationally co-ordinated staffing campaign that is still needed by members in most DSS offices: Political conclusions The strikers also drew their own political conclusions from their experience of the right-wing SEC during the strike by agreeing to urge CPSA members throughout the DSS to vote for Broad Left candidates in the DSS Section elections. An important consequence of the strike was the way that 14 strikers who attended CPSA Conference had a veil of naivety lifted from their eyes. Conference gave a standing ovation to a Hull striker who brilliantly explained the need for a national staffing campaign. Seeing this support from ordinary delegates and observers by contrast to the 'do nothing' right-wing leadership of DSS (who refused to let a Hull striker address their own DSS Section Conference!) has made many members in Hull more determined than ever to work for a fighting, socialist Broad Left leadership in CPSA.
Photo page 5 work inside Southwark council homes when they have traditionally been employed as fitters on the estate and block boiler systems.
When they refused they were sacked.
For more information about the dispute contact Southwark Trade Union Support Unit, 42 Braganza St, London SE17 3RJ. Tel: 071 582 8433.
mood started to become clear.
Local government delegates backed calls for a national demonstration against cuts, and a special meeting in September to plan the campaign ahead. The limit of these victories, though, was that 'campaigning' became a substitute for industrial action. need for union.
The stalling on pay, to ailow the employers to make an (unlikely) higher offer was heavily carried - putting off any possibility of the industrial action needed to get the 12% and national minimum wage claim till August!
Health branch delegates, despite accepting 7.9% on pay in May, behaved much the same. They trounced the national leadership of the Health Group to insist on a joint union conference to discuss the attacks on the NHS and plan a campaign of action — leaving only a handful of votes for a leadership plan for a 'branches seminar' in 1992.
As the conference proper began it looked, briefly, as if the NEC might have judged the mood - with the General Secretary leading a "set piece" debate on opposition to any vague deals under a Labour Government through the TUC. But Jinkinson's carefully measured phrases about resisting wage restraints which "depress the living standards of working people" whilst not ruling out "a dialogue between the government and employers and trade unions as social partners" scarcely won a ripple of applause. A more forthright, indeed embittered attack on the GMB's John Edmonds worked, by contrast, to bring the house down, and won an overwhelming Then the NEC lost it - they opposed calls for real support to NHS members campaigning to defend the NHS, with more money for campaigns and the organisation of local, regional and a national demonstration. They so obviously refused to *put their money where their mouth is" that by the end of the debate they could scarcely muster a few dozen votes on a conference floor with over a thousand delegates.
put forward a loose, woolly document that left a lot of questions unanswered. Because branches and the union's black members and women's conferences had little, or no, chance to discuss it there was a lot of confusion.
The small, but not that small, band of Conservative Trade Unionists assisted by the rightwing NEC members who came off the platform did a good job in clarifying some issues - they straightforwardly opposed merger with threats of splitting away and lost convincingly.
Unfortunately, parts of the left' nearly gave them a second bite of the cherry with a proposal from the large Birmingham Branch to 'refer back' merger -because they had no promise of a "perfect union" , the right leapt on the bandwagon.
Only Socialist Organiser, in a well-received special issue of our daily bulletin, cut through the confusion on the left. We argued the principles of industrial unionism and the need for 'one big union', and tried to nail the lie that NUPE and COHSE had rule-books like the EETPU! Despite being a small voice we made a real difference, contributing to the defeat of the proposal by 361,000 votes 225,000.
If the NEC felt they'd get it all their own way from then on they were wrong - their calls to oppose calls for more democracy fell like nine-pins in a debate that approved insisting on the sovereignty of union conference, financial resources to branches, a member-led not full-timer run union, and the rights of individuals, branches and groups to openly campaign within the union to change its policies.
The only defeat the left suffered in the whole business was in a 'fudge' on balloting for affiliation to the Labour Party — leaving the new union with separate "political" and 'nonpolitical' political union funds! The confusion and lack of united planning by the left let the NEC get away with that one.
To follow up the debate and prepare for a special conference on merger planned by NALGO in early 1992, a number of branches agreed to host a conference for branches, self-organised groups and campaigns NALGO, NUPE and COHSE on 9th November in Manchester... the first serious attempt to really unite activists across all 3 unions.
It would be nice to say that the Conference was rounded off by a serious debate on how to campaign in the fortheoming General Election - it wasn't... because the NEC scuttling around to avoid further defeat, switched from opposing to supporting a motion calling for a campaign and let it go through on the nod" when they realised - at last = what the mood was!
----- pull-quotes -----
Brian Nelson, CPSA Office rep at Hull W DSS, tells the story
Strike spreads Four weeks into the Hull strike,
Socialist Organiser, in our daily bulletin, cut through the confusion on the left. We argued the principles