Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

[question on what the SWP will advocate at…]

Socialist Organiser no. 490, 20 June 1991 · scan pp. 14–15 · about 1,077 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 14 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 14

question on what the SWP will advocate at the General Election, Cliff argued "voting Labour is the expression of working class people wanting something better' By that criteria, the SWP will be happy advocating a vote for the Democratic Party in the US. It was hardly a scientific analysis.

Cliff then appeared to be moving in the right direction when he said that the Labour Party was a "capitalist workers' party". It was bourgeois because of its policies, dominant ideas, etc. Yes, I agree, but what made it a workers' party? Cliff remained silent, except to say that a (decreasing) number of workers were members of the Labour Party. But workers are members of other parties, too.

The question was raised again at a meeting I spoke at a few days later. The local SWPers accepted the Labour Party wourge is ins reds, party" but by virtue of its social composition. Using that criteria the SWP is a bourgeois party! And anyway, he argued, the Labour Party was losing its working class base.

There are three points to be made here. First, that the SWP makes a sociological analysis of the Labour Party, rather than seeing its organic trade union links, what makes it a workers' party, Second, that this drift out of the Labour Party by activists is nothing new. It happened in the '60s and '70s and the way the SWP uses it is thought that the article penned by Paul Mellelieu was too puerile and abusive on the subject of Bob Dylan to be worth replying to.

However, having read Colin Foster's pathetic attempt to support Dylan, I am forced to put pen to paper.

Colin Foster basically concedes all Mellelieu's case — ie. Dylan has done nothing worthwhile for the last 15 years, but draws the slightly WHATHS-ON Thursday 20 June "The case for socialist feminism", Middlesborough SO meeting. Teeside Poly, 6.00 "Nothing to celebrate", , candlelit vigil in opposition to the "Victory Parade". : 9.00-midnight, Trafalgar Square. Organised by Women Against War in the Gulf, Labour Against the War and others "Racist Britain - what's the answer?", ", Sheffield SO meeting. SSCAU, West St, 7.30. Speaker: Gail Cameron "Save the NHS" , Leeds SO meeting. 7.00, Swarthmore Centre Woodhouse Square Friday 21 June "Women and violence at Conference. Birmingham Union Studies Centre, Fli Street, Digbeth. Details: 6169 more charitable conclusion that Dylan's early work more than makes up for the last "15 or even 25 years"

Why did he bother? By dismissing anything since Blonde on Blonde he ignores what is critically regarded as Dylan's finest album, Blood on the Tracks, plus Street Legal (1975), Empire Burlesque (1985), and Oh Mercy (1987) to name but a few.

I am sick and tired of Dylan beng boxed into one particular slot, ie. protest singer; granted, these occur Socialist Movement TUC TGWU members meeting. 1.00-5.30. ULU Malet Street, Euston, London Wednesday 26 June "Socialists and the Labour Party", East London SO meeting. Oxford House, Derbyshire Stree E2, 7.30. Speaker: Maxine Vincent "Fighting council cuts", Merseysı SO meting. 7.30, Unemployed Centre, Wallasey "Women and the fight for socialism", SW London SO meting. 7.30, Lambeth Town Hall Wednesday 3 July "We stand for workers' liberty" London SO Forum. 7.30, Lucas Arms, Gray's Inn Road, Kings C Thursday "America: the prospects socialism", Leeds SO me 7.30, Leeds University L Saturday 6 July Socialist Campaign Group conference Monday 8 July "Lessons of the Iranian tion", Manchester SO m 8.00, Town Hall. Speaki CARI Manchester Al tion, called by and Poll Tax throughout his work, but his music is more diverse than any other artist still peforming today.

If you want to do a hatchet job why not concentrate on those who deserve it - ie. The Rolling Stones?

One final point to make: it seems grossly unfair to blame Dylan, who is not a selfpublicist, for some of the more stupid and pretentious things written about him.

Jane Hinchliffe Birmingham iti-Cuts Labour Thursday 18 July Luton Socialists for Labour meeting. 7.45, Union Streel Speaker: Cate Murphy of expulsion. Here, surely, was a rich seam to tap for potential recruits. (What's more, for a change, they would not be students).

The inevitable "Open Letter" soon followed, headed - rather prematurely in many cases — "Where Now for Socialists Outside the The "Liverpool Labour Councillors (LLC) were quite right to stand against the official Labour candidates," says the "Open The LLC, continues the "Open Letter" , understood you could not fight Rimmer's attacks from within Labour's ranks".

Obviously the SWP has every right to indulge in dead-end sectarianism and cut itself off from the strug gles in the Labour Party. But to suggest that it is objectively impossible to fight within the Labour Party against the right wing is politically illiterate.

There's plenty more that on the way.

The "Open Letter" is at pains to stress that "the 'real' Labour Party is not the party of the (LLC) rebels, but that of the witchhunters. "And as proof we're told that "the Labour Party has never (their emphasis) called a strike."

Nor has the SWP*. And the trade unions have never won a general election. (Nor has the SWP). So where does this discovery get you? Only to recognise that the it was not a credible alternative to the So what's the alternative? Yes, it's that old favourite of "join the SWP": "We urge all those socialists who have stood up to Kinnock's attacks not to follow the path of the ILP in the 1930: but to join with us in building a real socialist alter native.

If the SWP bothered to read a couple more history books, they might discover that they are pretty well advanced along the path followed by the ILP in the 1930s (and the Workers Revolutionary Party in the 1970s).

The SWP's recent chasing after Liverpool Broad Left reminds me of their last lusting after 'Militant'. This little ditty was composed at the time:

(To the tune of 'What a wonderful world it would Don't know much about history, Marxism's still a mystery Don't know the line that Lenin took 'Cos I've only Cliff's book But one thing fact If we got together and pass ed an Enabling Act What a wonderful world it would be... * With one exception. An SWPdominated "Rank and File Conference" in 1977 called a one-day strike in support of the firefighter: It was a miserable flop.

Scan page 15

NALGO Conference

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 490

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →