From Boys From The Blackstuff to boredom
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-06-20Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 13 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 13
Television Kevin Feintuck file progress report on Bleasdale's "GBH"
f the Guardian is to be believed, Derek Hatton is attempting to have Alan Bleasdale's series GBH banned in case it prejudices his trial. If the second episode (shown 13th/16th June) is typical of the rest of the series there may well be a case for withdrawing the programme in order to save us from more "Greatly Boring Humbug"
The first episode, for all its faults, had established its two main characters and laid the basis for a story. It would not have been about the Labour Movement as we know it, but would have kept a fair number of us tuning in if only to see Michael Murray come to an inevitably sticky end.
Unfortuntely, the second episode offered very little in the development of the main story line. Much of the 90 minutes was spent reinforcing points which had already been established in the first episode. There was also a minor smattering of thuggery organised by the supporters of the mysterious group headed by academic guru, Melvin Sloan (played by Paul Daneman).
On the political manipulation front Sloan and his lieutenant, Lou Barnes (Tom Georgeson) have been busy laying the seeds for rioting by the black communities in Murray's city. Murray who prides himself on his anti-racist credentials, at first tries to resist, and suggests they try Cardiff instead!
In terms of character development we have seen Jim Nelson's hypochondria coming along in leaps and bounds. His stressed condition is causing him to wander into cupboards and tool sheds at night and prevents him from driving over bridges. Never the less, he has stuck to his task defying the weekly pickets, to run his school singlehanded.
Poor old Michael Murray's obsession with the father he never knew is becoming more evident and we have also had it confirmed that his downtrodden chauffeur is in fact his elder brother. The episode did have a couple of worthwhile moments.
I think my favourite was young Michael's mother (Julie Walters) being wooed by her son's headmaster who attempts to charm her by reading from T.S. Eliot. A close second was headmaster Weller, as an old man, using his brolly to damage the obnoxious gutter press reporter.
Some of the unanswered questions from last week are beginning to become clearer.
Yes, there is a state conspiracy going on (not surprising).
Yes, Murray is on the make from building firms (less surprising).
No, the organised working class has yet to appear, let alone assert itself (not surprising but still disappointing).
As for future episodes my tips are: • Lou Barnes and/or the nasty thug played by Andrew Schofield are the state agents; • The mysterious fair-haired woman is none other than Murray's childhood temptress, Eileen Critchley; • When Murray's wife Maureen is finally shown we will see that Murray the brutalised boy has turned into Murray the brutal man. My last prediction is that despite the second helping being so dull, I won't be the only reader to waste my time watching the third episode. (Kevin Feintuck was a Liverpool City Councillor from 1987 to 1990) there's a leak in the bogs.
The bills are hidden behind the clock her savings baked in a pie, the carpet's strewn with toys and socks.
She sits back and has another drag, pulling her in every direction her children tear her like a rag. Open University, foundation and brick but no time for the roof: yet again pregnant and feeling sick. What she could have been in life hangs melancholy over the chairs, puppets and cuddlies designed through strife.
The bailiff's on the doorstep, if hustles in all that's left is a frozen chest and layers of shedded skin.
She threatens her husband with snip, he treats his privates as a Sergeant would; the eldest daughter's giving him lip. Fagash Debbie, there are too many holes, too many problems to sew: turn up the TV, it'll tell them know
Scan page 14
rie Heffer's (and my Lown) anglo-catholicism •was/is not quite as eccentric in revolutionary circles as you suggest. In Britain, Trotskyism originated from anglocatholic socialism.
The Reg Groves/Stuart Purkiss group (initially with Fr St.John Groser) was a breakaway faction of the Catholic Crusade, (of which Fr Conrad Noel of Thaxted was the leading light), The Crusade was founded (on a democratic centralist basis) in 1916, itself a breakaway from the Church Socialist League, of which Noel had previously been national secretary. When the Communist Party was founded in 1922 the Crusade was a constituent grouping.
Noel was however what the International Left Opposition elsewhere (eg Lore in the US or — ironically — Ridley in Britain) thought of as a "premature Trotskyist"; so the Crusade disaffiliated, in (I think) 1924.
A faction, (known to Crusade members as the Stalinist Faction,) disapproved, left the Crusade, and re-entered the CP. whose new rules insisted that they did so on an individual basis. A year or two later it reemerged as the Balham Revolutonary Front.
A subsequent stalinist faction in the Crusade around Jack Putterill and Stanley Evans caused a split in the "30s; the Noel faction, Stuart and Reg reunited as the Socialist Christian League which existed until 1961, members of which subsequently launched Jubilee (after the "Year of Jubilee" in Deuteronomy, wherein all wealth was returned to common ownership) which still exists and of which Ken Leech is the moving spirit.
Sammy Bornstein's account of the Reg Groves group's history and evolution is only lacking in that he assumes that Reg (and, for a shorter time, Stuart) abandoned anglo-catholicism while in the CP and in the Left Opposition — he didn't. Moreover, he told Trotsky, when he first contacted him, that the group was predominantly christian-socialist (anglo-catholic socialist), Reg was sensitive to allegations by the CP HQ that his group only existed because of its religious connections, and so (unlike Stuart) he didn't widely announce the fact that he was religious, except in the context of christian socialist meetings (where there was no secret about his Trotskyism); and so, though he made theoretical connections between the two beliefs, he did not make organisational connections, and consequently did not take the theoretical connections to the point of a theory of organisation.
This lack struck Conrad Noel as theoretically sloppy and was probably why, even though the Noel and the Groves groupings were reunited after the '30s split in a new christian socialist organisation, he still - until his death in 1940 — referred to the Groves group as the "Stalinist Faction"
I would argue that such was the degeneration of the CPGB in the mid-twenties that no oppositional faction could arise within it, unless its members had some non-Party point of contact and loyalty. Except for Roy Merritt (the Bukharinist Group, which consisted of two brothers and a brother-in-law), all other oppositional factions came together after people had left the CP, or were formed within party front organisations, not within the Party itself.
Nor, incidentally, was this tradition the only anglo-catholic one within the far left; for instance, Jacquie Prynne wno was in Socialist Review and later the SLL, in the late '50s and the early '60s was anglo-catholic but, until she met me, unaware that she belonged to a wider tradition. There were several "spokes" in the YCL at that time. Fr Michael Scott was in the CP in England and South Africa, and broke with it because of its compromises with racism.
Laurens Otter Salop got for the first time the Socialist Workers Party (SWP) in Liverpool have recently had to perform yet another political somersault.
When Militant and the Liverpool Labour Party Broad Left first publicised their intention of standing independent Labour candidates in last month's loc council elections, the SWP dismissed it as a waste of time.
It was written off as "manoeuvring in wards"". Chasing after seats on the City Council was an empty diversion. The real struggle was on the picket lines, fighting the City Council's attempts to axe a thousand jobs.
When five out of the six independent Labour candidates who stood got elected, the SWP softened its line, of course, said the SWP, they had been quite. right to stand. Of course, said the SWP, it was good British labour movement has a political wing (the Labour Party) and an industrial wing (the trade unions). Only SWP members are oblivious to this pretty obvious fact.
The "Open Letter" goes on to deal with the split by the Independent Labour Party (ILP) from the Labour Party in 1932. The ILP failed "because it tried to ride two horses at once: was it to be an electoral alternative to Labour, or a party based on the struggles of workers?"
If the SWP bothered to read Lenin, they would know that he advocated that revolutionaries ride not two. but three horses at once: the political, the economic and the ideological.
The ILP breakaway from the Labour Party was a fiasco which quickly ended in a political wilderness. Whilst being much larger than the SWP of today, it was not a credible alternative to the Labour Party For obvious reasons, the SWP, which spins its own fantasies about being an alternative to the Labour Party, prefers not to acknowledge this fact.
"Even if the LLC," continues the "Open Letter" "take control of the Labour
----- pull-quotes -----
EYEION THE NEFIT
N in their political lives, members of