Ireland: their talks and ours
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-06-20Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 12
A democratic solution to the conflict between the communities in Ireland is needed. The mainstream political parties in Northern Ireland are talking to each other for the first time in 15 years, at talks organised by the London and Dublin governments. The dif ferent factions of the British and Irish left have had little dialogue, too. But last Saturday's (15 June) Labour Party Socialists meeting decided to sponsor a new debate, and began with an exchange of views there and then. Stan Crooke reports.
(Socialist Are are socialists in Britain addressing the current government or a future Labour goverment. We are in a country which is oppressing another country on the other side of the Irish sea.
That oppression must cease. Troops Out" might sound simplistic, but it means more than just military withdrawal. It means total British disengagement and an end to all forms of oppression. It means the removal of Britain from Ireland.
Irish people in this country are bitter towards the British left and the Labour Party because of their record on Ireland. The Irish community experiences anti-Irish racism. We must relate to the Irish community in a very principled, democratic and comradely way.
The situation has gone full circle since 1968. The bringing down of Stormont was the high point of the struggle. Things have gone downhill since then, with the exception of the hunger strikes. The mass nationalist movement in Ireland is no longer on the streets.
The Brooke initiative is a fraud because the anti-imperialist party in the North has been excluded. It is an attempt to strengthen partition and the border.
Only in the period 1918-21 and during the hunger strikes did the Labour Party take up a half-decent position on Ireland. These were periods in which the Labour Party was shifting to the left.
We do not have a mass audience, only a layer of people, to address. We need to relaunch debate on Ireland in the labour movement. We must be prepared for the next shift to the left in the Labour Party.
Martin Thomas (Socialist Organiser):
he question of the troops is simple. They have carried out repressive policies and we need to be for their withdrawal. But we need a positive policy as well as a negative policy. "Troops Out" does not mean a united Ireland under a Sinn Fein government. Sinn Fein has the support of just 4% or 5% of the population. "Troops Out" on the basis of the present relationship of forces would mean civil war and repartition.
The Protestant community, or whatever you want to call it, has a clear sense of identity and is heavily armed. The removal of the apparatus of the British state would not mean the disappearance of that community. A minority would fight. There would be a civil war leading to repartition.
This would be a step forward only from a British nationalist point of view; if you work on the basis that what's bad for the British state is good for socialists.
The status quo is unacceptable; in fact it has prepared the ground for civil war. So what is the answer?
Five alternatives are put forward on the left: (1) to deny reality, for example by being blind to the existence of the Protestant community;
(2) to call for socialist revolution as the immediate way to overcome division; but you cannot have this without a united working (3) to claim that the problems are not as great as they are made out to be; but this is wishful thinking and a denial of the evidence of the last hundred years;
(4) to call, in the manner of Sinn Fein, on the British state to coerce the Protestants; but Dhor the Cath! orothy Macedo:
homogenous. It was no interest in I much for the Labour 94 KC 29 Socialists must debate the issues. Photo: Martin Shakeshaft.
this is the opposite of self-determination, and Britain has neither the desire nor the ability to do so; (5) to link the call for "Troops Out" to a programme for a democratic solution to the conflict between the communities in Ireland, a federal united Ireland with regional autonomy. This is not a policy for implementation by the British state, but a programme of action for unity to be carried out by the Irish people, by the Irish labour movement, and, in the first instance, by the Irish left. A federal united Ireland with regional autonomy might not be the best solution but no-one has come up with a better one. The important thing is to at least recognise the problem and seek a solution.
"Neither the Protestant nor the Catholic communities are homogenous. In British politics there was no interest in Ireland before 1969: so much for the Labour front bench's argument that if only the violence stopped, then a solution could be found. 'Troops Out' is not the be-all-and-end-all. "
Neither the Protestant ›ic communities are 1 British politics there eland before 1969: so front bench's argument that if only the violence stopped, then a solution could be found. "Troops Out" is not the be-all and end-all. We have the right to come up with solutions, but we do not have the right to say that we won't support the demand of the Irish people for self-determination unless they support such and such a particular solution.
Bill Hamilton: Socialists in Britain should fight to have an input into the creation of a new Ireland, to make it as socialist as possible. The problem about federalism is that the Protestants don't want to be reconciled with the Catholics. But there should be the maximum amount of local democracy in a new united Ireland. Ruth Cockroft: Unless we address the issue of the Protestant community we will not build a movement in this country for a united democratic Ireland. Aspects of the Southern Irish constitution are institutionalised Catholicism. We need to address such issues, not just say that we're for a united Ireland. "Troops Out" is irresponsible if raised by itself, as it ducks the result of what "troops out" means by itself.
Tony Serjeant: It is wrong to see Ireland as a classic colonial situation. British banks are active in Southern Ireland, but Japanese banks are even more active in America. Does that make America a colony of Japan?
Terry Conway: The fact that I think Ireland is an oppressed nation does not mean that I don't recognise the existence of a Protestant community. But Ireland is not the only place in the world where imperialism has created a settler population.
The Protestant community is not homogenous. It is divided, not least along class lines. It does not help to use labels like Protestant and Catholic in a discussion as this entrenches such identity. No-one is talking about gluing together the 6-county and 26-county states. The laws in Northern Ireland on women and the rights of lesbians and gays are terrible. Martin referred to the "unity of the Irish trade union movement" but this is mainly unity for collaboration with the states North and South, and for selling out struggles. Ruth seemed to be saying "we don't support 'troops out' unless..." which is not what Martin was saying. You cannot support conditionality.
Nof Ttofias: There's nothing unusual about a trade union bureaucracy selling out struggles, but that doesn't make unity irrelevant. Hopefully we agree that there are two distinct communities in the North. But what Terry says clouds over that, as religion is a part of the identity of those communities. If partition were, somehow, to disappear, then those communal identities would not disappear.
Bill is right to say that the Protestants don't want conciliation, but we do. We need a programme or a policy which begins to talk about that.
Federalism should be put forward as an option, not as prescription. We need to widen out the debate, and debate with sections of the Irish left."
Declan O'Neill: The crucial question is why Britain is in Ireland. I am increasingly convinced that Britain has no economic, political or military interest to stay in Ireland. It would pull out if it could do so without creating instability; Federalism should be put forward as an option, not as a prescription. We need to widen out the debate, and debate with sections of the Irish left.
Cate Murphy: The Protestants are al distinct community and have rights which we should protect, whilst being against any privileges for them. Unless you recognise the existence of a Protestant community, you're not talking about self-determination for all people in Ireland, but only for Catholics., Pete Firmin: We have a right to say what we think of events in Ireland, but this needs to be put into context - that of solidarity with the struggle against British oppression in Ireland.
If the left has not built a mass movement on Ireland because of its own political mistakes, why could it not win over public opinion in the Gulf war when it had a correct position? Martin assumes that the working class in Ireland will always be the way it is now, without challenging the way they think. Federalism is a sop to their present consciousness, but not one which gets to the roots of the problem - the loyalty of the Unionists to the British state.
Socialist Organiser does not campaign for a Scottish Assembly, although Scottish people want one. But it calls for federalism in Ireland, although Irish people are not demanding it. There is a contradiction there.
Martin Thomas: There is no one solution which has majority support amongst even one community in Ireland. 70% of the Irish population (in Southern Ireland) already have self-determination. 20% of the population (the Protestant community) have self-determination, as they want to be part of the British state. 10% of the population (the Catholic community in the North) are opposed to the status quo. "Self-determination" is just a meaningless word unless you explain how it will be achieved.
Bob Whitehead: Ireland is very volatile politically. The essential problem is political, hence the use of terms such as Loyalist and Nationalist. It is a political conflict generated by an unresolved national question.
The way forward for Loyalist workers is a united country and a socialist future. I don't say it very loudly because I'm in Britain.
Rights for Protestants? Yes. Religious freedom? Yes. The right to a house in preference to Catholics? No.
Scan page 13
Jan