Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Fight for a general election! For a Labour government

Socialist Organiser no. 490, 20 June 1991 · scan pp. 10–12 · about 2,988 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

*National Union of Railwaymer WF -POTLAN" STRICT CIL 3y John Mcllroy Getting rid of Thatcher Gagrecing to replace the poll tax have not solved the Tories' problems. But the left has its own problems, too.

The development of general election fever has been accompanied by an outbreak of incoherence and a rash of adventurism.

The three major factors in the run-up to the general election are the growth of a broad consensus between Labour and Tory leaders; the instability, exhaustion and loss of vision of the Conservatives; and, crucially, the economic recession and its impact on the working class.

The first six months of Major's premiership have seen an increasing convergence of the three main parLICS Since 1983 Kinnock has moved Labour to the right and increasingly adapted to Thatcherism. Major has now attempted to move the Tories away from Thatcherism and meet the "new" Labour Party.

But the new "social market" consensus is still limited and contradictory. Major's pledge to end ation and minor increases in welfare (such as abolishing tax relief for top rate mortgage payers and index-linking child benefit), the talk of a citizen's charter, all these represent a move only to a pallid parody of the EC social market.

The aspirations symbolised by the appointment of the Christian Democrat Chris Patten as chair of the Tory Party is constrained by internal opposition among the Tories but, above all, by the economic situation. To take one example, a rise in unemployment of 100,000 produces an increase in spending on benefits of £350 million.

Increased unemployment has to privatise railways and thus cut into the Treasury's contingency reserves and limited the possibilities of increasing expenditure in electorally sensitive areas such as the NHS and education.

The legacy of Thatcherism still stalks the land.

Similar problems afflict policy on Europe. Major and his cabinet have taken a clear decision to go for monetary union at the EC intergovernmental conference in December, although they intend to negotiate hard.

They have had to indulge in manoeuvre and subterfuge to defuse internal opposition. The sniping of Thatcher, the fulminations of the Bruges group and "Those caught up adventures and shori cuts can only weaken the fight a Labour government.

Ridley, the motion signed by I05 MPs, attempting to tie Major's hands on monetary union - all these demonstrate the difficulties the Tory leaders face in sloughing off the legacy of Thatcherism.

So Labour is reaping the benefits of the new consensus. It is increasingly portrayed in contrast to the Tories as sane, sensible, stable and firmly under leadership control.

On the home front Labour has become "arguably" , as the Financial Times puts it, "the most conservative force in British politics."

Kinnock has accepted the fundamentals of the Thatcher settlement. He stands to it as Churchill and Eden stood in 1951 to the OF reforms 1945 ment.

Labour, too, is now the party of the market against planning; of privatisation against public ownership; of incentives and efficiency against redistribution and equality; of individual rights against trade union "privileges"

As the policy document Looking to the Future states: *We welcome and endorse the efficiency and realism which markets can provide."

Increases in public expenditure will depend on growth. Labour's language is taken straight from Thatcher's larynx: "We will not spend nor will we promise to spend more than Britain can afford." There will be "no irresponsible dash for growth""

Anti-union laws will stay in place and the European Exchange Rate Mechanism (ERM) will be the central weapon for disciplining the working class, "creating a new framework for wages and costs."

The continued differences between Labour and Tories in the new consensus centre on the degree of state intervention in economic decision-making.

Major will still have none of such Eaboumic Assessment, the National Investment Bank, Skills UK, a more interventionist Department of Trade and Industry, and a new panoply of quangos. Major wants to privatise coal and parts of the railways. Kinnock doesn't.

The choices within the new consensus have little to offer The working class. But the present position may prove temporary. After the coming contest — whether in government or in opposition — Labour will face an explosive situation which will provide greater opportunities for the left.

A Conservative victory will provide Major with the opportunity to The slump returns... consolidate social marketism. A defeat may see a resurgence of Thatcherism.

The left can influence this situation. We can do this best by making a choice, by taking sides.

The Tories are still the main enemy. And Labour is still the party of the working class and the unions.

he Tories remain the central party of the ruling class. The Labour Party's Finance and Industry group claims to have in membership "over 100 senior industrialists who back Labour" . But at the moment these remain mavericks and should not distract attention from the fact that the great mass of capital is totally for the Tories.

This is not because of any belief that Labour's policies would endanger capitalism. The capitalists' true concern is that while Labour's policies are capitalist, its support is working class.

The party - and indirectly a Labour government — is organisationally and financially dependent upon the bedrock working class organisations — the trade unions.

Kinnock has worked wonders in limiting this crucial problem. He has weakened Labour's links with the unions, curbed internal democracy, centralised power and circumscribed the rights of CLP activists. As far as capital is concerned, he has not gone far enough and the danger remains.

he recession which began in mid 1990 is still deepening.

We have just witnessed the fourteenth monthly increase in unemployment. It now stands officially at 2.24 million, almost 8%.

The key problem for the Tories is the difficulty of engineering any qualitative change in the economic situation before an election.

The Unemployment Unit reports there are already 3.3 million unemployed on the basis of calculation used betore 1979, and that the figure will top four million in 1992.

This unemployment is not concentrated in manufacturing and the North. It is affecting service industries and the South very severely: 48,000 of the 113,000 seasonallyadjusted increase in the jobless figure in March came from London and the South East.

The six recent cuts in interest rates bringing base rates down to 11.5% have not improved the situation. Large scale redundancies continued to be declared in engineering, electronics and former public utilities.

Company insolvencies rose by a fifth in the first quarter of 1991 compared with the last quarter of 1990, and two-thirds compared with the first quarter of last year. Investment in both manufacturing and service industries continues to drop, and the government predicts a 9% fall in manufacturing output in 1992.

The only comfort for the Tories lies in the inflation and earnings figures. The UK's annual inflation rate dropped to 5.8% in May, the lowest figure since summer 1988.

However, this drop, produced by the disappearance from the figures of the poll tax effect of April 1990, lower mortgages, and a squeeze on retailers' margins, still leaves UK inflation higher than the EC average of 5%, Moreover, if mortgage interest is excluded, the "underlying" rate of inflation is 6.6%. This underlying rate has been increasing and no significant fall is expected in the near tuture.

The CBI's pay databank shows the average level of wage settlements in the second quarter of 1991 running at around 7% compared with an expected 8%. Incomes Data Services estimate that the majority of pay deals are now between 6% and The first Thatcher recession of 1979-82 enabled Thatcher to make a breakthrough in utilising unemployment and legislaton to weaken the unions.

There are clear differences this time. The Tories have overdrawn their credibility.

However, the working class is weaker and the left is weaker. There are four million fewer trade unionists today than there were in 1979. We still live in the shadow of important defeats, from the miners' strike of 1985-5 to the docks dispute of 1989.

On the other hand, many workers have seen their living standards increase in the late 1980s as wages outstripped inflation. Both sides of the coin induce caution.

The number of strikes in 1990 was the lowest since 1935. There have been no major confrontations over job cuts. Workers have acquiesced in pay freezes at Michelin, Philips. IBM. and Thomas Cook,

Scan page 11

Our orientation might be 'You think Kinnock will deliver a little bit more? We think you will have to fight for every penny you get and for every The AEU reported a loss of 90,000 jobs in manufacturing between February and May with minimal resistance.

On the other hand, wage deals running at 6-7% when 3 million are unemployed show that the employers too are exercising caution - witness the partial retreat at Rolls Royce.

The recession is driving the working class into political opposition to the Conservatives. However the blows of the Thatcher years mean that workers look towards Labour with few illusions. They expect only small improvements. We do not have the great hopes and the great demands of 1945 — or even 1964 The working class is looking essentially towards a general election and a change of government. That underlines the importance of politics but it should not blind us to the dangers of not fighting now. If job losses and wage cuts are not resisted now, and the second Thatcher recession works through like the first, it may mean a fundamental weakening of the unions and an important restructuring of the working class in the interests of capital.

We must fight for a general election, and fight the effects on the working class of the recession.

abour stands at around 44% of the vote. The Conservatives, at •34%, are only one point up on their rating the day before Thatcher went. Since January the Tories have lost an 11% lead.

And little more than a year ago Labour's lead over Thatcher was 22%. The present 11% lead could be clawed back in the coming months; as an election approaches there is usually a tendency for support to swing back to the governing party.

A swing back is all the more likely as the present Labour lead is motivated by a negative reaction to the Tories, not a positive embrace of Kinnockism.

There is no room whatsoever for comes every vote will count.

le should organise our involvement over the coming period around the following ten key points:

(1) Campaign for tion! General elections are important to the working class and important to us.

The right to vote for a government once every five years shows how far the working class has to go and the limits of democracy. But it represents a gain and a right which must be exercised.

The question of who forms the government is one of burning importance.

Every day the Tories stay in goverment sanctioned by the so-called prerogative of the Prime Minister to set the election date, they are enabled to deliver further attacks on the working class. We are for the old demands of annual, fixed term parliaments. We campaign for their practical realisation by campaigning to kick out the Tories and for a general election.

(2) Don't wait for an election! Campaigning for an election does not mean for one minute that we soft-pedal the direct struggles that are going on now against the bosses and the state.

We are for strengthening action on the industrial front, against the poll tax, and against the leadership's attempts to throw out socialists and suppress activity and democracy within the Labour Party itself.

(3) The Tories are the main enemy. We must avoid a simplistic anti-Toryism which polishes up Labour. Nonetheless, the tacks on our class this century has been the Tory party, and this has been even more so since 1979.

Yes, Labour too will attack the working class. But despite its capitalist policies and its desire to make the producers bear the cost of Britain's economic decline, it remains the organised expression of the working class movement, linked organically to its primary institutions of struggle, the trade unions.

The Labour Party is supported by the majority of the working class and by the majority of working-class activists. For them and for us a Labour victory in the election is the only available means of removing Major, Lamont and Heseltine.

(4) For a Labour government!

The election of a Labour government may produce few and slim immediate benefits. In fact, few sections of the working class have great expectations of LabourA recent report on the UK by N PERSPECTIVE Nomura, the leading Japanese securities house, rightly rubbishes Tory propaganda that Kinnock has some hidden left agenda.

It argues that in the aftermath of an election victory he would swing further right and go back on the limited promises he has given. Pressure on the pound in the ERM after a Labour win at the polls might well produce higher interest rates, downward pressure on growth, increased unemployment and a pause on public expenditure.

This is all perfectly possible, even very likely. We do not urge a vote for Labour because a Labour government will of itself deliver reforms and improve the position of the working class.

We urge such a vote because with Kinnock in government and attacking the workers in practice, rather than as now on paper and in wordy rhetoric, the prospects of awakening the movement and organising a fight back will be better.

We urge such a vote because the election of a Labour government will improve the terrain on which the class fights, boost its fighting ability and enable a minority to see the need to go beyond Kinnock.

(5) For a critical vote for Labour. The stability of capitalism, the downturn in struggle, the weakness of the left, the nature and success of Kinnockism - all of these mean that campaigns centred around "For a workers' government" or "Labour to power on a socialist programme" do not meet the needs of the situation.

We are far from 1945, 1974 or even 1983. Only an idiot believes that Kinnock will introduce socialist policies.

Our orientation might be expressed as follows: "You think Kinnock will deliver a little bit more? We think you will have to fight for every penny you get and for every small improvement.

"Let us fight together. Vote Labour and prepare to fight!"

(6) Our Campaigning Demands. At the same time we should be raising wider demands and socialist alternatives and answers within our campaign for a Labour government. But we should not impute their realisation to Kinnock.

Central are the fight against wage controls and the fight for a "workers' charter" to replace the Tories' anti-union legislation with positive rights to organise, to strike, to picket, and take solidarity action.

(7) Stay in and fight! Get in and light. To comrades leaving ol thinking of leaving the Labour Par ty, disillusioned or worn out by the blows of Kinnockism and the defeats of the left, we say, "Don't commit political suicide at the very moment the means of deliverance are being pressed into your hand"

The best means of influencing and controlling a Labour government is through activity in both the unions and the Labour Party.

(8) There is no alternative! For the maximum Labour vote! The election could be close...The future of the working class is involved.

Every vote counts.

There is no present alternative to Labour, and no immediate possibility of building one.

Neither the Socialist Movement nor the SWP nor the Liverpool co-ordinated needed.

Org fight!

Broad Left is even the embryo such an alternative.

Those caught up in adventures and short-cuts can only weaken the fight for a Labour government. Those who, like the SWP, abstain from this struggle only help the Tories.

Those who argue that whether we support Labour Party or alternative" candidates depends on an examination of each case — on the local strength of the left and the base for defiance (suitably viewed through magnifying glasses) - will be seen correctly as dilettantes. They will cut themselves off from any influence with the majority of Labour-voting workers, weaken the credibility of the left and ease the way of the witch-hunt. We are against "protest politics in one neighbourhood"!

(9) No coalition! No pacts! In the event that no one party has enough seats to form a government, we are opposed to Labour entering coalition or forming a minority government as part of a pact with Major or, more probably, Ashdown.

In a coalition Kinnock would be able to blame his partners. He would become directly answerable to the bourgeois parties, not labour and the unions.

(10) Don't write the Tories off! The Tories could still win. There is still a long way to go.

Just as we need to arm the workers against a Kinnock government so we have to contemplate the possibility of a further period of Tory rule.

This would unleash major strug gles within the Labour Party, but it could also lead to demoralisation -particularly amongst young comrades whose expectations are likely to be higher - unless we guard against it.

campaign on this kind of basis A around •Socialists for Labour" can enable us to unite the left — or at least those on the left who wish to eschew diversions, adventures, stunts and salon politics, in favour of the tundamental nhiective of removing the Tories and replacing them with -abour government.

Scan page 12

Socialist Organiser No. 490 page 12

----- pull-quotes -----

the poll tax, the pumping in of billions to reduce poll tax bills in the meantime, the small reforms in tax-

complacency. There is still a lot to fight for and when the election

originators and orchestrators of the most powerful and successful at-

orientation might expressed as follows: small improvement. 'Let us fight together. Labour and prepare to

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 490

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →