Oppose the redundancies and campaign for Labour!
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-06-20Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 9
not convinced of the wisdom of standing independent candidates.
Only one out of the six independent candidates, for example, was actually a Militant supporter, and he stood only after an unsuccessful attempt to get a non-Militant to stand in the ward concerned.
Five out of the six independent candidates won. The non-Militant members of the BL believed, however naively, that by standing independent candidates and winning they could negotiate their tefighters the Labour Partyl tionally.
An 'independent' DLP would undoubtedly meet with initial success, they argued, in the short term, but would have undermined the long-term struggle to transform the Labour Party in a leftward direction.
Through the trade unions, the Labour Party possesses a big reservoir of support.
Six million workers are affiliated to the Labour Party through the political levy. Superficial commentators, both of the capitalist class and the ultra-left fringe outside of the Labour Party, usually dismiss this as being a mere relic of the past political allegiances of workers to the Labour Party. However, when the Tories attempted to break the link through enforced political fund ballots, the results not only astonished them, but also the leadership of the movement and the assorted critics of the political levy.
Every single union with a political fund recorded majorities, sometimes of a quite spectacular admission to the Labour Group on the City Council from a position of strength.
But the degree of success went to the heads of many members of the BL. It certainly went to the heads of Militant supporters. When Eric Heffer died and Peter Kilfoyle was endorsed as the Labour candidate, Militant jumped in with both feet to ensure that Mahmood was put up as a candidate.
The rest of the story and electioneering.
nature, in favour of retaining the levy. Some trade unions that did not even have a political fund adopted them as a result of the Tories' attempt to break the link between the unions and the Labour Party.
The mass of the working class, sc the Militant Editorial Board argued, while passively supporting the Labour Party, had not yet ac tively moved into its ranks.
They argued that for one worker who had supported an 'indepen dent' DLP, there would be anothel five, ten and perhaps 100 at a late! stage who would move into the of ficial Labour Party. These worker would be denied contact with th best fighters who would have con stituted themselves into an 'independent' DLP.
This left wing, particularly witl the tremendously rich experience of the last three and a half years could be a vital yeast for the rise o an even more spectacular mas movement in Liverpool in th future.
Things have changed since 1985, An interview with a meml of Liverpool Labour Party Socialists canvassing for Labour in Walton How can you justify campaigning for a witch-hunting Kinnockite loyalist like Kilfoyle?
It's not a question of canvassing for Kilfoyle as an individual, but of campaigning for a vote for Labour. Kilfoyle is a right-winger but so are a lot of other Labour MPs and aspiring MPs. A Kinnock-led government will be right-wing — but does that mean you should not campaign for Labour in a General Election? In any case, Mahmood's left-wing credentials are not all they are cracked up to be.
Do you think left-wingers should just make a few token appearances in Walton to show their support for the Labour candidates? No, I think the opposite. The leftshould be out in Walton as much as possible.
The left should be on the doorstep arguing that you can oppose compulsory redundancies amongst the council workforce, that you can oppose Kinnock's sell-outs at national level, and still be a member of the Labour Party. Not to do so means handing the campaign over to the right wing.
If Mahmood does well, it will only encourage silly people elsewhere to run independent candidates against Labour in a General Election in safe Labour seats. This will result in activists being pulled out of campaigning in Tory marginals, thus increasing the chances of the when the discussion reported by Taaffe and Mulhearn took place! Every change, both in Britain generally and inside the labour movement, strengthens the arguments against breaking with Labour and speaks to condemn Militant's little adventure in the Walton by-election.
The Tories have been in power for five and a half additional years. The left in the Labour Party has declined considerably. Strike figures are the lowest for 50 years. The Militant-led left has heavily discredited itself.
The whole Liverpool District Labour Party does not back Militant in Walton. Militant had not enough support in Walton to win the nomination there. They are "forced" to lie in their election leaflets, suggesting that they won the nomination but Kilfoyle was then imposed from London.
The Walton candidacy is not part of an advancing offensive working-class movement. It grows out of defeat and weakness, and out of Militant's growing sectarianism.
If Militant is right to split the Liverpool labour movement now, then Derek Hatton was right in 1985! Tories being re-elected.
Dead-end sectarians who don't care about the result of a General Election won't be worried about this. Socialists who live in the real world will be. Mahmood must not only be defeated, but be decisively so.
What has been the response on the doorstep so far?
It's dangerous to generalise from the limited amount of canvassing I have done so far, but the vast majority of responses have been pro-Labour. Even some traditional Liberal and Tory voters have said that they might vote Labour just to make sure Mahmood does not get in, and to show what they think of Militant.
The handful of Mahmood supporters I have come across say they are voting for her because Kinnock's record and the issue council redundancies. It's very much a passive protest vote. Anyone who thinks it is a vote Militant's "bold socialist programme" is living in cloudcuckoo-land, along with the people who decided to put up Mahmood.
The problem for socialists is that because Militant is equated with the left, opposition to Mahmood easily flows over into opposition to left-wing politics in general. Kilfoyle and his fellow-travellers are only to happy to encourage this. Again, this underlines the in portance of left-wingers getting i volved in the by-election campaign.
What kind of campaign is Mahmood running?
A thoroughly dishonest one. She claiming to be the real Labour candidate. You would also think, going by her election material, that this was a council by-election rather than a parliamentary by-election. Her focus, so far almost Derek Hatton (left) and Tony exclusively, is council redundancies, council rents and the poll tax The doorstep patter of her canvassers seems to be: there are two Labour candidates in this by-election. A real Labour candidate opposed to redundancies on the council, and an imposed Labour candidate who supports redundanicies. Which one are you voting for?
Mahmood wants to try to make the by-election a referendum on compulsory redundancies, whilst conveniently keeping quiet about the fact that the council budget she voted for involved setting a poll tax and freezing 50% of all council vacancies.
Mahmood has only two things go. ing for her. One is the number of people Militant is pumping into the constituency. The other is the fact that the issue of council redundancies is very important in Walton. Walton is a white, working-class area and, as a result of proven racist employment procedures by the council in the past, many council workers are drawn from this part of Liverpool. Of course, you don't find Mahmood attacking racism in Liverpool City Council.
What is the SWP doing?
Even before Mahmood was selected, the SWP in Liverpool agreed to go out and campaign fo whoever the Broad Left candidate was. Their only concern, of course, is to sell their paper and pick up recruits.
Militant are sectarians but they're not stupid. I get the impression that SWPers have been given the spadework of distributing Mahmood's turgid election material, whilst Militant go off and canvas and sell their turgid newspaper.
Who will win the election? Nothing is ever certain in politics, but it looks like a Labour victory. A split Labour vote and a high profile Liberal campaign might se the Liberals come up through the middle. Mahmood has only an outside chance but, as I said before, it's important that she is humiliated rather than just defeated.
However, once the by-election is over, the problems for the left really begin — the need to fight new wave of mass expulsions, an to fight the policies pursued by Rimmer on the Council and Kilfoyle in Parliament.
Scan page 10
ocialist Org
----- pull-quotes -----
"A Kinnock-led government will be right-wing - but does that mean you should not campaig for Labour in a General Election?"