Left unity and the left slates
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-06-20Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 5
avoid consultino lesser mortals! for this vear only, provided all will look ridiculous if it can't COUNTERPOINT n recent years the Socialist Campaign Group of MPs has usually gone through a rather ill-defined consultation process with the leaders of selected left pressure groups (notably those involved in Labour Left Liaison) about th make-up of the left slate for t NEC.
This year, even that limited consultation failed to take place.
One reason was the bitter after-taste left by the manoeuv ings which surrounded the Committee to Stop the War in the Gulf. Most left MPs had been quite disgusted by the appalling antics of members and associates of Socialist Action, who seemed determined to exclude other left groups. What should have been an exercise in maximum left unity during the biggest crisis for years became a hideous example of sectarianism.
Of course, some will say that MPs don't need much excuse to juvenating the Labour Party Young avoid consulting lesser mortals!
This year there were two vacancies on the left siate because Audrey Wise, recently elected president of USDAW, i: standing in the trade union section, and Jo Richardson has moved even more firmly into the Kinnock camp. The Socialist Campaign Group (SCG) replaced them with two men: Jeremy Corbyn and Dave Nellist.] LLL decided it could not sup port the new slate. At a meeting with SCG representatives, the Labour Women's Action Committee said that while it wanted four women and three men, a slate of four men and three women would be acceptable. for this year only, provided the candidates supported positive discrimination for women and black people. In other words, Nellist would have to go.
The next SCG meeting voted nem con to reaffirm the original seven names. Meanwhile, Labour Party Black Sections decided to put forward Greenwich councillor Kanta Patel in place of Nellist. This alternative slate was backed by the Labour Party Socialists national committee.
The Briefing Editorial Board has now voted twice to support the SCG slate, despite the problems mentioned earlier. It did so because it believed the left the behaviour of NOLS in NUS will look ridiculous if it can't agree on a credible, united slate: the only winners will be the right wing.
The Briefing EB was particularly conscious this year, fo the first time, CLPs are suppos ed to ballot all their members ti determine how their conference delegates vote in the NEC elections. We therefore need a nationally-organised, wellresourced and vigorous campaign if we are to secure a strong left vote.
Realistically, only Benn and Skinner stand any chance of b ing elected. The existence of more than one left slate will a dangerous diversion from maximising their support. to the General Election anc that the over other candidates who aren't going to be elected? Some have argued that, in that case, we might as well use this year to promote relatively unknown women. The need promote more women is undeniable, but the answer surely would be for them to stand (this year) for the Women's Division of the NEC. Last year there were no left candidates at all in this section.
This does not mean that we are insensitive to the problems with the SCG slate, nor do we accept that only MPs are suitable candidates for the NEC. But let's be honest, comrades, there have always been problems with the left slate and the way it's been drawn up. Last year, many people were unhappy about Jo Richardson being on it and it would certainly be possible to criticise other candidates on this year's slate.
Socialist Organiser, for example, which suports the replacement of Nellist by Patel, admits that "we disagree with other people on the slate at least as much" . The reason they give for picking on Nellist, ie. his association with Militant, looks unpleasantly like sectarian rivairy. Given that both groups are being witch-hunted, this is anfortunate. If we don't hang together, we shall certainly all be hanged separately. The fact that Militant has not defended Socialist Organiser does not mean we should return the com pliment.
One thing is certain:
Walworth Road and the LCC will be delighted by any evidence that we are squabbling amongst ourselves.
• This article first appeared Labour Briefing-