Scientists battle over royalties The AIDS wars
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-06-20Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 4
A defeat for Morris woule have been pretty decisive proof that racism remained a potent force in British trade unionism. As it is, By Sleeper Morris's victory represents a huge step forward for antiracism in the labour movement and for toes of the same hand. leaderships.
Aids activists demonstrate in Los Angeles admission to the USA of anyone infected "charter for members In 1984, the discovery of the virus that causes AIDS heralded a breakthrough in the understanding of the disease, one which may lead to effective treatment the members want. and perhaps even a cure.
However, it also privately favoured a Morris victory... unleashed a battle for recognition as its discoverer between Luc Montagnier of the French Institut Pasteur and Robert Gallo of the US National Institutes of Health.
This battle was not merely for prestige but involved rights to royalties from the blood test for HIV (Human Immunodeficiency Virus) infection developed by Gallo.
At present, though most royalties go to the AIDS Research Foundation, Gallo nets some $100,000 per annum.
The dispute has centred on the following facts. Montagnier's group isolated a virus from a Frenchman with AIDS in 1983. They were convinced that it was responagainst George Bush's policy of refusing by HIV sible for the disease but were unable to culture it. They named it LAV (for lymphadenopathy virus, from one of the symptoms of AIDS) and sent samples of it to Gallo's labs who were also working on the virus that caused AIDS.
Shortly after, in 1984, Gallo announced the discovery and culturing of the virus that caused AIDS - he called it HTLV-IIIB (for human T-cell leukaemia virus - type III, strain B). This name was the result of Gallo's conviction, ' since shown to be unfounded, that the virus was related to others that caused a type of leukaemia.
At first, it seemed that Gallo's group had won the race to identify the AIDS virus fair and square - and with it the right to lain amounts of money research grants and royalties. Suspicions were raised that this might not be the case when, in 1986, the genetic codes for LAV and HTLVIIIB were published. They were almost identical, differing by only 2%.
Now, when it is realised that the AIDS virus (now called HIV, for human immunodeficiency virus) is extremely variable, this similariA TH ty becomes inexplicable. HIV undergoes frequent mutations, a fact that makes the development of a vaccine extremely difficult, so much so that samples of HIV from any two people would differ in their genetic codes by 13% on average. The probability that two samples taken on different sides of the Atlantic would differ by only 2% is vanishingly small.
The only possible conclusion was that HTLV-IIIB was LAV, the small difference arising through uncertainties in the sequencing technique or through mutations in the few generations that had taken place. The only remaining question was whether the confusion had occurred deliberately or through innocent, though inefficient contamination.
The relationship between Institut Pasteur and Gallo soured rapidly and eventually the Institut took the US government to court over the rights to the royalties from the patented blood test developed by Gallo, using the LAV This did not settle the question of the origin of the original LAV/HTLV-IIB, however,. At present, the NIH are investigating Gallo's laboratories because of inconsistencies in its records though its inquiry team have publicly cleared him of the charge of stealing LAV. They said he would have no motive to do so as he had plenty of samples of his own.
The row erupted again this year when Gallo's team announced that the sample of HIV sent by the French was in fact different from LAV. Stung by this apparent demolition of their case, the French searched through their samples and records and found that they had sent several samples from one patient and that one of these had become contaminated with HIV from another patient. It was the latter which later surfaced as the fast-growing virus known as HTLV-HIB.
The result has been that. Gallo has finally admitted that the first identified AIDS virus came from the Institut Pasteur. Unfortunately, this is unlikely to be the end of a saga that has occupied the valuable time of many scientists. The various inquiries have taken up several researcher years and have temporarily halted some projects. Now, the battle for royalties will recommence, as will the Institut Pasteur's claim for compensation for its costs, estimated at E2m.
Scan page 5
Socialist Organiser No. 490 page 5