Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Manipulation and no movemen

Socialist Organiser no. 489, 13 June 1991 · scan pp. 13–14 · about 963 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 13 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 13

Kevin Feintuck, who member of Liverpool City Council from 1987 t • 1990, reviews Alan Bleasd ale's GBH Plan Bleasdale's TV series A Boys from the Blackstuff was graphic description of a layer of the working class in Liverpool, atomised by unemployment, struggling for self-respect and survival in Thatcher's Britain. His latest, much hyped, series "GBH" started on Channel 4 on 6 June.

The central theme of the new seven part series deals with a very different feature of the 1980s Labour Movement. The writer has stated that his series is not intended to deal with the experience of Liverpool during the 1983-7 period.

Having seen the first episode many viewers, myself included, will be left with the feeling that, despite his protestations, much of his material uses events, and particularly characters, from that period. As the credits to the Untouchables used to say "Only the names have been changed to protect the innocent." The only difference in Bleasdale's series may well be that the (Robert Lindsay) and Jim Nelson, the sincere, middle-class Labour Party member and head teacher of emotionally disturbed children, played by Michael Palin.

Michael Murray is a manipulating and abusing individual whose need for power appears to be closely connected with a brutalised and despised childhood.

Some of the characteristics of Murray's childhood have emerged in his conversations with his chauffeur. Other strands have been shown in a series of flashbacks, á la Dennis Potter, showing him as a victim of violence at school and hinting at other, yet-to-emerge, unpleasant activities in which Murray is the perpetrator, or at least conscious participant.

Murray also wears flash ties at interviews, shouts his opponents down at public meetings, employs eye-to-eye intimidatory techniques and threatens violence, of which more later.

The main action of the first episode is focussed around a Day of Action called by the Council to fight against an extremist and undemocratic Tory Government. The way in which the Day of Action is decided upon sums up the theme of manipulation which we can expect to see a lot more of in future episodes.

The push for action has not come from any recognisable section of the Labour Movement. The Labour Party and Trade Unions have been invisible In place of a recognisable Labour Movement, Bleasdale has created a sinister group of conspirators clustered around a University professor named Mervyn Sloan. Sloan appears to exercise a quasi-religious influence on his followers and with an eye to a half movement as such chance has instructed Murray to call the Day of Action on a date to coincide with the opening of Parliament. Murray, in return, has agreed to act as the group's mouthpiece (for reasons that are not altogether clear or convincing).

Having established their mutually advantageous relationship, Sloan's group provide cheerleaders and voting fodder in the lead up to the Day of Action. More dramatically, the Day of Action is enforced by groups of young, white, The viewer is clearly going to learn a lot more about the formative influences in Murray's childhood. We will also see Jim Nelson suffering as the well-meaning Mr Nice Guy who has confronted Murray whose confidential school papers seem to have hit the mark in describing him as damaged and disturbed.

Socialists will certainly be wondering when, or if, the Labour Movement as such will impact on this cess-pit of manipulation and intimidation. More particularly, perhaps we will learn whether Sloan's bizarre messianic sect is all that it appears. For myself, a right wing/police conspiracy seems a decent bet at this stage.

Another interesting question is whether Alan Bleasdale is capable of portraying Labour Movement politics other than as a set of blindly struggling individuals (Boys from the Blackstuff) or in the form of sinister conspiracies and grotesque parasites such as Michael Murray.

Oh, by the way, is Murray the loudmouthed, flashy-suited thug meant to represent Derek Hatton? I've read that Bleasdale has said, 'It's a disservice to me to diminish the central character Michael Murray by identifying him with Hatton. Murray is much more interesting.

I am sure the author is quite right, but I can't wait to see how Murray gets on with the firms involved in his housebuilding programme. ing their political banners with those of the petit bourgeois "Volunteers" of Patrick Pearse. He is very critical of the bourgeois nationalists.

Their brand of religiondrenched, romantic nationalism is thoroughly ridiculed. -In the end, though, this was not the main criticism O'Casev received. When the play was first shown it was booed and hissed off stage during its first week. This had been stirred up by the Republicans Sinn Feiners - focusing on its "immoral" content.

They objected to a scene in a pub with Rosie Redmond, a prostitute, who speaks openly about her work, taking the piss out of men. This was defamation of the men of the Easter week, our bravi lads; it was a disgrace, you see, to show such a woman in a Catholic country. In the confusion which followed the protests many otherwise "liberal" people (artists and so on) did not rush to defend O'Casey. 'Casey left Ireland - a country that could not tolerate his pricking at Irish myths - for good soon after.

The play is really extremely good and quite complex - it made me want to find out more about this part of Irish history_ Yet it is also a simple and very clear depiction of what happens people in struggles, how some political ideas win over others as they weave into existing traditions and prejudices.

Scan page 14

The Chartist demands of the 1830s still hold good Organiser N PERSPECT

----- pull-quotes -----

"Socialists will certainly be wondering when, if, the labour

will impact on this cess pit of manipulation and intimidation"

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 489

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →