Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

[Tony Brown reviews Silence of the Lambs what…]

Socialist Organiser no. 489, 13 June 1991 · scan p. 13 · Tony Brown · about 617 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 13 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 13

Tony Brown reviews Silence of the Lambs what is the most important part of movie making?

The cast, story, script, music, setting?

Nowadays it's got to be advertising.

The promotion of Silence of the Lambs has been remarkably effective. Plenty of advance publicity, strategic film clips on TV followed by a limited release at first, and finally widespread distribution.

Most people know what they're going to get before they even buy their ticket. Or do they?

I was prepared to be scared. I thought of asking if the cinema might keep the lights on. I knew about Hannibal the Cannibal.

But what I got was a pretty average detective story, dressed up in particularly nasty clothes.

A serial killer preying on women is on the loose and he has just taken another young woman, the daughter of a female Republican Senator. It's a race against time to find the killer before the daughter becomes another dismembered victim.

Who knows better how to capture the lunatic than another serial killer, Dr Hannibal Lecter (Anthony Hopkins)? And who better to entice him to assist the FBI than a young, attractive woman agent, Clarrice Starling (Jodie Foster)?

Lecter and Starling's relationship is really the core of the film. Lecter is portrayed as a calm, sophisticated, analytical psychologist who just happens to eat the people he kills. Starling is from the mid-west, full of suppressed feelings about her dead father. An incredible coincidence, eh?

At their first meeting Lecter manages to insinuate himself into her mind and from then on strange paternal relationship Frederick Chilton (Anthony develops.

Despite the convenience of this pairing, their scenes together are the most gripping parts of the film. Hopkins' performance is compelling. Without it the film would be no better than dozens of others of its type.

The audience is expected to overlook a number of gaping holes in the story's credibility - who could really believe either Hannibal's escape or Clarice's stumblings in Buffalo Bill's (enormous) house?

What is most objectionable, though, is the basic story. It's as if far from innocent assumed names.

The two main characters to have emerged so far are the newly elected Labour Council leader Michael Murray Heald, left) with Dr Hannibal Lecter (Anthony Hopkins) the writers sat down and tried to think up the vilest atrocities to entice a public that has become immune to horror thanks to the tabloid media.

All the women are either victims or potential victims. You wait for something to happen to them because that is the framework that is created.

This modern genre is like the tabloid press. What it portrays on screen is out of all proportion to what really happens. It plays on fears and prejudices; it adds to a fear that justifiably exists, and reaffirms it rather than confronting or except for a few placards on picket lines. The Labour Group of Councillors consists of an assortment of beer swillers, mindless yes-people and the occasional racist. combatting it.

Jonathan Demme could have made it worse but at least he refrains from gory closeups. He doesn't glorify the violence, but the subject matter is so odious that he doesn't need to to get the effect of turning one's stomach.

Hannibal Lecter is certain to enter the pantheon of demented film characters. Hopkins has signed for the almost mandatory sequel and who knows what else will be dragged up next time.

Apart from Hopkins" performance, Silence of the Lambs has no redeeming features. male activists who are shown terrorising Jim Nelson's pupils, under the direction of one of Sloan's runners.

The first episode of GBH has left a lot of unanswered questions.

----- pull-quotes -----

Alan Bleasdale's GBH: Bleasdale's GBH

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 489

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →