Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

VOTE Socialist Unity Those who do not learn from history are

Socialist Organiser no. 489, 13 June 1991 · scan pp. 12–13 · about 1,123 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 12

1979: 'Socialist Unity' tries was not a serious challenge to to give a revolutionary twist Labour's dominant right wing. to a Tory election poster. The and was therefore a stupid "Socialist Unity campaign diversionary gesture at a time ple who hated Callaghan, Socialist Unity had more to do with the competition of the IMG with the much larger SWP than with serious class politics.

That, at any rate, is where it started. It was an attempt by the IMG to exploit the contradictions in the SWP's approach to In March 1977 both the IMG and the SWP stood separate candidates in the Stechford (Birmingham) by-election. The SWP was trying to move into politics, so to speak! Both organisations got only a few hundred votes on polling day, but the IMG (with 494 votes) did noticeably better than the SWP (which got 377, though it was perhaps four times the IMG's size).

Why? Probably because the "parliament is a waste of time" , "strikes are the only answer" approach of the SWP didn't make them good vote gatherers.

Whatever the reason, bettering the big SWP cat rapidly went to the head of the small IMG mouse. From now on electioneering was their great expertise. They decided on what their discussion bulletin referred to as a "unity offensive on the SWP.

Socialist Unity in the election could, they said, mount a credible alternative to Labour. There should be united left candidates. That was the answer to traitor Callaghan and threatening Thatcher.

The excitement of being able to compete with the SWP and the flocking to them of a few hundred people desperate for a socialist choice in the election drove everything else out of their heads. They had been in the Labour Party for the previous two or three years; now, almost all of them pulled out. They re-launched their paper on the winds of success, renaming it Socialist Challenge, which, edited by the enterprising and shameless Tariq Ali, even managed to give the appearance of SWP collaboration - by reprinting Paul Foot's book reviews from a commercial magazine!

Above all, the IMG recruited. Everything now was "unity" . Unity of odds and sods on the fringes of the labour movement with each other, but not unity of serious socialists with the labour movement, for whose activists the election was a deadly serious business. Needless sectarian divorce from it, in fact.

Nor was there any unity with the SWP, either. The SWP learned the lessons of the Stechford by-election: from that day to this they have never stood in an election! Politics, they say, is for the Labour Party, which they denounce for its parliamentarianism, except for one day every four or five years when they are ardent Labour supporters.

By the election in June 1979 Socialist Unity had dwindled to six candidates. Their programme had become blurred and muzzy, and it was not revolutionary socialist. All the Socialist Unity candidates, predictably, did very badly, averaging only a few hundred votes. Not so predictably, Tariq Ali, one of the best known black men in Britain, standing in Southall where there had been much anti-racist activity, and the Labour MP had been tained with racism, got only 477 votes.

The IMG bubble had burst, but not before they had established one of the most discredited and irresponsible episodes in the recent history of the left. While the vandal Tories were marching towards power, they when the labour movement was trying to stop Thatcher.

spent their time making imaginary war on the SWP - which was busy making imaginary war on Labour (except on election day...). Both pursued self-advancement above all else.

Let it be clear what I am saying and am not saying here. If, in 1979, socialists had been in a position to make a serious, credible challenge to Labour's dominant right wing, then it would have been criminal not to have made it. Because there was no such possibility, nor any half-way serious reason to believe that there was, it was criminal to mess about.

Socialist groups compete with each other and try to recruit. Any group which says otherwise is either not long for this world or silly and hypocritical. But Socialist Unity was designed to compete with the SWP and recruit to the IMG, by engaging in manoeuvres which cut across the needs of the class struggle — which in the given circumstarices had to mean fighting for the victory of the trade unions' party, the bourgeois workers" party - the Labour Party - against the open party of big business, the Tory party.

All the big class issues and the reality around them were forgotten in the debauch of wishful thinking and sectarian opportunism.

Many on the left are today in a mood like that which generated Socialist Unity. It is not, they half-say, worth electing a Kinnock-led Labour government. They could not be more wrong.

The choices now are essentially the same as then. There is no conceivable working class based alternative government to the Tories except Labour. To say it doesn't matter is to play the Tories' game! To say that there is no choice is to abandon politics.

In fact there is a choice: if the trade unionbased party — even under a Kinnock who wants to continue Tory policies — beats the Tories it will be a tremendous release for the energies of the labour movement. With that under our belt, we can deal with Prime Minister Kinnock!

The idiocy of Socialist Unity disgraced the Labour left; it will be a shame if similar idiocies disgrace us now that it may be possible to put an end to the Tories - this time with Militant playing the role the foolish IMG played in 1979, with the victory of the five "real Labour" council candidates in the Liverpool local government elections of 1991 standing in for the IMG's "victory" at Stechford in March 1977.

And, finally, what happened to those who ran Socialist Unity? Big Flame's leaders are now among the most shameless anti-socialist witch-hunters in the Kinnockite Labour Co-ordinating Committee! Strands of the ISO/Workers' League evolved into the group around the magazine Catalyst, in the Socialist Society: the Socialist Movement AGM showed they haven't changed much! John Ross, one of the masterminds of Socialist Unity, is now a house-trained professional "left social democrat" , and Ken Livingstone's pet sycophant. The real Socialist Unity spirit seems to live on in that section of Socialist Outlook — perhaps they are the majority — which abstained at the Socialist Movement AGM on whether to advocate a vote for Labour in the next general election. Those who do not learn from history...

Scan page 13

LTURAL FRON locialist Organiser No. 489 pag

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 489

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →