The left and Labour: lessons
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-06-13Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 12
LABOUR CAN'T HANG Today, many on the left are so disgusted with the Kinnockite Labour Party that they can't control their urge to get out of the Labour Parthe Walton by-election...They should study the lessons of the labour movement!
Let us start with "Socialist Unity"s attempt to create an alternative to Labour for the 1979 general election.
One of the most striking things in the recent history of the left is the incomprehension with which a large part of the left regarded Thatcher when she was moving towards power at the end of the "70s.
The Tories had changed radically in opposition, hardened and embittered by the long series of ruling class failures over 15 years to quell the labour movement - under both Labour (1964-70 and "74-279) and Tory (1970-74) governments.
The Tories edged towards power openly determined to smash up the labour movement. They intended to inflict savage cuts, following in the pioneering tracks of the Labour government after 76. The slump that came in 1980, and the collapse of militancy that came with it, allowed the Tories to inflict tremendous damage to the labour movement. That they would succeed like that could not be predicted in 1978-9; that a Tory victory in the general election was a serious threat to the working class should have been obvious to anyone able to read newspapers.
Yet a sizeable part of the left behaved in this situation as if the Tories scarcely mattered, and as if the Labour leaders were the main enemy. They chose to ignore or brush aside all the broader questions facing the working class. They tried to act in defiance of the central political fact of life in the 1979 general election: Labour was the only alternative to the Tories. Instead of relating to the broad class questions, they mounted a miniature - token - electoral challenge to the Labour Party in a handful of seats.
This was "Socialist Unity", a broad coalition put together to mount such an electoral challenge to Labour.
Now there were very good reasons for Neil Kinnock today, they were actually in power, doing foul deeds. They ran a limping capitalist government - dependant on Liberal, and even Ulster Unionist, support for the last two years of the government's life — while they attacked the living standards of those who put the government in power, pioneered "monetarism", and initiated social services cuts at the dictat of the IMF.
Labour ran a regime of very savage repression in Northern Ireland, and in general, under James Callaghan, the Labour government did its best to serve the same capitalist class that Mrs Thatcher would serve much more ruthlessly and more effectively throughout the 1980s.
Yet, it was going to be either this government re-elected or a Tory government. More: despite its record in office, Labour was still the trade unions' party, it still retained the loyalty of progressive workers; the only sizeable defection of werkers from Labour in the 1979 general election, that of the skilled workers in the Midlands, went not to the left, but to the Tories. Its links with the labour movement normally inhibited what it could do against the working class.
For the left, the possibilities were stark:
• Support Labour, however "critically". This is what the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory did, producing its own anti-Tory propaganda which a number of Labour Parties distributed, and also warning people to prepare to fight back against Callaghan.
• Try to present itself as the possible government alternative to both Labour and the Tories.
• Throw in the towel, declare the irrelevant, that there was no choice, and advise the working class to abstain.
• Ignore the broad question of government, and the Tory threat, and mount a token "socialist" propaganda candidacy in a few constituencies.
Socialist Unity decided on the last option.
Who and what was Socialist Unity? Its core was the IMG (from which Socialist Outlook and Socialist Action and the Castroite Communist League can all claim descent). Then there was "Big Flame" group of semi-mystical quasi-Maoists.
Beyond that there was the ISO/Workers League, a group expelled from the IS/SWP "While the vandal Tories were marching towards power, Socialist Unity spent its time making imaginary war on the SWP - which was busy making imaginary war on Labour (except on election day…../* in 1975, which contained a sizeable proportion of the cadre of the IS group as it was in the late '60s and early "70s. And there was "Marxist Worker" of Bolton. Then there were quite a few unattached individuals who hated Callaghan and wanted action.
Numbers? IMG: 800-1000 perhaps; the ISO/WL had 200 at its founding conference and probably had a big periphery; Big Flame less than 100; Marxist Worker, five or six. And perhaps a few hundred "independents" As a whole, it was a conglomerate heavily middle class and white collar union in its composition.
How could this collection ever, for one single moment, have imagined itself a credible electoral force, anywhere, let alone an alternative to both the Tories and the unionbased Labour Party? At the beginning, Socialist Unity talked of standing in lots of seats, and then narrowed it down to half a dozen.
By the time of the 1979 general election, there was scarcely any pretence that it was anything but a stunt. People were advised to vote Labour, wherever there was no Socialist Unity candidate.
he truth is that Socialist Unity was something intruded into serious working class affairs — and few things in recent history have been more serious for the working class than the 1979 general election! - from the realm of irresponsible toy-town sectarian fringe "politics" And, despite the self-presentation, and its attraction for peo- FOR EVER. condemned to relive it CHEER UP!
CONSA PATE
----- pull-quotes -----
LAGAINST THE TIPE
ty. They are ripe for adventures, like Militant's "Broad Left" candidacy in