Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Will Maior become Heseltine?

Socialist Organiser no. 489, 13 June 1991 · scan pp. 11–12 · about 1,265 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 11

The more Major signals to the electorate that he is not Mrs Thatcher the more he will incur e wrath of Tebbit, John Moore d Keith Joseph of Way Forward, d, to a lesser degree, of Lilley, dwood and Rumbold of "No irning Back"

On the other hand, he has a firm se of support from those who see, any continuation of Thatcher's emory, an electoral liability, and ditional Tory loyalty to a new ider. As he faces the protracted d messy business of laying the Il tax to rest he also knows that blic attention is now firmly cused on local taxation and the ises are biased against the Convatives.

Another difficulty lies in the fact at within the ERM the pound is ervalued and cannot be devalued thout accepting an important feat. The attempt to slash inflaon that its present position reures necessitates the maintenance high interest rates and an atck on wages which, between 1979 id 1989, grew by 14% in Germany Id 145% in the UK.

There can be little change in exing policies here this side of a neral election, although they litate against a Conservative vicAfter such a victory, however, it even possible that Major, who for variety of compelling reasons re-tes incomes policy, could be conmaced of the utility of a one-off age freeze which was central to rance's successful entry into M. After all, everything else has en tried in the unavailing struggle break wage pressure and a freeze ild have a useful trade-off in eping down unemployment. Conservative policy in the run-up the election is likely to differ from the Thatcher inheritance basically in relation to Europe, the welfare state and social policy, and its discarding of any new radical experiments. Mrs Thatcher's attacks on the NHS and education will be reversed in terms of expenditure cuts and privatisation. But the moves towards an internal market for the NHS and opting out" for schools will continue. It is likely that Major will accept the limits of Thatcher's attempts to cut back on expenditure on the welfare state. The unions are out and they will stay out. They have nothing to offer.

Major's "social liberalism" is also likely to be reflected in a softer approach to law and order, immigration policy, sexuality and the family. However, the "liberalism" side is likely to lead to a continuation of the privatisation policies the Conservatives judge to be so successful with coal, sections of the Post Office and parts of British Rail the main candidates for selling off.

Winning the election will now be central and Major is likely to ignore criticism from the guardians of Thatcherite economics who warn him against his image as a "nice chap with a cheque book" , and who, like The Economist, fear that if the small increases in public expenditure are "the first trickle of a broader flood of pre-election spencurb inflation" • At the moment, in keeping with the best traditions of the Tories, winning is all.

Over the longer term it is likely that the pressures from the failure of Thatcherism from the gradual, if contested, process of EC integration, and from the electorate, will turn Major further in the direction of the policies proposed by Heseltine — an approach which is essentially that of the continental Christian Democratic parties and increasingly that of the British Externally, EC integration will be a prolonged, contradictory and uneven business. But Major's unwillingness to set it as his objective will increase constructive and fertile contact, bring the UK into the European mainstream and foreground emulation of the organisation of state and industry in Germany and France.

The latest example of those internal pressures is the report of the House of Lords Select Committee on Science and Technology, "Innovation in Manufacturing Industry" , chaired by Lord Caldecote, chair of 3i - the venture capital group — and including prominent industrialists such as Lord Keaton, formerly of Courtaulds, and Lord Gregson, a director of the Farey Group, which claims that lack of state support for industry is damaging to the economy and the "national interest"

It argues thạt *there was no investment in manufacturing industry during the 1980s...if market forces alone are to determine the course of events it is conceivable that we will end up with no significant British-owned manufacturing industry in the UK." It found that Britain was the only country in which expenditure on R&D has declined as a percentage of GDP during the 1980s and that this was due to a reduction of government support. Capital investment as a proportion of GDP was "well below that of most of our major competitors".

None of this will mean the end of the present attacks on the working class. They will involve a new and more consensus-based approach to expanding the progress made by Thatcher in decisively weakening the working class. But increasingly the glaring weaknesses of chaotic communications, inadequate transport, shortages of skilled labour whilst millions are unemployed and investment drought whilst millions flow abroad, the limits of Thatcherism and the market in ensuring accummulation, will prompt the rehabilitation of state intervention.

This has already been observed by the keen eye of Thatcher herself. She remarked in early 1991: *I see a tendency to try to undermine what achieved and go back to more powers for government" (Sunday Times, 10 March 1991). It will be fought hard by Thatcher loyalists. But in the end, in the way of the Conservative Party, Thatcher will be safely iconised and in practical terms castrated.

What we will see is a further example of the dialectic of continuity and change we have observed throughout the history of the Conservative Party. Like his predecessors Major will change the Party - although we can safely leave military coups to Militant and General Grant. Major will go with the tide because he is a pragmatist and because such an approach is more consonant with the requirements of Conservatism and capital in the 1990s.

Heseltine was the wrong man at the wrong time. A premature antiThatcherite, he lost the leadership battle, but he could still win the war over policy.

The precise details of the "when", , "what" , and "how" of change will depend on numerous factors. The most important in the short term will be the result of the coming election. With the recession deepening and passing from services and the switch to manufacturing and the north, and presently looking deeper than the trough of a year ago, with unemployment already over 2.5 million, interest rates at 13%, inflation still at 9%, the poll tax still on the books, with £1.6 million arrears, and with a leader deeply implicated in every one of these failures, the result should be a foregone conclusion. After all, it has been the electorate's belief in the Tories' superior economic competence which has given them the edge in recent elections.

If he can pull it off against all odds, possibly the worst electoral background any government party has faced since 1945, it will be a great achievement by Major and his party. But he will owe such a crucial and unrepayable debt to Neil Kinnock that, under the superficial trappings, the achievement will really be that of Kinnock and the Labour leadership.

If Major wins the next election one of his first and most enjoyable duties will be to offer Neil Kinnock a knighthood.

Scan page 12

ser

----- pull-quotes -----

ding, it will make a nonsense of the government's professed desire to

If Major all the odds... the achievemen will really that of Kinnock.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 489

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →