Militant's failure
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-06-13Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 9
Broad Left" has organised a -akaway "Real Labour Party" in -erpool. They won five seats in council elections, and are now untesting Eric Heffer's parliamen-y seat in Walton.
The story briefly outlined above Is these developments into Espective.
The split in the Liverpool Labour -ty is a product of the defeats woblem for the 'Rea abour Party' is that me main architects I defeat, the people who made such a ffered by the left.
In terms of credibility, the prom for the "Real Labour Party"
hat the people at its head, Miliwere the main architects of eat, the people who made such a culous noisy hash of things en they had control of the coun Around the "Real Labour Pargrouping are also many workers desperately want some means ight back against both the Kinkite Labour council and the ry government.
evertheless, they are misled. A paratively tiny breakaway such Heirs can only result in making Liverpool Labour Party safer the Kinnockites. That would be and it would be a great politica error even if it were just a straightforward breakawy by outraged honest Labour Party people.
In fact, the breakaway is dominated by Militant, which has a powerful political machine. This is inevitably going to turn out to be a self-promoting stunt by Militant...
Lesley Mahmood scarcely bothers with the "Broad Left" or "Real Labour Party" name tags: she is, she says, publicly, Militant's candidate.
Socialists other than those who support Militant have no reason to support this stunt.
Socialist workers in Liverpool should refuse to accept this split in the labour movement. They should continue to demand that all those expelled in Liverpool be readmitted to the Party, that the structures of the Liverpool Labour Party be re-established on a democratic basis, and that there should be a new, open and democratic selection meeting to choose a united labour movement candidate in Walton.
The danger of letting in the Liberal Democrats must be a real one. The Liverpool labour movement should demand of Mahmood that she stand down and join the campaign for a new selection meeting.
If on polling day Mahmood and Kilfoyle are both on the ballot paper, then vote for the official Labour candidate.
The central task of the labour movement now is to get the Tories out and put in a Labour government. In the best case the breakaway in Liverpool and its candidate in Walton would be a diversion from this.
In this case, it is part of a selfpromoting stunt by the organisation that inflicted Derek Hatton on Liverpool, and presided over the grotesque antics of the mid '80s there. It deserves to be thoroughly condemned by everyone who has the real interests of the working class at heart. May Nov '83 May '84 July "84 Labour makes gains in elections for one-third of Liverpool City Council's seats and wins the Council from the Liberals (who have controlled it since 1973). Militant supporters are central in the new council Labour group20,000 people join a march to support the Labour council's demand for the return grant money withdrawn over the years by the Tory government.
Budget day for the council. Despite a on day strike by council workers and a big demonstration at the Town Hall, Labour's 'unbalanced' no-cuts budget is defeated by Labour right-wingers voting with the Liberals and Tories. Derek Hatton All other budgets are defeated too.
New council elections. Labour wins a solid majority. An opinion poll indicates that 55% of Labour voters would back a local general strike if the Tories intervened against the council. Mar '85 But the Militant-led Labour council does not vote through the unbalanced budget. The mass campaign is wound down in favour of negotiations with the Tory government. This is the decisive turning point when confrontation with the government could have linked up with the miners' strike and given a lead to all other councils. June '85 The council leaders announce a deal with the government.
Some of the financial problems are postponed to the next year, and the council can gel through with a 17% rate rise. Militant call it "a 95% victory", but the Tories are quietly satisfied: they Sept "85 have evaded the dange of a fight on two fronts, miners and local government, at the same time.
Oct '84 The Council appoints Sampson Bond, a Militant supporter, as its race relations officer, against the strong opposition of the City's Black Caucus. The ensuing row wrecks the Council Unions' Joint Shop Stewards' Committee and alienates Liverpool's black community. Throughout the country - in LYS branches for example - Militant wages a savage campaign of racist stereotyping against the leaders of the Black Caucus, denouncing them as "Pimps and Gangsters".
The miners, defeated, are forced back to work.
Liverpool Labour Council has not yet said anything definite about plans for a confrontation with the government over the budget for the financia year starting April 1985. Instead it delays setting a budget - a policy also followed by a few other Labour councils.
Councillors propose a budget with a 20% rate rise and some financial juggling to see them through the year without a showdown. The council workers* unions say no. The Council sets an 'unbalanced' budget — yet starts no clear campaign for action.
The Council announces that it is about to run out of cash and will issue 90 days redundancy notices to all employees "as a legal device" . The council unions protest. The council leaders withdraw the notices.
The council shop stewards call a ballot for an all-out strike.
The vote goes against a The council leaders send out the redundancy notices again — some by taxi to bypass a teachers' picket line. NALGO members strike in protest. 5-11 Oct Labour Party Conference. Neil Kinnock makes great play of de nouncing Liverpool Council for sending out the redundancy notices. The Liverpool left is not yet totally isolated - David Blunkett from the plat form, hypocritically of fers them help - but isolation will come over the next year. The Council is forced to withdraw the redundancy notices by legal action brought by the NUT. It proposes another "legal device' - laying off the whole council workforce from 1-28 January!
Labour's National Executive sets up a kangaroo court 'inquiry' into Liverpool District Labour Party. This is simply the Kinnock faction seizing its chance.
The Council announces a deal. It gets a loan from Swiss banks on condition that it makes cuts and stays legal in future. It reveals that the required cuts have already, quietly, been made! And it soon comes out that the loan had been negotiated back in August! The entire saga of redundancy notices, taxis, clashes with the workforce ete is rendered inexplicable. To this day Militant has offered ne credible account of what it thought it was doing. Liverpool, the Council that dared to fight by Peter Taaffe and Tony Mulhearn relies on lies and bom bast.
Mar "86 A court declares that the Liverpool Labour councillors must be surcharged and disqualified because of their delay in setting budget.
The Council sets a budget implying cuts. In July 1986 the District Labour Party is given details of £12 million cuts.
Militant supporters vote them through. Oct 86 Labour Party Conference approves the expulsion of Derek Hatton and other leading Militant people from Liverpool, with opposition only from the hard left.
Since 1986 the Liverpool Labour Parties have faced repeated purges and suspensions - which have, however, failed to create a safe, controlled, Kinnockite local party.
Scan page 10
John Mellroy series on the Thatcherism I the problems John Major The election of John Major as Mrs Thatcher's successor on 27 November 1990 clearly demonstrated the problems the Party faced. Major received 185 votes against Michael Heseltine's 131, and Douglas Hurd's 56. Not merely did he lack the overall majority required by the party rules (he became leader technically not by election but by the withdrawal of Heseltine and Hurd from a third round of voting), but he received far fewer votes than the falling Thatcher's 204 in the first round a week previously. -In essence the election was not about Major but about Heseltine. One choice was to keep Thatcher and sit out the crisis with gritted teeth. After the first ballot this was no longer possible. The immediate choices then were for a shallow cosmetic approach, dropping Thatcher as a figurehead because she was an electoral liability, sprinkling around a little largesse in a less strident tone but basically standing firm on Thatcherism, or, and this was what Heseltinism was about, introducing changes of substance and a relatively clear break with key aspects of the policies of the past; or, and this was what Major stood introducing more gradual modulated nuanced changes.
Heseltine demonstrated that the first approach was finished and he provided, through his polarised opposition to Thatcher, the opportunity for the third approach, which would base itself firmly on continuity with Thatcher but feed off the corpus of Heseltine's policies for change.
This process could be seen almost -12 apporters put tell вощен Socialist Organiser No. 489 page 10 concludes his failure of ly sketching confronting leading Militant people Since 1986 the Liverpool Labour immediately from the fashion in which, given Thatcher's continued support for what only a few days previously she had brought herself to call the poll tax, and Heseltine's promise of a fundamental review, Major and Hurd fell in behind Heseltine with reptilian alacrity.
The fall of Thatcher stemmed from desperation in the Tory ranks:
almost anything would be better than Thatcher, who was leading them to certain defeat. An anarchy of the self-seeking was unleashed as the electoral college of MPs behaved, in the words of one backbencher, like "a bunch of demented ferrets" Nevertheless, the approach of the candidates - muted to meet the occasion -demonstrated the divisions and the alternatives on offer.
Heseltine shared much of the hard approach of Thatcher in terms of both policy and personality. A self-made multi-millionaire, he believed that in some ways the approach of the first Thatcher government had been too faltering. Hugo Young of the Guardian reported: "If he'd been in charge, he told me, he would have shaken out employment, imposed the squeeze, thrott!ed uncompetitive business, all far more harshly than Chancellor Howe:
As Secretary of State for the Environment, Hezza, as the Sun typically termed him, had been the executioner of public sector housing, stopping local authority building and given away the existing stock of council houses. As Secretary of State for Defence in the second Thatcher government, Heseltine had been gung-ho, deploying Cruise and Pershing missiles, taking a firm line on the peace movement.
For all his vaunted "compassion" after the 1981 inner city riots, hard urban regeneration was minimal, given the attack on local Wes against a send out the redundangovernment grants that Heseltine was simultaneously spearheading.
The other tendency in Heseltine stemmed from his role as Minister of Aerospace in Heath's 1970-74 government. His spells at Aerospace and Defence in the 1970s and 1980s gave him a clear understanding of the scale and finance required for modern industry to compete effectively in international terms, and the soaring cost of research and procurement which necessitated co-operation beyond the national sphere.
By the 1980s he was even firmer on this: he believed that a European bloc was required to create the scale and efficiency to compete effectively with the US and Japan. Britain needed a fused financial-industrial economy and it could not rebuild an industrial base alone in the conditions of the '80s.
It was indeed Heseltine's support for the integration of the UK economy with European capital against the US-client relationship which led to his resignation from Thatcher's Cabinet in 1985 over the Westland affair. Thatcher wanted the ailing helicopter company to be taken over by the US company Sikorski. Heseltine wanted to put together a European package of support.
If Heseltine set the EC against Thatcher's Atlanticism and free world market, he also set the state against, or rather with, the market. He wanted a closer interpenetration of capital and state on the Japanese model with the state supporting financing, sometimes direcung, capital. This was the onl route by which the UK could catch up and reverse its century-long decline, given the vast scale and intensity of world competition and the lead possessed by the UK's competitors.
Heseltine put particular emphasis on state support for regeneration of manufacturing, the need for imTHE Marwic HORT OUR proved education and training, the need for an extended role for the Department of Trade and Industry.
Thatcherism, in Heseltine's eyes, had produced a private affluencepublic squalor situation in which the private affluence had proved shallower and ephemeral because of the public squalor. The public squalor was part of the UK's economic problems because when it came to infrastructure, transport, communications, the education system, research and development, UK capital could not be expected to stand completely on its own two feet.
Capital in other countries did not stand on its own two feet. It received state aid. That gave it a competitive edge and put it into shape to knock the stuffing out of its UK opponents. To help and direct capital, to give money and to give a lead, that's what the state was there fore, that was the secret Thatcher forgot.
Heseltinism would repair the ravages wrought by her amnesia.
As Heseltine put it in the mid'80s: "There is also a general appreciation that the only way forward is political, not industrial, not military, not research-led. It is in the end the only ultimate customer, the national taxpayer, who through their politicians can bring about the co-ordinated market place that alone will deliver the efficiencies and economies. I do not believe that the market itself will produce such a situation. Government must take the lead."
John Major was a hope of a different colour. His entire political formation had not taken place under the shadow of Thatcher - he had worked with Heseltine in the past and cited lan Macleod, an apostle of 'One Nation' Toryism as an inspiration. But he was, if anybody was, working with Lawson at the Treasury and then as Chancellor, directly responsible for the boom which had nurtured inflation and then for the policies which had brought his mistress to her knees.
He seemed entirely lacking in the conviction of Thatcher or the radical flair of Heseltine. Yet Major had been instrumental in getting the pound into the ERM against Thatcher's opposition. He had for long been associated with Tories such as Chris Patten and William Waldegrave in the Blue Chip group, a supper club which agonised over the excesses of Thatcher and wanted a stronger emphasis on social concerns, particularly education. He had now signalled that he was ready to let the poll tax go.
Like Thatcher herself, but with more sincerity, he avowed that the welfare state was a major achievement and was safe in his hands.
It was difficult, certainly, compared with Heseltine, to see exactly what Major stood for. Was it simpa matter eliminating the Wage and "bull in ocher the Housing Act vouchers in edt privatisation? ( quickly doff Tha ing become leade would wear n disloyalty nor h certainty, quickl It seemed diff way Major woul jor, in all probabi ed conspectus h ment that "I am pure in any way"
tial pragmatism.
advantage of Tha she saw him as th Hurd of course w personal assistan Old Etonian - a beat Heseltine.
Major was thu:
mantle of Thatch benefitting from amongst section:
against the tr politically unre Heseltine.
And there was a a change could on ty - and of cours otherwise lose thi *least worst choic jor just scraped he His few months shorter because suspension of don casioned by the ( all-party consensus have not seen mu Will see more, and see much this sid There have been a of cosmetic measur money for hospil homeless and ha fected by AIDS thr ment. There have b interest rates and 1 William Waldegri that, in relation to 1 Thatcher overdid commerce. Not mi that there have beer the need for mo legislation.
In one sense, hov with 12 months a already been big chi is in the government finished - althoug execution and wha will still create maji the Tories, as will another round at le and non-payment is entry into the ERM portant step for Europeans and the r ther steps towar operation. Major tegration and attem! it meets Britain's in Already at the st was telling the Ger Britain's "national help build and sh: Europe, and to di thusiasm."
Britain must be heart of the comm closely with ou (Observer, Marcl Whatever his protes is not travelling in 1 tion as Thatcher. ( rhetoric, he repress changes.
But these change problems for Major. ternal opposition to the poll tax is be former chairs of the Tebbit and Cecil P thin the Cabinet b oyalısts Peter Lilley, Michael Howard and lan Lang. A new That-l herite group, "Conservative Way onward" has been formed as a variant of the "No Turning to safeguard Mrs ber s achievements. ion Trust fiasco or acation or further Dr would Major itcherism and, havi because the party either Heseltine's is conviction and y don Heseltine's icult to see which d go because Maility, had no detailimself. His state1 not ideologically bespoke an essenHe had the strong itcher's blessing as le closest to her -as Heath's former it, an inscrutable nd the best bet to s able to wear the lerism whilst also the strong feeling of the party eacherous and liable parvenu also the sense that ly benefit the pare MPs who might eir seats. As the e" candidate Maome. at the helm seem of the relative nestic politics ocsulf war and the s. In one sense we ich, although we cannot expect to e of an election very small trickle res, such as more tal doctors, the lemophiliacs inough NHS treatseen small cuts in Health Secretary ave has stated the welfare state, the language of ach, and against 1 declarations on re trade union vever, compared igo. there have anges. Heseltine t. The poll tax is H h the method of t will replace it or problems for t 1 the fact that east of payment inevitable. The I is both an imward for the precursor of furds closer cowill accept inpt to ensure that terests. tart of 1991 he mans it was in self-interest to ape the future so with en*right at the unity, working partners stations, Major the same direcControlling his ents important presage new They face ino. Support for ing rallied by party, Norman Parkinson, and y the Thatcher
Scan page 11
N PERSPECTIVE Socialist Organiser No. 489 page 11
----- pull-quotes -----
in terms of wedibility the
we people at its wead, Militant, were
diculous and noisy ash of things when wey had control of we council."
"Heseltine the EC agai Thatcher's Atlanticism free world