UCATT rats jump ship
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-06-13Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 4
just jumping ship: they're trying to scupper the vessel as they go. A group of full-time officials led by Alan Black and Andy Verdeille (heads of the Direct Labour Section and the Exhibitions Industry Section respectively approached the EETPU as soon as the left victories in the lections were announced. UCATT General Secretary, Albert Williams (now suspended, pending an inquiry into his involvement in ballot-rigging) had been holding merger discussions with the electricians for years. But what Black, Verdeille and Co. were proposing wasn't a merger, but an EETPU "raid" on UCATT, aided and abetted by disaffected UCATT officials.
The mutineers promised Pirate King Hammond at least 50,000 recruits from UCATT's total complement of 200,000. In exchange, they wanted comfortable quarters and cushy commissions aboard the Good Ship EETPU. Three UCATT regional secretaries (including Paul Corby of Yorkshire) signed up with Hammond's crew there and then. But, in the meantime, another vessel hove into view: it was the GMB, under full sail, with wily Cap'n John Edmonds at the helm. Edmonds had never before sailed under the skull-and-crossbones (indeed, just three years before, he'd led the TUC's assault on the EETPU privateers) but the prospect of rich pickings from UCATT's hold was too much to resist: "Avast there, me hearties!" he cried to Black and Verdeille, offering them even more attractive terms than Hammond had done. The mutineers would be given jobs with the GMB, to set Edmonds tried to present his raid as a "life-boat" sent out to save the crew of a foundering hulk. Under these desperate circumstances, he argued, the Bridlington Agreement didn't apply. And anyway his only motivation was to save the Good Ship UCATT from the EETPU's But no-one believed this load of bilge — not even Norman Willis, who warned Edmonds that if he proceeded with his piratical plans, TUC lefties, like the MSF and TGWU, would take great pleasure in proposing that he walk the plank, just like Hammond three years before. All very embarrassing for Willis, not to mention Admiral Kinnock. So Edmonds lowered the skull-and-crossbones and set a new course proposing to take Messrs Black and Verdeille on board for GMB jobs "outside the building The rest of the mutinous UCATT officers have now signed up with Hammond and a new EETPU Construction Craft Section is being established. A series of bitter skirmishes can be expected as the two unions engage eachother in local authorities and the private sector.
Can UCATT loyalists keep their ship afloat and steer her away from the rocks? A vigorous recruitment campaign on non-union sites would be a start. And on sites where UCATT "members" never see a union card (let alone an official) and the employers choose the conveno before there is a workforce, basic norms of independent union organisation need to be re-established, with funetioning stewards' committees. Given the crisis facing the union, there is a strong case for a special recall conIn the medium-term the best bet is probably a merger with the TGWU - a prospect made more likely by Bill Morris' victory in the recent T&G election. But even so, the UCATT Broad Left needs to concentrate on basic recruitment and site organisation if Hammond's pirates he right wing cliqu UCATT by means ballot-rigging and sweetheart deals with employers lost their majority on the union's executive three weeks ago.
Now, in the words of one UCATT militant, "the rats are deserting the sinking ship. We've got to keep the By Sleeper ship afloat." He might have added that the rats are not by 12 years of Tory rule not to vote Labour no vote Labour, or - that was the question at the Socialist Movement AGM at the weekend (1 June).
Should the Socialist Movement in its press, Socialist, due to come out up a new Construction Section. September, after two or three postponements, advocate voting Labour at thi General Election?
At most labour movemer events the issue would not non-TUC boarding-party. be contentious, but the SM is a strange beast. Some of its central figures are not members of the Labour Pa ty, and advocate building a "new socialist party": members of the Scottish Ne tional Party and Plaid Cymru, the Welsh nationalists, support the SM project, so there was bound trade".
to be friction on the question of advocating a vote f Labour.
The intervention of Socialist Outlook supporters, however, was by fa the most interesting aspect of the debate.
On the surface Outlook share Socialist Organiser's orientation to the Labour Party. They are in Labour Party Socialists. One supporter of Outlook is chair *Socialists for Labour"; ference. two of the witch-hunted Lambeth councillors sympathise with Socialist Outlook.
The pro-Labour resolution at the SM AGM was are to be seen off. submitted and motivated by Outlook supporters. It would have seemed certain that they would vote for th position. Life in and aroun the walking political contradiction that is Socialist Outlook is not so simple.
On the vote Socialist Outlook split three ways.
Most of them abstained - including the mover of the "vote Labour" resolution! It took two attempts for their comrade who is chair of "Socialists for Labour" to vote in favour.
Others, including Davy Jones, Outlook's most prominent supporter in the SM Kinnock's not the first traitor voted against - and in favour of reflecting the "pluralist tradition" of the Socialist Movement; in rea ty, a "neutral" position or the general election.
It was the same Davy Jones who, with an air of exasperation, assured the Labour Party Socialists AGM last October that of course Socialist would back a Labour vote everywhere.
This comedy is important for two reasons. First, in working class politics there has to be clarity. The issue of the general election is the next chance the labour movement has to de-throne Major and his cronies. Socialists must be clear in their support for Labour, despite Kinnock, not because of him. A victory for Labour would give a tremendous boost to the working class, demoralised and disoriented by 12 years of Tory rule. It would allos greater opportunities for socialists to argue their ideas: that is the important of a Labour victory at the general election.
Secondly, the event was instructive in the political method of Outlook.
Essentially those who were ambivalent on voting Labour were retreating from class positions. Ex-Labourmembers argued that Labour was now so terrible, with its support for the Gulf war and compliance with the Tory poll tax dictats in local
MANCHESTER
AND government, that socialists could not lend their support One speaker said that we should advocate a vote for "socialism" , not Labour, and that the general election was not a priority for socialists. And some longstanding Labour activists argued that in some constituencies where the SNP or Plaid were the contestants, we should vote for them instead.
All this showed the effects of 12 years of Tory rule and more deep-rooted confusion on what the Labour Party is and what it represents. in society. For some of those present it was easy to support a left wing Labour Party, but not this one.
SO can sympathise: the general election will not be a battle between socialism and capitalism. The sharp turn to the right dismays us. The election is, however, a battle between the existing working class movement and the Tories. And, after all, Labour under Kinnock is not radically different from the Labour Party in the past, nor will a Labour government after the next election be so different from past ones: Labour has supported every imperialist war, it has routinely betrayed the working class. What's new?
So how do Outlook fit into this? Some of their supporters made speeches I could fully support, some however were very strange. The small success of the SNP, Plaid and, most recently, the "Real Labour candidates for them complicate the issue, because they have been successful against Labour "from the left".
There was a subsidiary issue. A pro-Labour stance would alienate the good activists in the SNP, Plaid and the Green Party who support the SM (as well as caus ing possibly irrevocable splits within Outlook itself). Some of this is true, but some Outlook supporters saw this "pressure from the left" as a positive development.
It seems obvious that socialists should relate to youth in Govan that support the SNP because they supported non-payment of the poll tax (they've now dropped this policy) but Outlook just mimics and echoes them.
The socialist left must engage in a political struggle to orientate radical youth to the labour movement. Voting Labour is part and parcel of that. In different circumstances, with mass radicalisation and a discredited Labour government it may be different, but presently with a battere labour movement, getting s Labour government is the overriding priority.
This fascination with Scottish nationalism is not just a fleeting fancy either. It tells us much about the history of Outlook and the international grouping they support, the United Secretariat of the Fourth li ternational (USEC).
In the '70s the main forerunner of Outlook helped set up the Scottish Socialist Party as a split from the Labour Party. It quickly withered and died. The USEC has had a penchant for investing faith in non-socialist radical movements. From guerrillaism to Stalinism, these radical movements have been part of the developing world revolution pushing ever onward and upward, they say.
Now there's a thought: Jim Sillars as the new Fidel Castro. lim Sillars
Scan page 5
NTERNATIONAL Socialist Organiser No. 489 page 5
----- pull-quotes -----
That for years ram INSIDE
NALOO IN UNIONS
HILTO DEFEND UUR NHS JUN Wć
MANCHESTER TIES - BRANCH
*SALFORD HAL LTO