Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Unite the lett

Socialist Organiser no. 489, 13 June 1991 · scan p. 3 · about 1,003 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 3

There is a great deal of senseless squabbling within the left and quite a lot of it is needlessly destructive, and even personal.

It is easily forgotten that there are also serious issues involved in some of the divisions on the left. For example, Socialist Organiser and Briefing separated a decade ago because there was a radical disagreement between us on policy for the left which was winning power in a number of cities, including London.

We said that left-wing should be made into bases for resistance to Tory cuts, deliberately going for sharp confrontation with the goverment, mobilising their workine elace communities hehind TY ME DANG them.

Briefing backed those such as Ken Livingstone who tried to evade confrontation with the Tories by raising rates to compensate for the Tory cuts: everywhere this policy led to frittering away the left's strength and to turning the councillors into the reluctant local administrators of Thatcher's policies.

When they had discredited themselves, Thatcher then moved to Labour Party. Strike figures are now the lowest for 50 years - that fact shows up the mindlessness of Socialist Worker's approach.

But even if strikes were now as big and frequent as they were in the early 1970s it would still be a nonsense to pretend that we can dispense with politics, with "Labour". No we cannot!

le have no real alternative to and no other way, now, to break the back of this Tory government except a Labour victory in the general election.

Trotsky used to point out that it is a recurring pattern in politics that belly-crawling such as Kinnock's at the top of a labour movement generates incoherent "ultra leftism" amongst those who find it disgusting - an emotional "rejection" of politics.

Kinnock has generated such moods on the left with his witch-hunting and purging within the Labour Party, his refusal to fight the Tories outside it, and the neoTory policies he promises to try to pursue if he wins office. A lot of people on the left can no longer see any point in fighting to return a Labour government. That is the alarming message that came from the Socialist Movement conference (see disqualify some of them.

That dispute is now a matter of history, but it was no idle dispute, and the split that arose out of it was nrohahlv nnavnidahle.

It is inevitable that major political issues often lead to division. But they can also lead to the healing of divisions, to unifications.

Such a major question now faces the left. Where do we stand on policy for the next election?

Two poles are forming inside the left: those who say unequivocally that the Tories must be defeated and Labour returned to office. And those who say that Kinnock is such STAP the report on page 4). The Militant-led breakaway from Labour in Liverpool is, essentially, a product of the same mood.

Whatever they say for themselves, their indifference to kicking out the Tories shows how far from being revolutionaries, or serious socialists, or even champions of the labour moment are "It is a nonsense to those - almost 50% - at the Socialist Movement conference who were against advocating a Labour They do not represent a labour movement alternative to Kinnock: on the contrary, their proposed response to Kinnock amounts to abandoning the field of working class politics to him and his friends.

For socialists to do that represents a deepening of Kinnock's a wretch, and his party moved so far tothe right, that it makes no sense to actively campaign for the destruction of the Tory government and the return of Labour.

Between now and the next election the differentiation between those two poles will sharpen. It is a divisive, but it can also be a unifying process.

Unity is possible between those groups and individuals on the left who agree that our central task is to defeat the Tories and elect a Labour government, and on the need to combine a vigorous campaign within the working class and tama victory and its unnecessary prolongation. It is an admission of defeat, a throwing in of the towel, albeit with good "socialist" "revolutionary" and antiKinnock" slogans scrawled all over Without the defeat of the Tories there is no way forward for the labour movement! The road to the renewal of working class self-confidence and militancy goes over the defeated carcass of this Tory government. Kicking out the Tories and the election of a majority Labour government - that must be the central goal of every serious socialist in the lead up to the general Anything that gets in the way of that - including Neil Kinnock - is acting against the interests of the working class and playing the Tory game. Those socialists who find the choice of Kinnock's Labour or the Tories an impossible one and retreat into abstention, passivity or little local adventures like Militant's Walton by-election candidacy, are part of Kinnockism's | triumph within the Labour Party.

The real socialists now are those who know this and themselves to fight within the trade unions and Labour Part! i to concentrate the energies of ti le labour in the labour movement to achieve this with a fight against Kinnock and his careerist friends.

Though conditions are different, the precedent is there in the 1978 unification of critical pro-Labour forces, in the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, out of which grew Socialist Organiser. -If we can unite a sizeable portion of the fighting, pro-Labour left, then we will also be taking a big step forward in the fight against Kinnock and the pink Tories who now run the Labour Party.

Unite the left! movement on defeating the Tories and electing a Labour government in the coming general election.

To do that it is necessary to oppose and resist the sectarian and abstentionist moods which are now growing in the labour movement.

----- pull-quotes -----

SHERWOOD says DON'T PAY

pretend that we dispense with politics, with 'Labour'. No cannot!"

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 489

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →