Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Southwark building workers' strike: We should face reality squarely

Socialist Organiser no. 488, 6 June 1991 · scan pp. 14–15 · about 938 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 14 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 14

WHAT'S-ON Liverpool Insitute of Higher Educa "Save the NHS", SO London eRdŞм wich "Students and socialism", Ox TuesdaynI JULE den Ford SO meeting. Speaker: Mark "Ther sose-reri mimity:: "Crisis in the USSR", Essex EU University SO meeting. 6.00. Thaneder-20 ne JEINE ieD "Resourcing the Future", con- field University SO meeting, 1.00 Parade* 9.00-midnight, Trafalgar Princeton College, Sidmouth St, O11 Against the War and others London Racist Britain what's the Sunay-Jeme PondeN- SSCAU, West St, 7.30. Speaker:

ony O'Brien's letter in SO 485 accusing us of misleading the readers of this paper in regard to the recent strike in the Southwark Council DLO deserves a serious reply.__.

If anything, it is Tony's letter that is misleading. A previous letter has already dealt with some of the minor technical details of this matter. We want to concentrate on the political issues at stake.

In Tony's words: "Our criticism of your article is not sectarian. We recognise the valid work done by many Socialist Organiser supporters in the struggle against the employers. Our criticism is that articles by labour movement organisations must be (1) factual and objective; (2) recognise all aspects of the struggle and not just see defeats and victories; (3) to give recognition to those who are prepared to lead workers in the struggle against the employers in the knowledge that workers will hesitate (even when principled leadership is being given at a rank and file level) at certain stages of the struggle and may only give limited support. "

Let us start with the first sentence. "Our criticism" implies that the SO articles were written by people with no inside knowledge of the DLO and that Tony is speaking in the name of the stewards' committee. Not so.

One of the authors is a long standing activist in the DLO, an EETPU shop steward and former treasurer of the DLO stewards' committee. Hardly distanced comment from the outside...

Tony's point (1) has already been dealt with in SO 486. Point (2) is the crucial one.

Tony tells us to be balanced and not just see "defeats and victories". It was precisely our intention to provide a balanced account and doing so first of all requires calling things by their right names.

An indefinite strike called off after two days with largescale scabbing and very limited support from the second biggest union involved is a defeat and a retreat. There are no other words to describe it.

Bringing in a small victory won before the strike like the reprieve for 24 apprentices' jobs as Tony does will not make this retreat go away. A defeat is a defeat. Recognising this should in no way be seen as a criticism of the leadership provided by the stewards committee.

Pointing to the terrible role of the national officials, accurate though this may ben doesnot get activists in Southwark DLO out of the problems facing them. In fact, it can become an excuse for inactivity. Though we are sure this was not Tony's intention, the following comment can easily be interpreted as implying that no local battles have a hope of success until we change the national leadership:

*...there is no substantial victories or overall successes possible without a leadership that will initiate a national campaign, so as to defeat the government and its policies, which is behind all these attacks."

But we will only get a "new leadership" out of the work that activists do to stop the retreat in the existing local, defensive battles, and attempting to link them up.

Recognising retreats is the first step to being able to reverse them.

In the past certain left groups always talked of the need for a "new leadership" But they never told serious activists how it could be built in the real class struggle in the here and now. The "new leadership" would either just descend from the sky like Superman or be summoned up by recanting the "correct" slogans. But it never materialised.

Surely Tony doesn't

ollow that road?

Yours in comradeship Henry Mott Shop Steward Southwark Council DLO Tom Rigby Socialist Organiser EB Thw scanDi "Lapour- ant: Jl Dawber. For venue phone Mike on 1532 452312 Sandell. Oxford Poly, 7.00 FiRe 2s Seet tish yay а -meeting. Glasgow Tollcross Com Sarudei T bewiER Thursen ference organised by the Red Green Network. Kingsway "The New-aldi Order, ihr surgery could affect survival rates by 100% or more in some cases.

The women studied, 249 of them, had all been treated between 1975 and 1985. They had been suffering from various stages of disease — in some, the cancer had spread to the lymph glands in the armpits. Some had had mastectomy (removal of a breast) while others had had "lumpectomy" (removal of tion Mader-l IME Brighton SO meeting, Race Hill Wetlnesder-12 kone Speaker: Mark Osborn 'Lesbian and gay liberation", "Wher is 200 GEI to lodge anywhere. They will then be unlikely to survive:

No doubt other theories will be put forward, but the possibility must arise of treating or controlling breast cancer with hormones. These could De either progresterone, which has an antioestrogen effect, or synthetic "anti-oestrogens". . The question also arises whether other types of cancer might be affected by hormone levels.

1210015. Du mentingw Emer ae Forumo i Tuester-BAlN "The Bolshevik Revolution", ShefWet nesder 18 dane Merseyside SO meeting.

Wallasey Unemployed Centre, and how to fight it", East London SO meeting. Oxford House, Derbyshire St, E2, 7.30 "Th aSEM OT SOe Teeside Tech SU meeting, 1.00 Square. Organised by Women Anains Wer in the Gulf, Labour answer?", Sheffield SO meeting.

Scan page 15

Socialist Organiser No. 488 page 15

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 488

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →