Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Eastern Europe: theory is grey

Socialist Organiser no. 488, 6 June 1991 · scan p. 14 · about 460 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 14 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 14

Chris Reynolds, in SO 487, argues that Mandel is incorrect to stress the obstacles facing a capitalist restoration in Eastern Europe. But surely Mandel's analysis made in 1989 has been borne out by events.

The investments made by western capitalism in the East have remained pathetically small. Ironically capitalists were much more willing to do business with the Stalinist regimes which could impose austerity policies without having to worry about any democratic sanction.

And while the world recession means that there is overcapacity in the west, capitalists have seen little point in boosting production by moving eastwards.

It is true that the black market has developed but this should not be seen as a process. leading inevitably to capitalism. On the contrary, while money can be made by dubious means, those with resources to invest, le bureaucrats and black marketeers, will abstain from productive investment.

In this situation, it does not seem sensible to adopt catch-all labels which can only simplify what is essentially a transitional stage.

Mandel is right to stress the contradictory nature of the situation - on the one hand a powerful working class, on the other a captialist dynamic but one facing serious difficulties. This dialectical approach is surely preferable to imposing some schema from the Marxist list of terms on a complex and unprecedented reality.

Chris Reynolds appears to require that we approve or disapprove of the situation as a whole and does not permit an approach which sees both positive and negative aspects.

Theory is grey but reality is green!

Doveton, Newton Abbot Most people with breast cancer are quite elderly but some 6,000 younger women, below the age of menopause, are diagnosed to have it each year. Since their cancers tend to be rather more virulent, anything that can improve their chances of survival is worth investigating.

This lay behind the research published last week into the link between time of surgery and the breast cancer patient's menstrual cycle. The study was carried out at the Imperial Cancer Research Fund's Breast Unit at Guy's Hospital in South London.

It was a considerable surprise to the research team to find that the timing of breast stream during surgery, probably in greater numbers than they are during the life of the tumour. If any of these lodges elsewhere in the body, it may cause a secondary tumour.

Now, the levels of female sex hormones change throughout the menstrual cycle, with ostrogen high and progesterone low between Days 3 and 12. Ostrogen is known to control the production of enzymes by tumour cells which break up groups of cells. These enzymes allow tumour cells to invade tissues and implant themselves. At other times, the hormone levels are reversed and the tumour cells may be unable

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 488

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →