Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

US 'Politically Correct movement Linguistic Stalinism

Socialist Organiser no. 488, 6 June 1991 · scan pp. 12–13 · about 1,269 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 12

TIDE Labour-controlled council in the Abant a children recook from is ban a children's book from its libraries on grounds of racism.

The book, apparently, tells the adventures of a cheekly little monkey. The "racism" arises because the book's illustrations show the monkey dressed in a schoolboy's uniform: the good burghers of Sandwell decided that this would give offense to black people. A case, perhaps, of "racism" being in the eye of the beholder.

Sandwell Council and the cheekly little monkey somehow came to mind as I grappled with accounts of the "Politically Correct" (PC) movement in the US. I should state at this point that my information on the PO phenomenon comes mainly from Peter Jenkins, the Butskellite political columnist of the Independent. But whatever his other faults, Jenkins is not prone to hysteria and does not have a record of "loonie leftie"-baiting. Also, his accounts tally with my own observation of the PC movement's British equivalents.

...linguistic Stalinism is only one manifestation of the PC: comes as part of a package deal that involves extending (or, rather, reducing) multiculturalism to an absolute relativism. "

The movement's best-politicised activities concern behaviour and language. A number of colleges and universities in the US have begun adopting PC codes, supposedly intended to curb behaviour and/or language that might give offence to racial minorities, women, gays and lesbians. Some of this is quite reasonable and no-one but a bigot could object. But quite a bit is downright silly and some of it is an affront to any conception of free speech.

The University of Connecticut, for in stance, has prohibited inappropriately directed laughter". The New York Times has adopted a "style book" that requires the use of the term "adult male" in place of "man". The word "burly" is also on the PC banned list.

I tried the "burly" on my boss, a commitred feminist and anti-racist. What images and implications did the word conjur up? "Male", "big", maybe (but not necessarily) *stupid" • The PC movement has banned "burly" because it supposedly gives a Dead White European Males' Einstein, Marx and Freud. These males and their cultural and scienti rejected, according to the Politically Correct mo negative image of black men. As-my boss pointed out (when I explained the point of the exercise to her), that argument only makes sense if you are pre-disposed to the assumption that all black men (sorry, males) are big and stupid.

But linguistic Stalinism is only one manifestation of the PC: it comes as part of a package deal that involves extending (or rather, reducing) multi-culturalism to an absolute "relativism". According to this view, there is no such thing as objective "knowledge"', "facts" do not exist; philosophically, "reality" is a complete illusion. One culture, philosophy, scientific theory, concept of history, or whatever, is as good as another. It's all subjective, a matter of opinion.

But here we come to the central contradiction of PC/relativism: instead of applying their own laissez-faire approach to themselves (as well as everyone else) they proclaim it to be the only acceptable point of view, and set about purging reading lists, limiting free speech and hounding "incorrect" academics.

special target of the PCs are 'DWEM's - Dead White European Males. These include Plato, Shakespeare, Voltaire, Newton and (presumably) Marx. The object seems to be the complete repudiation of the entire Western cultural and scientific canon (tainted as it is with racism, sexism, etc) in favour of more "Politically Correct" alternatives.

In particular, mighty efforts are being made to "prove" that Western civilisation has its origins not in the Greeks but in black African sources. Similarly, the science of Newton (and Einstein) is rejected in favour of "ethno-mathematics" and "feminist Now, it is certainly not my intention here to deny that mainstream education and culture has always downplayed the contributions of women and black people. In particular, the superiority of early Asian civilisation over European ones has been consistently ignored by most Western historians. And who knows what unrecorded contributions to culture and science were made in Africa over the centuries? But that cannot detract from the fact (sorry to have to insist on prosaic old "facts") that the highest achievements of art, literature, science, history and philosophy that we have on record tend to be the work of "DWEM"s. They are (or should be) everyone's birthright.

To reject mainstream European culture because of racist, sexist societies that produced it, is to deny the working class and the oppressed their opportunity to arm themselves ideologically for the battle for a new, better society. It is intellectual Luddism.

Tronically, the chief victims of the PC movement are black students. According to the Marxist historian of slavery, Eugene Genovese, "we have transformed our colleges from places of higher learning into highest achie record are th Orgreave, near Sheffield, June 1984: thousands of miners' pickets and riot police fight pitched battles outside a coking plant. The battle raged daily from 29 May until coke runs from Orgreave were suspended on 18 June. Dozens of miners were injured in police attacks; Arthur Scargill himself was places for the technical training of poorly prepared young men and women who need a degree to get a job in a college-crazy society" . Meanwhile, young blacks are ghettoised into Afro-American studies and their educational achievements devalued accordingly, The PC relativists no doubt disdain such formal categories as "left" and "right" but my guess is that they would not object too strongly to being called "left wing". In fact, ments of art, science, philosophy, etc. that we work of DWEM's. This is intellectual Luddism hospitalised.

The miners won that skirmish. They were defeated in their strike because the leaders. of the Labour Party and the trade unions were so far from having the same determination and courage as the miners who faced the brute force of the capitalist state at Orgreave.

Neil Kinnock spent most his time denouncing the violence of the miners' pickets!

The trade union leaders passed general motions of support for the miners, but did nothing to mobilise their members or to link their own struggles with miners'.

they are profoundly reactionary.

he exiled Iraqi architect Samir al-Khalil recently published a book (The Monument) which examines the role of art and architecture in Saddam's military dictatorship. Khalil is especially scathing about Robert Venturi, the "post-modern" architect presently in the news because of his National Gallery extension.

Venturi was one of many Western architects who tried to make money from Saddam's huge programme of grotesque public works, climaxing in the infamous "Victory Arch"" based on giant replicas of Saddam's own arms holding sabres. Khalil accuses Venturi of something more than simple greed and opportunism: his artistic prostitution is the direct result of his relativism.

I didn't follow this line of argument at first but then it fell into place. For the likes of Venturi, Saddam's regime and the requirements it places upon arts and culture is just as acceptable as any other commission. You want grotesque, militaristic kitsch? You've got it! For Venturi, there are no objective standards, either in aesthetics or in This is a particularly extreme example of "relativism" and it would obviously be unfair to bracket all the PC movement aherents together with this particular charlatan. But they are linked by a common philosophical approach and it's one that Marxists should fight tooth and nail. As for Sandwell council, I suspect none of them have (yet) heard of the "Politically Correct". They're just silly. But then, it's all relative, isn't it?

Scan page 13

Organiser

----- pull-quotes -----

+ 507 are condemened to relive it

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 488

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →