Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Why India is lurching into

Socialist Organiser no. 488, 6 June 1991 · scan pp. 8–10 · about 2,326 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 8

The assassination of Rajiv Gandhi and the inability of the Congress Party to find successor, has highlighted the disarray of mainstream politics in India. Why are tl politicians unable or unwilling to come to grips with India's problems? And where is the way out from the chaos? Martin Thomas reports ndia has a large, and often militant, working class.

Textile workers in Bombay, dockworkers and rail workers across India, and many other groups of workers, have fought great industrial battles against great odds.

But politically most of the working class is still tied to various sections of the bourgeoisie or the middle class. And the Indian bourgeoisie is increasingly rotten and corrupt.

India had strong handicraft industries and a rich culture before it was conquered by Europeans. Two centuries of British rule largely destroyed the handicraft industries - flooding their markets with the products of British factories - and kept India's peasant majority in medieval dependence and poverty.

British rule also, however, created the conditions for a new sort of industry. Commenting on the British administration's railwaybuilding drive in the 1850s, Karl Marx wrote: "I know that the The political dynasty pays its last respects English millocracy intend to endow India with railways with the exclusive view of extracting at diminished expenses the cotton and other raw materials for their manufactures.

"But when you have once introduced machinery into the locomotion of a country which possesses iron and coals, you are unable to withhold it from its fabrication. You cannot maintain a net of railways over an immense country without introducing all those industrial processes necessary to meet the immediate and current wants of railway locomotion, and out of which there must grow the application of machinery to those branches of industry not immediately connected with railways.

"The railway system will "British rule in India was administered and enforced largely by Indians."

therefore become, in India, truly the forerunner of modern industry."

Marx also wrote that "The Indians will not reap the fruits of the new elements of society scattered among them by the British bourgeoisie, till in Great Britain itself the now ruling classes shall have been supplanted by the industrial proletariat, or till the Hindus themselves shall have grown strong enough to throw off the English yoke altogether"; and elsewhere he wrote about how British rule in India sustained poverty and stagnation. The growth of modern industry in India remained very slow until independence in 1947.

Since 1947 industry has grown much faster, though still slowly compared to countries like South Korea. There has even been some improvement of the conditions of the peasantry, at least in certain parts of India.

British rule in India was administered and enforced largely by Indians, with only a minority of British people in the administration and in the army. That apparatus of rule was carried over intact into independent India. The party which fought for and won independence, Congress, was led by people like Nehru and Mahatma Gandhi from a partly-Anglicised, often Englisheducated, elite.

That elite set about developing independent India's economy with ideas shaped by English Fabian socialism and by admiration from Stalin's USSR. The state took a leading role. Today, two-thirds of India's industrial assets are owned by the state, and the other third of industry is heavily regulated.

Bureaucratic direction and regulation did develop the basics of modern industry in India. But, as in many other countries, it has run up against limits.

The bureaucratic strategy was also a narrowly nationalist and protectionist one, aiming to develop India's economy as a more-or-less self-sufficient unit with relatively little international trade. That approach was not as absurd in India, with its huge size and resources, as in many other countries. But even India cannot be walled off from the world economy. Its industries need foreign technology. It has to make exports in order to pay. for that technology.

Increasingly, state regulation Police drag away Hindu chauvinist has spiralled into a mess of corruption, with officials demanding a rake-off in bribes from every business enterprise.

Both Rajiv Gandhi and the last two prime ministers, Chandra Shekar and VP Singh, favoured "liberalisation" of the economy. None of them achieved much. M class feels itself to be more of eanwhile the growing middle of a power, and has become increasingly vocal. Its revolt ag ainst the old elites has been expressed through a variety of movements based on particular communities or castes.

Britain manipulated divisions between the peoples of India in order to rule, selectively recruiting certain "martial races" for the arareas like the Punjab for public works over rebellious areas like Bengal; and encouraging Muslims dominated onionainst the menuBOVeLICHL.

the communities at the time of partition.

The Congress Party officially opunited Indian nation without ficial stance to shoddy hypocrisy . Thus has the basis been laid f the movements which threaten turn India into a mess of commun and sectarian conflicts. The mo threatening is the Hindu-chauvini BJP. Linked to a fascistic par military group, the RSS, the B campaigns on the theme in decades of official concern for ti Muslims and other minorities Congress and its vario breakaways (like VP Singh's an Chandra Shekar's parties) - larg ly, in fact, lip-service — have disa vantaged Hindus.

What may appear to be "nation liberation movements" within ti Indian federation are mostly se tarian or communalist movemen Its total of value-added in manufacturing is comparable to, for

Scan page 9

In Kashmir, the only state of the Indian federation with a Muslim majority, a free vote would probably go in favour of secession to Pakistan, and India's central government has maintained control with great violence.

In the Punjab, a section of the Sikh movement — based mainly on better-off farmers and students -wants a separate Sikh state, a "Khalistan" . But the Sikhs are a slight minority of the population in the Punjab, and a minority closely interlaced with the Hindu majority. A separate Sikh state could be created only after terrible violence and forced population movements. Moreover, the Sikhs are not an oppressed minority in India; on the of rich streets, and three million in shanty towns. The worst poverty is in the countryside, where most of India's people live. 70 per cent of the workforce is in agriculture.

Nine out of every hundred babies born alive die before age one; in Britain and other Western countries only one out of every hundred dies. Average life expectancy is 57 years. Half of all men in India, and three-quarters of women, are illiterate India's production, in both industry and agriculture, has grown slightly faster than population (production, four per cent growth per year: population, two per cent). But most of the gains from growth have gone to the better off. Millions of landless rural labourers and sharecroppers are as poor as ever. whole they are better off than the Indian average. In Assam, a "nationalist" movement based mostly on students uses Maoist rhetoric. But its cutting edge is the reactionary demand for the expulsion of Bengali migrant workers and a ban on further migration.

The two hidden, but central, issues in India are land reform and the creation of a united and independent labour movement.

India must have more land reform laws than any other country in the world, but less actual land reform than most. Many peasants still work under systems of sharecropping or other forms of dependence. Capitalist agriculture is developing, especially in better-off areas like the Punjab, but in a highly unequal way, creating a small minority of relatively well-off farmers and a huge army of landless people reduced to grabbing a living by odd jobs. Public investment still goes mostly to the state industries - impressive-looking, if inefficient, and equipped " 1 strong lobbies in the corridors of power -rather than to help the majority in the countryside.

India has many trade unions — too many. The movement is divided into a large number of small trade unions, often local, and also divided politically, with unions often tied to one or another political party.

There are two main parties claiming to represent the working class, the Communist Party of India and the Communist Party (Marxist). The split between the two CPs dates back to 1964, and was linked to the rift between Moscow and Peking. The CPI was the Moscow-loyal party - heavily dependent for its upkeep on the control by businesses linked to it of a large part of IndianUSSR trade - while the CP(M) declared itself independent of both Moscow and Peking. The CPI has its main base in Kerala, in southern India; the CP(M) has long been the leading force in West Bengal, around Calcutta.

Both CPs have tied themselves to bourgeois parties. The CPI even supported Indira Gandhi's "state of emergency" in 1975-7. The CP(M) has generally supported the bourgeois opposition to Indira and Rajiv Gandhi, most recently VP Singh.

If it can unite and develop its own independent politics, the Indian working class can remake India. If not, the country faces further bloody chaos and poverty.

rie Heffer, who died on May 27, was the nearest thing to a socialist Organiser MP, but he was not a Trotskyist.

When he broke with Stalinism in the late '40s he also rejected He seems to have been influenced by the "ultra-left" commentators who traced the degeneration of the Russian Revolution to the pre-Stalin Civil War period, and to events such as the Bolshevik suppression of the uprising at Kronstadt in 1921. He was never Trotskyist. It was a point he would insist upon.

Nevertheless, names aside, he was the nearest thing to a British Trotskyist MP in existence. Of course — it is no secret - there are two MPs who call themselves Trotskyist, but they supported Russia's barbarous equivalent of the Vietnam War, the Stalinist attempts to napalm and starve Afghanistan into submission to the Russian empire.

By contrast, Eric Heffer had a consistent record of unqualified class struggle politics for the whole world.

Not only was he an enemy of US imperialism, and of regimes such as that of Pinochet's Chile and apartheid South Africa, but an enemy of all Stalinist regimes and of the Russian empire too. Hi was always an active supporter of those in the USSR, Eastern Europe, China, or wherever, fighting Stalinism from within.

When it seemed a lost cause, and long before Solidarnose made it fashionable, Heffer fought for free labour movements in the Stalinist states. He spoke at the conferences SO organised in support of free labour movements in the Stalinist states.

Names aside, Eric Heffer's politics were "Trotskyist" politic on every question of the class struggle — East as well as West. With the exception of the European Community, Socialist Organiser could always ask Eric Heffer to comment on the key political questions of the day and be pretty sure his views would coincide, as near as made little dif ference, with ours.

We tested it often enough and we were never disappointed or rebuffed. Again and again we put his comments on the front page, proud and pleased that Heffer, who commanded a considerable respect all across the labour movement, was willing to take his political stand with us.

Eric Heffer was a parliamentarian. He seems to have operated in the House of Commons almost as if it were a trade union. But Eric Heffer as chair of Liverpool Labour Party, 1960 when the Tory anti-union laws were being used to bludgeon striking seafarers, Heffer appealed to workers - on the front page of Socialist Organiser - urging them to ignore the law and break it, and to organise mass pickets to resist the police. Together with Tony Benn he went down on the seafarers' picket lines. And that's only one example.

Legality and the sovereignty of parliament were no god to this parliamentarian. The interests of the working class always came before such considerations. In Heffer's view workers had a right to resist unjust laws and naked Tory class legislation.

During the Gulf war the dying man stood like a rock against the tidal waves of chauvinism. Many other examples could be cited of Eric Heffer's consistency and reliability.

It is this which allows us to put the keening for Heffer in the press of his bourgeois enemies into the necessary perspective. Others in the history of the labour movement who have won the esteem of the class enemies of the labour movement had sought it; and they paid for it by shedding their own identity, by betraying the working class, by toadying to its enemies.

In contrast, though he seems to have won a great deal of affection, and from unlikely people, Eric Heffer remained himself, a proud representative of the oppressed and exploited and an irreconcilable fighter on their behal against their oppressors and exploiters.

Yet, he was a man full of paradox and even contradiction. The nearest thing to an SO Trotskyist in the House of Commons was also a devout Anglo-Catholic! At the age of about 50, he returned to the religion of his youth, and died in the arms of the church of which Elizabeth Windsor is the hereditary chief. And Eric Heffer seems to have extended even to the Tories a rare Christian charity, and the human goodwill and human solidarity of a practising and consistent socialist. If even some of the newspaper reports on his friendships are true, he was. possessed of a startlingly nonBolshevik tolerance.

Yet, to the end - to the day he went to the House of Commons, dying, and spoke out against the ruling class and their war in the Gulf, and to his very last day -Eric Heffer remained politically uneroded and unsoftened. He remained the fighting working class socialist he started out to be more than 50 years ago. We are immensely sad that he is gone.

John O'Mahon John Bloxam

Scan page 10

The failure of Thatcherism part 2 aniser

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 488

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →