Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Yes, campaign for democracy

Socialist Organiser no. 488, 6 June 1991 · scan pp. 7–8 · about 1,547 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 7

The Commonwealth of Britain Bill not until 1928 did women get the vote at the same age as heroic episodes in the long struggle for democracy. It was vote; in Switzerland the got it only three years ago! Patrick Murphy discusses the issues raised by Tony Benn's Commonwealth of Britain Bill 00 years ago the French 2 people rose up against the aristocrats and clerics who ruled them and fought to create a new, democratic France. The spirit of their revolution became contagious and the democracy germ infected every European nation in the 19th century.

That spirit was summed up by one of the French leaders, Camille Desmoulins: "The great only appear great," he said, "because we are on our knees. Let us rise!"

Although the majority of French people were involved, the political direction and aims of the movement were dominated by the most organised, articulate and prepared social class, the middle class or bourgeoisie. For that reason we describe the French Revolution as a classic bourgeois revolution - that is, that although the changes brought about benefitted everyone outside the ruling class, they benefitted the employers, the new capitalist class, above all.

"It matters very much to us how democratic capitalist society is. The undemocratic aspects o the British system have been allowed to continue because they inhibit and contain working class radicalism, they defena our rulers from scrutiny and give them a wider range of options in maintaining their economic domination.

We got the sort of democracy which allowed the middle class to take political power but at the same time declared private property and economic laws to be sacrosanct and protected from political interference.

If we were to take the French example as the typical bourgeois political revolution then we would have to say that Britain's transition to liberal capitalist democracy was still not complete. The French aimed to set up a secular, republican democracy which would remove special feudal and inherited privileges. In Britain the political system still bears the imprint of feudal privilege, even though the move to a parliamentary system here began 150 years before the French Revolution.

"ony Benn addressed this issue in his recently published Commonwealth of Britain Bill. Benn proposes a very wide range of reforms to the constitution which, if they were implemented, would change everything, and then again, nothing. He would abolish the monarchy, have four-year fixed terms for parliament, replace the Lords with an elected House of the People, introduce a separation of powers with a President elected from both Houses, create federal parliaments in Scotland and Wales, and remove the Official Secrets Act and put the security services under democratic scrutiny. Even this summary draws out only the major changes in la very detailed Bill. The police manhandle a suffragette in pre-World War 1 Britain. The women's fight for votes is one of the most as late as 1918 that women in Britain got the vote, and Benn's bill raises two issues of general importance to socialists. First, he has come in for criticism from people on the left who regard his concern for the constitution, formal demoracy, and individual rights as all beside the point in the "real class struggle". Here Benn is a better guide to revolutionaries than many self-styled Marxists.

It matters very much to us how democratic capitalist society is. The undemocratic aspects of the British system have been allowed to continue because they inhibit and contain working-class radicalism, they defend our rulers from scrutiny and give thint ai wider ranite of opinis domination. Every extension of democracy weakens their ability to contain us.

their prograd me for coded, is, the demand for annual parliaments, universal suffrage, and payment of MPs. Lenin insisted that socialists should be for the maximum democracy possible under capitalism since this was the clearest, and most open, form of oppression, the most favourable conditions for the struggle for genuine, thoroughgoing social democracy:

Even more important BEHIND THE socialist tradition is the idea that the struggle to extend democracy, to fill it out, is tremendously educational — it educates workers in the nature of the society in which we live, makes our daily oppression political, brings home faster than any number of lectures the need for political as well as economic change. Socialists are always the best and most consistent democrats; to miss that is not only antidemocratic, deep down it is apolitical.

From that point of view there is much positive in what Benn is trying to do; his attempt to deepen liberal democracy in Britain should be welcomed. There is, however, a fundamental weakness or limitation in such proposals for workers. Ba tamentary chambers or the enn is aware that real power parliamentary chambers or the courts but in ownership and control of the economy. Liberal democracy gives people the right to remove their MP, councillor or ruling party, but we are no closer to removing our boss or our relatio with major comi panies He tries dea men. In France, it was only in 1945 that women got the in a complex Charter of Kights, which includes "the right to useful work at a fair wage that provides an income sufficient to maintain a decent standard of living". This is hardly "extremism" — it suggests a basic human minimum for all as a "The idea of 'fair wages' is utopian, it is contradiction in terms. Wages serve a particular function in our society - they buy labour power for employers a rate which ensures that employers accumulate profits al workers continue to need to work. "

right but this sort of right can only enforced if we have open political control over precisely those aspects of society which our entire system protects from "politics"

iberation from need is possib Her No. 488 page through a better constitution but through a break from reliance on parliamentarianism and constitutionalism.

What do we mean by such a break? Assuming that Benn's democratic bill were passed, and genuinely enforced - who would decide which work was useful?, "useful" for what purposes, profits, export trade, social need? What is a "decent standard of living" in the 1990s — a healthy diet and secure accommodation, or a three-day week and a regular foreign holiday?

Most importantly, who is to decide what is a "fair wage"? What is fair to the worker is extreme to the employer and no "independent" body will accept that workers should be well paid regardless of the effect on profits and "economic viability" The truth is that the idea of "fair wages" is utopian, it is a contradiction in terms. Wages serve a particular function in our society -they buy labour power for employers at a rate which ensures that employers accumulate profits and workers continue to need to work. There is of course more to say about wages, but they are absolutely not paid to provide a decent standard of living.

Decent standards, a good income and useful work or activity are all laudable aims, and the fight for such goals is the central driving force behind the struggle for eventual working-class liberation. Yet these are the very problems, the very inequalities and injustices which cannot be resolved within our existing economic system, which point the way to a new method of organising society. In the struggle for these goals ordinary working people need to be able to decide tor themselves what are acceptable standards, reasonable incomes, useful jobs and functions, etc. and have the power to act on these decisions - outside of the consequence for profits and viability.

That requires new structures, new democratic bodies at every level which have so Far only been glorified in history, the sort which cannot be laid down in blueprints by any Marxist because they arise when workers move into a very high level of struggle.

That such bodies do arise is a fact which the history of our class persists in teaching us - the Commune in Paris in 1871, the Soviets of 1905 and 1917 in Russia, the Councils of Action in Britain's 1926 General Strike, the Workers' Council of Hungary in 1956. Socialists should study and draw from such examples, not as ready-made blueprints, but as indications of the creative power of our class and the distinctions between our democracy and liberal democracy.

concede a "decent standard of living" to working people because it is reasonable to do so, and he can logically and persuasively demonstrate that and, more importantly, because he will use his influence to produce the sort of mass pressure and action from below to force such concessions.

His confidence in the importance of working-class self-activity is to Benn's credit, it sets him apart after a period when the fashion has been to move in the opposite direction.

Socialist democracy, we should capital it ever a a break rome is a break trom tension of it. As long as we look mainly to the norms and rhythms of parliamentary politics we are still on our knees — when we rise the great appear weak, the impossible appears possible, and democracy begins to affect the aspects of our es that really matter.

Scan page 8

After Gandhi assassination

----- pull-quotes -----

Bony Benn still looks to the Tiberal pariamentary system to

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 488

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →