Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Seven sell-o A mr disputes the series

Socialist Organiser no. 488, 6 June 1991 · scan pp. 4–5 · about 1,322 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 4

3. The membership rejects the "package" and comes 4. Management threatens to sack the entire workforce they don't return to work unconditionally. 5. Secret negotiations between national officials and 6. A new deal is reached: management withdraw the ickings and the unions agree to the package. 7. The national officials pronounce the deal a "vicery" and the membership reluctantly accept it. That is what happened on several occasions at BL in, he '70s and it's also what happened last month at the ¡ovan shipyard (now owned by the Norwegian company The company told the press that the oufcome was *not victory for either party", but then they could afford to WORKERS"

e magnanimous: they'd got everything they wanted. The Confed, the AEU-dominated alliance of all the shipmilding and engineering unions, had backed the Govan tewards' decision not to negotiate until the sackings were But then Alex Ferry and the Confed leaders spent a veek in secret talks with management and made no atempt to build support for the strike. The Scottish TUC vas similarly unenthusiastic about the strike, with General Secretary Campbell Christie urging "sensible regotiations" but avoiding any call for solidarity action. LIBERTY 91 In the end, the Confed officials recommended a return o work on the same pay and conditions terms which had provoked the strike in the first place: an angry mass neeting voted 653 to 414 to accept. The central argument was that the yard might shut if the dispute continued.

The union bureaucrats love to boast that "we'd have seen willing to fight management but the members let us lown" • A strike like the one at Govan exposes that sort of gaff: the members were, initially, solid and morale was sigh. With decent leadership, they would have stayed but. Kvaerner's threat to close down the yard was probably a bluff — but even if it wasn't, Govan shipyard workers have an obvious example to follow in resisting This miserable story of squandered rank and file militancy may well set a dangerous precedent: Rolls Royce have already withdrawn their mass sackings. Whe the union leaders accept their pay freeze no doubt we wi be told that, overall, a "victory" has been achieved.

vaerner Govan is a classic example of rank and rile Rolls Royce is a classic example of the almost laughable weakness of the "left"" in the unions, faced CAXTON HOUSE LONDON 218:30-JUNE The Morning Star last week reported, with obvious ap proval, a lobby of Rolls Royce's AGM where workers, "kitted out in City-style bowler hats", buttonholed shareholders "to enlist support for a four-point plan to save 6,000 jobs and the future of the key Leavesden helicopter plant". The object of this farcical resurrection of the "anti-monopoly alliance" (workers plus small shareholders vs nasty Lord Tombs) was to "urge the company to seek short-term funding projects from the government to weather the recession". All very well, perhaps, as a publicity stunt, but as a strategy for resisting Rolls' wholesale attack it's useless.

More worrying still is a "detailed survival plan" drawn up by the officials, which even the Morning Star admits would involve the partial closure of the Leavesden plant. Presumably, if Rolls do anything short of closing down ORGANISED BY THE ALLIANCE FOR WORKERS' LIBERTY the whole site, it will be hailed as a great "victory".

nyone who senior social worker for INSIDE Staffordshire Social hof disputes that Services, and his role as roke out in British THE: UNIONS "the chief architect and eyland in the late 1970s initiator" of "pindown" ill have experienced a It has not made us aware of istinct sense of deja vu the real issues behind the scandal. hen reading about the Pindown was a disciplinary -cent Kvaerner Govan method used in some of the rike. residential children's homes The pattern is almost the run by Staffordshire. The Ime: Leyy report says: "pindown fundamentally relied on 1. Management proposes *package" of draconian Sleeper isolation, humiliation, and confrontation, was wholly Itacks on working negative and entirely unaconditions and/or wages. ceptable." 2. The union leadership prevaricates, Young people and children rends acceptance. as young as nine were made to strip down to their ut on strike. underwear or, in some cases, nighclothes and were kept in sparsely furnished rooms in solitary confinement. They were deprived of any form of anagement. communication with their peers, staff and the outside world.

They rose at 7am, had their meals in silence and had to knock on the door to be allowed to go to the toilet.

The only occupation allowed was the mindless task of coivaerner) in Glasgow. pying out the telephone directory. One young person was kept in this inhumane conditions for 84 days.

This treatment is indefinsible. Through his solicitor Latham attempted to justify this regime as a "contract vithdrawn. whereby issues, problems and relationships were confronted and privileges were fully earned". But clothes, reading material and human com"privileges" cor hts, children munication not and young people in care.

Social service managers, local councillors and government departments have denied knowledge of "pindown" but the Levy report quite clearly states that "pindown" was not a secid technique.

A concerned worker wrote a departmental memo as early as 1984, but "pindown" continued. There were many visits to the homes involved by members of the local closure. social services committee who failed to notice what was going on under their noses. Did they, I wonder, ever speak to the children, or read the log books? Apparently not.

In 1987 the Social Services Inspectorate visited one of the homes and failed to notice what was happening.

The government's response has been to order an inwith a similar situation. vestigation by Bill Utting, the Social Services Inspectorate Chief! What a response. His inquiry will only look at the monitoring and control of children's homes and won't include issues of staffing and resources. The intended thoroughness of the report can surely be judged by the fact that Bill Utting retires on 19 July and intends to complete the inquiry before he leaves Barry O'Neill, the former Director of Staffordshire Social Services, who took early retirement last December, told the Levy inquiry that "there was a clear Tony Latham policy decision to let Tony Latham get on with it and not to interfere as long as he produced the goods." What were those goods? Traumatised, acquiescent children?

The media have pointed out that the majority of staff are unqualified and inexperienced. As a former residential social worker, I HOO IF Y HATE THỊ POLLTA THREE DAYS OF SOCIALIST DISCUSSION AND DEBATE MANY INTERNATIONAL GUESTS CAXTON HOUSE, 129 ST JOHN'S WAY, LONDON N19 TICKETS AND DETAILS FROM THE ALLIANCE FOR WORKERS LIBERTY, PO BOX 823, LONDON SE15 4NA. OR PHONE MARK ON 071-639 7965 WORKERS' LIBERTY '91 IS SPONSORED BY THE SOCIALIST ORGANISER EDITORIAL BOARD.

But training should not be necessary to stop children being treated cruelly, as with "pindown" • Training should be about ways of working with very difficult children, and alleviating the all too real stress of this particular job, which carries a high risk of personal attack.

Many residential social workers are committed to the children and young people in their care. Many residential homes do provide a positive alternative for children who cannot remain with their families. Media coverage has ranged from restrained to emotive to hysterical.

But it has failed to question this society's sanctioning of the punitive treatment of children. Remember the "short, sharp, shock" treatment meted out to juveniles in the early 1980s? This coincided - perhaps not incidentally - with the "birth" of Latham's brainchild, "pinThatcher and the Tories have long lauded the virtues of the family. Latham is said to have used "pindown" deliberately to give its recipients a negative view of care and get them to return to their families.

If so, he ignored the reasons why the children were in care in the first place.

Scan page 5

JE

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 488

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →