Socialists for Labour
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-06-06Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 3
HANDS - BRADFORD SATE t is time for socialists to some plain speaking on A. general election is coming. It might come as early as October, or as late as next June, but it is not going to be more than a year from now.
The general election will be a chance to get rid of the Tories - it will be the only constitutional chance to put them out for another five years.
What are the alternatives? Either the Labour Party under Neil Kinnock has moved so far to the right there is now no real difference between Labour and the Tories, and therefore socialists have no choice in the election and should treat it as an irrelevance. Or there are still important differences between Labour in one camp, and the Tories and Liberal Democrats in the other, and therefore socialists should actively work for a Labour victory in the Socialists are increasingly divided on this question. In response to the disgusting antics of the Kinnockites who lead the Labour Party, many socialists have given way to a bitter mood of hopelessness: there is, they say, or half say, no alternative to the Tories, and certainly not Neil Kinnock's Labour Party.
We in Socialist Organiser and the Alliance for Workers' Liberty believe that socialists should throw their weight strongly behind the Labour Party in the coming election. Between the Tories and Labour - even under Kinnock and his gutless team of public relations experts and right-wing careerists -there is, still, a fundamental distinction.
The Labour Party is still, despite what Kinnock and his friends have done - the political party of the trade unions, which means that it is the party of the organised working class movement in Britain. The Labour Party is a vast distance now from the sort of political party the working class needs: but it is the only mass working class party there is.
To the left of Labour there is nothing that has political credibility with more than a few thousand workers. In national politics there is simply nothing that could conceivably offer itself as an alternative to the Tories.
The Liverpool left is really no exception. There, a sizeable group of anti-Kinnock leftists the Militant-led "Real Labour" Broad Left - has split from the Labour Party and won a bloc of seats on the council. Despite this success, it is improbable that they can even win the late Eric Heffer's seat in the upcoming Walton by-election, though, a is impossible that they though, apparently, they plan to could in a general election present themselves as an alternative to the Tories even on Merseyside. That is the measure of where the left is, because in Liverpool the anti"The emansipation ofathe weeking class is also the emancipation of all human beings without distinction of Set or se Karta Socialist Organiser PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA doesdesk 10704089) 796 Larest date for seporise Monda Jbhn DiMahor Published by WL Publications Ltd, PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA Printed by Tridant Press, Edenbridge Registered as a newspaper at the Post Office Articles do not necessarily reflect the views of Socialist Organiser and are in a personal capacity unless otherwise stater
EACHERS
fightin Educat Kinnock left has gone furthest from Labour and, in the local elections, can claim to have established some electoral credibility.
No, Labour is the only conceivable alternative to the Tories which the labour movement will have in the general election.
This is, to be sure, a grim situation for socialists. We are in this situation now because, in the great battles of the early '80s - when, for a while, it looked as if the left could remake the existing mass labour movement - we were defeated in the unions and in the Labour Party by the right wing and their soft left allies.
As a result of that defeat we have seen the Kinnockite right-wing leaders of the Labour Party rat on workers in struggle, refuse to lead - or even support - the battle against the poll tax. We see them doing their best to look like Tories with a slightly more sensitised social conscience. We see them now refusing to mobilise workers to fight the Tories, and indulging in endless passive waiting for the Tories to get so unpopular that an election victory drops at Neil Kinnock's feet.
The revulsion which sections of the left feel for Kinnock's Labour Party is all too understandable. But revulsion is a bad guide in politics, and a short-sighted one. Despite Kinnock, a Labour election victory would bring great benefits to the working-class movement.
Tory defeat after a dozen years in power would break their mystique and shatter the sense that they are invulnerable. The feeling of powerlessness and helplessness before the brutal determination ot the entrenched Tories has been a big factor in undermining working-class militancy and self-confidence throughout the 1980s.
No matter how right CRISIS government would be, it would inspire no such feeling of helplessness in the labour movement. Quite the opposite: no matter how right wing Labour's leaders are the fact of a Labour victory would nevertheless encourage workers to look for advantages and for openings that would let them advance. Workers would be encouraged to press wage claims and to demand the restoration of the cuts the Tories have made in the health service.
Kinnock says that Labour would keep most of the Tory anti-union legislation. But pressure would mount from the trade unions for radical changes. Even without such changes, it is highly unlikely that a Kinnock government would be able to use the anti-union legislation now on the books with the same crippling ruthlessness the Tories used - for example — to destroy the dockers' defensive strike two years ago.
he scoundrels who lead Labour would perhaps try. The labour movement would fight back. The left in the labour movement -Labour Party and trade unions would revive in the fight around such questions. When the then Labour government tried to bring in anti-union legislation in 1969 resistance from the labour movement forced it to retreat and abandon its plans.
To be indifferent to these issues because of disgust with Kinnock is to be indifferent to politics. To be indifferent to replacing the Tories with a Labour government because Kinnock would try to do in Britain what "socialists" like himself have done in France, Spain, Australia and New Zealand, is to be ridiculously fatalistic. It is to be defeatist even before the battle begins.
Kinnock will not be in control of the forces unleashed in the labour movement by a Tory defeat. The labour movement will resist many of the measures Kinnock will try to implement.
Many workers who are now Kinnockite because they think Kinnock's Labour is the only hope we have of getting the Tories out will raise their expectations once the Tories are defeated. Once the labour movement has kicked out the Tories we can stop the Kinnockite right-wing Labour leaders carrying on with Tory policies! Anyone who says otherwise now is a wretched coward and defeatist!
The fight to get rid of the Tories could mobilise millions of workers now, even a fight focused merely on the call for an immediate general election, it only Neil Kinnock would fight. A left-wing campaign to kick the Tories out and return a Labour government, even an unofficial campaign of limited numbers, can give the left itself a unifying focus, and the ability to mobilise behind us many workers who are not now particularly left wing, but who do desperately want to stop the Tories destroying the National Health Service.
For the "revolutionary" left to turn its back on the election is for the left to turn its back on the millions of workers who will back Kinnock for the reasons above. It would be to turn our backs on the working class as it actually exists in Britain now after a dozen years of being battered by the Thatcherite class warriors in power, That is why left wingers have organised "Socialists for Labour". That is our approach.
Against this, the jaded and weary defeatism which grips much of the revolutionary left is simply not serious working class politics. It is, in many cases. just not politics IS a reversion to primitive anarchist attitudes and to old-fashioned "preaching socialism" and to the sort of helpless bewilderment in face of bourgeois power which characterises the socialist sects before the birth of the modern labour movement.
This election is the only political process available to the British working class right now. Socialists must help workers go through this experience and learn from it, not tell them "everything is hopeless" (and in the case of the SWP add: except strikes). To say everything is hopeless, and add bitter "T-rrevolutionary" curses at Kinnock is the most pathetic and irresponsible sectarianism. say socialists should perhaps vote Labour on the day but should not now try tc organise the left independently to fight for the Labour vote in the election - that is to accept that politics is now the exclusive domain of the triumphant right wing of the Labour Party. That too, even when accompanied by much "revolutionary" noise, is the crassest and most prostrate political defeatism.
Small, local breakaways from Labour like that in Liverpool - - a breakaway at the heart of which is Militant, which made such a wretched hash of things when it had power in Liverpool, opening the door to the present right wing Labour council — are no more an alternative than is weary abstention.
The key task now facing the working class is to get rid of the Tories. By organising to help do it the left can also prepare the labour movement for the inevitable fight against a future right-wing Kinnockite government.
The serious left in Britain now are those who can combine the fight against the right wing of the labour movement with putting forward principled perspectives to help the entire broad labour movement -the movement as it actually is now orient itself in the battle with the ruling class and their chief political party.
Right now that means throwing what we have to throw into the fight to drive out the Tories. That is the necessary focus now of the fight to build an organisation of socialists who will ultimately be able to reorganise the entire labour movement, doing the job the left tried and failed to do in the '80s.
It is a job that must be done, because there can be no socialism without the working class, and without remaking the labour movement it has built in over a century of class struggle.
Until it is done, the left always be faced with dilemmas such as those we now face in this election.
Build "Socialists for Labour"! Edittomed Board Grahem Bash Vladimir Derer TerEngleton Jatin Haria (Labour Party Black Sections)
Dorothy Menedy Joe Marino John Mcllroy bhre Ichbison Peter Tatchell awn from a broad cross-section of the Expressed in articles are of the authors and not
Scan page 4
Organiser Liz Dickenson Rolls Royce workers steps to a Saturation coverage by the press, television and radio has made us all familiar with the name of Tony Latham, a would agree. Staff are undervalued, low paid and not given enough training.
----- pull-quotes -----
GONN TE -STOP THE CORY THE pro-capitalist a Kinnock Labour
ILGO NO JOB CUTS!