The law is a sexist pia!
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-05-23Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 13 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 13
Television Cathy Nugent reviews nside Story dealt with rape — the police investigation of rape, newspaper reporti of rape, and with rape as an experience women are put through.
The hour-long programme -entitled A Very Serious Offence was able to do no more than scratch the surface of the issues volved. Nonetheless, these were dealt with seriously.
Mostly, the programme dealt with the way rape victims are treated by the police. And, I suppose, contrary to most of our expectations, offered a positive image.
One woman was filmed reporting a vicious attack on her by three men. She was interviewed by police from the Met - a notoriously brutal police force in all other respects - sympathetical. ly by both men and women.
I don't know if there have been enough changes of attitude by the police to justify this picture. Unfortunately, the programme did not give us any information from which to judge. Certainly police policy and practice has recent years.
Women officers from the Met were shown being trained to deal with rape victims. Past police practice was criticised. A video was shown of a programme made some years ago about the Thames Valley police. Here a woman was harassed, accused of wasting police time and interrogated abou her sexual experience.
This scene was used as a startin point for discussion. The looks of horror, disgust and shame on the faces of the women police was very revealing.
The rest of the programme seemed slightly incidental and was awkwardly spliced together with the film of the woman in the police station.
There were interviews with two extremely brave women who had been victims of rape attacks and had gone to court. There was an interview with a woman barrister who seemed quite sensible if a bit toffee-nosed in her distinctions. between women who had a "reasonable lifestyle" and those who didn't.
Most unsatisfactory though wer interviews with convicted sex of-F fenders. This largely consisted of voice overs. This may have been necessary but the overall effect was too selective and too shallow.
It was shallower in other respects too. We were bombarded with statistics flashing up on the screen. One I caught stated that b 1992 the Home Office intends to have universal rehabilitation programmes for sex offenders. Okay, but what likelihood is there that this will really happen?
But despite this too unsceptical and bland approach, I thought the programme was excellent. If the filmed events in the police station encourage even more women to come forward (as is now happening) and report attacks this is a good thing.
But of course the story does no end there. The woman in the programme decided not to proceed with her "complaint". The implication was that she couldn't face any comeback from her attackers, or did not want to go through the trauma in court.
It is a sad fact that going to court is the major stumbling bloci for rape victims.
There they will be put on trial. They may be expected to be emotional and tearful (and thus convincing). They will be expected to account for their own sexual morality. This is quite astounding: ly unfair!
Elsewhere the law takes accoun of prejudice. For instance the accused's past record (if they have one) is never read out in court under any circumstances. Yet a Sexist pig in a wig woman's sexual experience is.
As a defence it can only imply "loose women ask for it" that's the law, then the law is a sexist pig!
Yes, of course it is!
It should be changed: perience should be deemed 'inadmissible evidence". Rape in marriage should be on the statute book, and judges should not be obliged, no more than they are in any other crime, to instruct juries to "be careful" about the victim's statements.
Scan page 14
National lesbian and gay activist conference an apolitical old Socialist Organiser No. 487 page 14 LET*