Kitsch "Trotskyists
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-05-23Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 12
jor struggles which actually took place, say- world view demolished by Socialist Action, "the East European revolutions are the worst setback for they ended up decreeing 24,000 redundancies AGAINST THE as a "tactical move" , making cuts, and allowing an unscrupulous buffoon like Derek TIDE Hatton to become their chief representative. Such fiascos followed logically from their "perspectives" in which everything was always getting better in the best of all ilitant (Revolutionary Socialist historical processes: if indeed the future was League, the Grant faction) was always rosier than the present, then why risk dimmest of the left factions in the established positions and opportunities for propaganda by taking chances in 1960s. But in the early 1970s they grew "ephemeral" struggles? Why not always substantially. delay, temporise, postpone?
They were in the right place — the Labour Despite some successes they have had in Party Young Socialists - by inertia rather the anti-poll tax movement, Militant has than by good judgement, but they were there, visibly declined in recent years. And now the at a time when all the other left groups were, collapse of Stalinism in Eastern Europe has to one extent or another, continuing ultra- shattered their world view, more drastically left illusions generated by their elation than it has shaken the SWP's. around 1968. They offered an apparently The alleged economic successes of stable, serious perspective, while the other Stalinism, about which Militant used to write left groups wavered and zig-zagged in their so enthusiastically, were for them the outattempts to adjust and reorient. ward and visible proof of the secret truth Later they were able to extend their growth they cherished: that capitalism was helplessly from the LPYS into some trade unions, declining, and a new order irresistibly moving notably the CPSA; and they got a big boost forward. But now it is Stalinism that declines from the enormous publicity they had when helplessly! Its alleged successes were the Labour Party first started witch-hunting Potemkin villages, facades behind which them, in the early 1980s. there was emptiness and decay. The supBut their successes led them into fiascos. posedly automatic forward movement of Their successes led them into positions where history - propelled by the basic needs of the they could no longer just repeat their pro- productive forces, no less - has somehow paganda and wait for their "perspectives" to gone into reverse. come true. They won the leadership of the Militant today is like a chicken continuing CPSA and a leading role in Liverpool City to run around with its head cut off...Like the Council. Now they had to lead struggles, not SWP, it has an apparatus, a public profile, just predict them. They showed a miserable an established momentum which will prolack of nerve, judgement, and capacity to bably keep it going for a long time, and even learn from mistakes. They were timid, enable it to grow. But, like the SWP and inbureaucratic, dishonest. deed more so, it is moribund.
During their time in the leadership of the CPSA they tried hard to damp down the ma- he IMG current have also had their the ing they were "premature". In Liverpool collapse of Stalinism, though their the working class since Hitler's to power in 1933.
Beginning on 17 July 1936, General Francisco Franco led an armed rebellion against Spain's Republican government. The far right, the church and the old order rallied to the generals. The armed working class rose to back the government against the fascists, then, radicalised, began the struggle for power behind the Republican lines.
The two million-strong anarchist movement and socialist left, the POUM, were caught between!
view, more flexible, gives them chance to regroup and rationalise.
In late 1989 Ernest Mandel, addressing a Socialist Outlook conference, described the revolutions in Eastern Europe as processes which could lead either to a progressive; liberating workers' political revolution or to a foul, reactionary capitalist social counterrevolution. Both of these culminations, he argued, were far off: the workers were in political disarray, Western capital was cautious about moving into Eastern Europe, and the emerging private capitalist forces within Eastern Europe were weak.
This last argument surely underestimates the speed with which private-profit enterprise is growing from the "black economies" and on the fringes of government-owned business in Eastern Europe, as well as forgetting that government-owned business can be capitalist too, but the essential point was that Mandel foresaw a long period before either a socialist or a capitalist decision.
What would happen in that long period? What was the character of the overturns which had already taken place and of the new regimes in Eastern Europe? Mandel was silent. The present was an undefinable limbo between the "deformed workers' state" past and the either-socialist-or-capitalist future:
Almost 18 months later, that is still the dominant view of the neo-Trotskyist spectrum of opinion represented by Outlook. And they reach this conclusion because it is the only way they can square their good impulses (leading them to welcome the East European revolutions as opening the way to still deny national rights to the Israeli Jews. Though they are more willing to entertain political criticism of Sinn Fein than Socialist Action they have argued for British trade unions to withdraw from Ireland."
the free development of workers' movements) with their bad theory (which logically should lead them to condemn those revolutions as horrible regressions to capitalism.
Some of them yield to the pressure of the bad theory, Oliver Macdonald (a maverick PIRINA fascism and their deadly "ally", the Stalinist Communist Party. Betrayed and murdered, the worker: rose in Barcelona in May 1937 and were put down.. The anarchist leaders split, some joining the bourgeois Republican government and Durutti, on the left, marching off to fight, leaving politics to the liberals and the Stalinists.
Eventually, in 1939, the fascists won out. working class had suffered a terrible defeat.
within Outlook) declared in a debate at the 1990 Workers' Liberty summer school that the East European revolutions marked the end of the epoch that opened in 1917, the end of an epoch in which a new social order had competed with capitalism. Socialist Action asserts that the East European revolutions are the worst setback for the working class since Hitler's rise to power in 1933.
However, the IMG faction had dispersed and declined well before 1989, because of its inability and lack of serious, continuous work in any direction rather than because its politics were necessarily worse than the other groups. The story was told in an article in Socialist Organiser no. 478.
Socialist Action is now a grotesque sect, closer both in its political positions and in its methods to the collapsing Stalinist tradition than to anything Trotskyist. Outlook is less grotesque. Its core is made up of people from the "IMG" political traditions who became disgusted and were wearied by the wild political gyrations of John Ross (who is now editor of Socialist Action). That is to their credit. But rather than taking on Ross and defeating him in factional battle, they opted out to go their own way; rather than reexamining their whole tradition, they have slipped into a bland, tepid, sloppy "average The ideas of the "IMG" tradition still operate in their minds. Though they are less vehment than the SWP, they still deny national rights to the Israeli Jews. Though they are more willing to entertain political criticism of Sinn Fein than Socialist Action, they have argued for British trade unions to withdraw from Ireland. Though they are less disposed to excited discoveries of the "new mass vanguard" than they used to be, they have huge illusions about the potential of the Socialist Movement as such a "new vanguard"?.
Towards the end of the Gulf War, Socialist Organiser wrote to Socialist Outlook noting that the two groups had cooperated fruitfully in anti-war work, and suggesting a formal meeting to discuss further cooperation in that work. The reply was a letter of two sentences, the first saying that there was "no political basis" for such a meeting, the second suggesting a phone call to fix a meeting. At the meeting they explained that they wanted to make plain that agreeing to consult implied "no political convergence" between the two groups. In other words, Outlook is frightened of seeming close to SO but can't quite think how to distance itself by clear and coherent political argument.
Scan page 13
Cinem.
Tony Brown reviews Hamlet Kenneth Branagh's Henry V Shakespeare film. It wasn't that it was a bad film, it was just that 1 found Shakespeare movies too inaccessible.
All the criticism normally aimed at studying Shakespeare at school - too difficult, outdated language - applied even more so to the film.
It is ironical that the freshest attempt at a Shakespeare play should come out of Hollywood. Hamlet's success continues the trend of nonformula films doing well this year. Blockbuster sequels are playing to small audiences and movies that aren't expected to do well are becoming hits.
It's even more of a surprise because Zeffirelli's decision to cast Mel Gibson as the Prince of Denmark was scoffed at. How could Mad Max play the anguished and procrastinating Hamlet? Well he does; and he does it very well. Gone are most of the annoying mannerisms that Gibson has developed, and in their place is a robust and assertive characterisation of Hamlet.
Zeffirelli has stripped the play back to the core story of the murder of Hamlet's father by his uncle Claudius, Claudius' marriage to Hamlet's mother, Gertrude, and Hamlet's relationship with Ophelia. -This allows him to focus on Hamlet's relations with the two women in his life, Gertrude and Ophelia.
When Gertrude marries her brother-in-law, Hamlet declares: "treachery, they name is woman" (Shakespeare was more subtle: "Frailty, thy name is woman".)
Hang on, what about Claudius? Glen Close and Mel Gibson play Gertrude and Hamlet He actually murdered Hamlet's tather. But it becomes obvious that Hamlet feels Gertrude has betrayed him as much as his dead father. It is his mother's love that he wants.
Soon after Ophelia, at the behest of Polonius, her father, seeks to compromise Hamlet. She does it only in obedience to her father and against her own best wishes.
Hamlet feigns madness to protect himself and give himself time to consider his predicament.
His angst has a more concrete source. He is in love with his mother, and with Ophelia, both of whom appear to have betrayed him.
Zeffirelli plays the much parodied scene with Yorrick's skull at the graveside as the piece of humour it is in the lead-up to the final climactic scenes where Laertes, Gertrude, Claudius and Hamlet all die.
For Glenn Close the horrific death scene has become part of her forte, following Fatal Attraction, though at least she only dies once here.
Her Gertrude is passionate and sensual and along with Alan Bates, lan Holm, Paul Schofield and Helena Bonham-Carter, makes for a strong cast.
If you feel like something classical, then Hamlet is worth seeing. Gibson's sword in the final scenes is as lethal a weapon as anything else on the screen this year.
----- pull-quotes -----
Those who condemned to relive it
"Though [Outlook] are less vehment than the SWP, they