Welfarism: the Tory target
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-05-23Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 11
Attempts to control public A expenditure and cut back the welfare state have been less successful. The government White Paper on Public Expenditure published in November 1979 announced "Public expenditure is at the heart of our current difficulties".
The Tories were not concerned with public expenditure as such -the state needed to spend, spend, spend on the police and the army, for Thatcher was determined to maintain Britain's military role externally and extend it internally -but with spending on industry which distorted the market and, crucially, with welfare spending.
At the heart of their strategy was the view that such spending was economically disastrous as it fuelled inflation, government borrowing, and must be slashed and so must taxation, which fuelled inflation as workers sought to compensate for tax losses through wage increases.
What the government was saying essentially was that the role welfare spending played in reproduction, in accumulation - through providing capital with a healthy, skilled, compliant labour force - and in the legitimisation of the capitalist system, by demonstrating that the state looked after people who could not look after themselves, would be discarded in the interests of slashing inflation and increasing profitability.
Welfarism took resources in terms of labour and investment from the productive private sector. It did not work — look at the failures of the education system or the NHS.
Government intervention had created a political market in which the parties were forced to outbid each other to increase state spending to buy the votes of the inflated labour forces in the public sector and others dependent on state expenditure.
Government overload set in as governments tried to do too much and too many things the market did better. Inflation soared and had to be paid for by more taxation and government borrowing, stimulating the money supply and stoking up further inflation. The consequent dependency culture made people even more demanding and gave the process yet a further twist.
Geoffrey Howe's first budget set the pace in June 1979 as he put up prescription charges, cut income tax, announced £1.5 billion reductions in public expenditure and promised to reduce the Public Sector Borrowing Requirement.
The National Enterprise Board was gradually abolished and 57 of the quangos which had flourished under Labour were wound up:
But the recession made things difficult for the government. Social security for strikers was undermined, earnings related supplements were abolished, benefits were taxed, and pensions and other benefits were, from 1980, only increased in with the annual increase in prices not wages. Prescription charges increased from 45p in July 1979 to 70p a year later, and had soared to E1 by December 1980.
Local government's grants were slashed. Council house rents were increased and charges for school meals were hoisted. Regional budgets were cut and the squeeze on education began.
But much of this "good" work was undone by increasing social security payments as unemploy'For most of the decade the Conservatives ambition to reduce the tax burden went unrealised for all the rich"
ment reached new post-war levels and increases in spending on the military and the police, as well as the need to buy off certain public sector unions.
By the end of the first Thatcher government public spending had not decreased, indeed, on some figures, the "good" work of the 1974 Labour government was undone and public expenditure increased to 46% of GDP.
With faster economic growth and a stabilisation and decline in unemployment during the second Thatcher government, public expenditure as a proportion of GDP fell to around 40% as compared with 43% in 1979 Nonetheless it still increased in absolute terms so that again, whilst there was success, it was very limited success.
As late as 1985 spending on law and order" had increased 29% on its 1979 level, social security had increased by 28%, defence by 23%, industry and employment by 17% and health by 17%.
The only real cuts were in education and in housing where there was a massive 55% cut. — the consequence of the blitz on council housing. Since then these figures have increased as the government has come to grips with the restructuring of education and the NHS.
The picture is, however, a complex one: in education, for example, demographic changes meant that "demand" on the schools were reduced whilst, because of the greater numbers of old people, demand on the NHS was increased, and, of course, the annual cost for treatment of the old are far greater than the cost for treating the young - and expenditure is also pushed up by the soaring cost of new technology.
For most of the decade the Conservatives' ambition to reduce the tax burden went unrealised for all except the rich.
By 1987 the tax paid by a married couple with two children on five times average earnings had declined by 6% and the tax paid by a similar couple on 10 times average earnings had declined 15%. But a similar couple on average earnings were paying 2.5% more than in 1979 and a similar couple on half average earnings were paying an extra 4.2% in tax.
The restructuring of social securíty, the introduction of the Social Fund, the changes in education introduced by the Education Reform Act and the introduction of the market into the NHS, would be seen as important achievements by the Tories. They do represent progress for the broad privatisation approach.
The Tories' policies have not been simple failures. But they have to be balanced against the fiascos of the Housing Action Trusts, and the "pick a landlord" schemes. Despite this, the Tories have succeeded in destroying council housing and increasing homelessness - and in seriously weakening local government in relation to the national state. But even here their achievements have been contradictory.
The poll tax, the final move in the slogging match with local government since 1980 - a match Thatcher entered not because of any antipathy towards local government but because of its potential to foil centrally determined programmes for the restriction of public expenditure - was the final throw of the dice that brought about her fall.
And as we enter the second Thatcherite recession all the problems of the first, this time reappearing in more severe form, will inhibit the public expenditure project.
Scan page 12
The collapse of Stalinism and the left Socialist Organiser No. 487 page 12 pET: A JEREZ 47C03