Tube dispute over - for now
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-05-17Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 15 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 15
unions' ability to negotiate over pay would be a disaster, opening up the danger of a big growth in non-unionism.
The pay freeze has another side too. It could well herald the start of a management offensive aimed at holding down wage levels across manufacturing industry.
With profits plunging and production levels plummeting, wage and salaries costs per unit are now at their highest level for a decade. 12.1%.
Rolls Royce has seen profits fall from £233 million to £156 million between 1984 and 1990, and has a big interest in driving down real wage levels to boost profitability.
Rolls Royce workers will pay for an economic crisis not of their making. Their ability to resist this double-sided assault will have big repercussions for trade unionism elsewhere.
If union organisation is to remain effective then there must be no concessions over pay. For that reason the fight against the pay freeze and the new contracts must be linked together. Concessions over pay in return for promises over future *consultations" must be avoided like the plague.
Rolls Royce stewards need to tackle the bosses" viability arguments head on. Rolls is still making massive profits and Chairman Lord Francis Tombs of Brailes could still afford to give himself a 51% pay rise last By a Central line guard and RMT memberIs the RMT circular put it: Significant concessions gained. at ACAS, strike action called off""
Management's concessions do mark a retreat on their part They have abandoned their *Level 3" cuts and Action Stations proposals (respectively 2000 job losses and the package of "efficiency" proposais defeated by the '89 strikes). Guaranteed earnings for transferred staff have been extended from 18 months to 3 years. Promotion and transfer arrangements and the nomination system have been restored and the machinery of negotiation Hot cakes he new look Socialist Organiser is selling like hot cakes at trade union conferences this weel At the CPSA - low paid civil servants - conference has been upheld.
However, there are still going to be 780 job losses and the other concessions are agreements to talks and working parties on safety, rosters and staffing, but with no committments, no guarantees, On balloting for strike action RMT got a 2:1' majority — on the face of it a good result, but it should be remembered that the worst ballot result during the '89 strikes produced a 5:í majority. This result must have been due in large part to the actions of the ASLEF leadership. ASLEF recruits only train drivers and guards (who were less affected by the cuts) and is a union with a strong craft tradition. Craft unions might instil a strong sense of solidarity within their ranks, but they also toster a sectional outlook which makes unity with other workers more difficult. ASLEF argued constantly "the Bournemouth at least 60 papers were sold in the first two days.
Meanwhile at the UCW postal workers' annual conference in Blackpool, 20 papers and 24 copies of our Lessons of the Postal Strike pamphlet were purchased by delegates. curs don't affect train drivers -we've got no dispute" . ASLEF representatives devoted their entire effort for months to undermining the case for a united fight against the cuts. This culminated in ASLEF telling their members to cross RMT picket lines to break any strike.
If ASLEF had united with RMT we could have defeated all management's proposals.
Management of course made all the propaganda advantage they could of the division. After the RMT ballot result was announced they threatened suspension or the sack for anyone striking who refused to sign a pledge promising to take no further industrial action. Given ASLEF'S threatened scabbing, this raised the prospect of RMT activists being victimised and sacked with little hope of united action to win reinstatement.
In the circumstances there was a good case for accepting the deal. However, RMT members were given no choice in the matter.
The budget deficit remains — management may have stepped down a little but it can only be a matter of time before they're back with more cuts. • Socialist Organiser supporters on the Underground have started producing a fortnightly newsletter: 'The Tubeworker".
Scan page 16
Adam Keller reports from Tel Aviv