The trouble with K Aid Televisi
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-05-17Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 13 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 13
Gustavete, Carmela and Paulino seek comfort -NTH Jean Think of the starving millions", my mother| used to say to me when I, didn't want to finish my dinner.
She would say it with a hint of irony in her voice - knowing that whether I ate my dinner or not had no bearing on how many more millions in another part of the world would be starving. It must have been a phrase that had been said to her, in all seriousness, some time in her own past: by her mother perhaps, or in church.
Princess Anne, judging by the posters on every bus shelter lately, is more backward than my mother; telling us to give up a meal for charity, as if we all have some personal guilt or responsibility for those starving to death in Africa, Bangladesh or the Iraqi-Kurdish mountains.
One of Princess Anne's meals would feed one of the Kurdish families, kids included, for six months, while the working class women of the North Peckham estate or Birkenhead are choosing between feeding the kids or paying the poll tax.
But those working class women will feel more guilt than Princess Anne, for sure. Their kids are not dying of starvation, are they. Their kids are not being put in tiny, doll-sized graves while the mothers weep, helpless to stop the deaths of their own children.
Princess Anne probably makes a monthly standing order out to Oxfam, safe in the knowledge that she has earned every penny she's got and is prepared to be very generous with it, too. Why should she feel guilty?
And the working class women will send money in, despite the choices they have to make week after week, because they do care. Chris Tarrant, on The Simple Truth. concert for the Kurdish refugees last night (Sunday 12 May) said that kids were sending in 10p coins.
Thank goodness. The idea that *all charity is bad because the state should provide" just doesn't hold water when we watch our TV screens. Even if the governments, both local and imperialist, are responsible for what is happening in parts of Africa, the fact that working class people here feel a social responsibility for, and a sense of solidarity with, those starving to death is a good thing.
So why did last night's concert grate so much? Maybe Lenny Henry has found a knack of mixing humour with pointless death better than Chris Tarrant. Or maybe watching Tracey Ullman make sugarsweet statements about how awful it must be not to be able to feed your own children, one breath before telling us that her daughter was off visiting Princess Di, has the effect of making you want to puke.
Hopefully Tracey's daughter, when she grows up, will be able to ask her friends in high places why the Kurdish children are dying, who drove them from their homes, who paid the driver for years, and who is prepared to do so much now except get rid of the driver.
And hopefully, when in reply she is told that the only thing she can do is miss a meal, she too will puke in disgust at the bypocrisy of those in power.