Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Will Militant form a new party?

Socialist Organiser no. 486, 17 May 1991 · scan pp. 12–13 · Anne Field · about 1,954 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 12

Those who do not learn from history are condemned to relive it laid careful plans to deal with the General Strike. Mosley fascists. On the eve of the General Strike The Tories were ready for confrontation when A Special Constabulary was created to enlarge it occurred. In 1925 they established the OMS - the police force. The armed forces were mobilisOrganisation for the Maintenance of Supplies - ed to guard the docks, railways and telephone AGAINST THE TIDE The "centrist split" in the Labour Party long predicted by Militant founding-father Ted Grant, is now underway in Liverpool.

That is the line now being argued by Merseyside Militant supporters intoxicated by their successes in the 2 May Liverpool City council elections. Six Labour Party wards stood their own candidates for council against official candidates imposed by the Labour Party bureaucracy, and five of them won.

When threatened by right-wingers with expulsion from the Labour Party for supporting the rebel candidates, Militant supporters have responded by declaring that they are leaving the Labour Party anyway and don't care about being expelled. Next year, they boast, they will have 23 rebels winning council seats.

Given the widespread disillusionment with the Labour Party leadership at both local and national level, Militant will doubtless take some people with them. Where to is another question.

Like it or not, the present situation -where 1990 had the smallest number of strikes since 1935, and the left is generally on the defensive — is not one of the wide excitement, enthusiasm and radicalisation necessary to create a mass left-wing alternative to Labour.

If Militant goes through with what its Merseyside supporters are now talking about, then the best it can realistically hope to achieve is a duplicate of the Socialist Workers Party. Militant will become one of the "sects on the fringes of the labour movement" it has denounced for so long.

The last big attempt to split a sizeable left wing from the Labour Party was in 1932, when the Independent Labour Party broke away. The ILP had been very influential in the party. It had five of the 52 Labour MPs then sitting in Parliament. It had 17,000 members. It was several times stronger than Militant can hope to become. Yet its breakaway was a fiasco. By 1935 it was down to 4,000 members.

One factor behind the talk of splitting Militant's exaggerated self-satisfaction about its strength in Liverpool. Maybe Militant people outside Liverpool will prove more cool-headed, and restrain their Merseyside comrades.

Militant took the limelight in Liverpool in 1983, when it gained controlling influence in the City Council Labour Group. In the first months of that administration, it ran a good campaign against cuts, demanding money from central government.

In July 1984 the Tory government made some concessions to Liverpool. In fact that deal was the beginning of the end for Liverpool City Council's radical stance; it avoided the possibility of a local government revolt coming together with the miners' strike then in full swing (which is what the Tories wanted to avoid), and it only postponed the council's money problems to the next year.

Militant nevertheless hailed the deal as a *95 per cent victory" and drifted into an attitude of the most stupid bureaucratic arrogance. It alienated the majority of Liverpool's black community, and many council trade unionists, by insisting on one of its own supporters as council race relations officer.

The whole business ended in a fiasco. The council gave redundancy notices to the whole workforce (as a "tactical" move), was forced to withdraw them by court action, and finally collapsed into a deal with Swiss banks which involved making cuts. The leading Militant councillor, Derek Hatton, quit the labour movement to become a spiv businessman and showbiz self-publicist.

But Militant still gloats about Liverpool! They published a book about their period of Armoured cars in Oxford Street The general strike of May 1926 holds many lessons for today. By that year the Tories had The timidity of the trade union leaders helped their plans along.

to break any major strikes. It consisted of exchanges. influence on the council which - solemnly and with a straight face - compared that period to the French revolution of 1789-94.

The political horizon of the average Militant supporter in Liverpool goes no further than the city boundaries. For over a year their supporters in wards and CLPs have moved an unending series of repetitive resolutions concerned solely with Liverpool and the poll tax. They did not know or did not care about issues such as the Gulf war or attacks on lesbian and gay rights.

It was the climax of thie self-immersion in Liverpool parochialism when, last month -after initially opposing the idea as "an act of desperation" — Militant decided to back the idea of wards standing their own candidates against official (albeit bureaucratically imposed) Labour candidates.

The six independent candidates, only one or two of whom were actually Militant supporters, stood on a platform of opposition to the poll tax although the Council budget they had supported involved setting a poll tax), opposition to rent increases (although they had abandoned the former policy of a rent freeze), opposition to redundancies (although the budget they had supported proposed a 50% non-filling of council vacancies) and opposition to bailiffs (although they kept quiet about how the "socialist" council of 1984-5 used bailiffs against rates debtors).

Not quite the "bold socialist programme" that Militant usually talks about!

he other dimension in this affair is Militant's attitude to the Labour Party. For some thirty years, Militant and its leading ideologist Ted Grant have been distinguished from other left groups by their slavish devotion to Labour Party routines. They even argued that a peaceful, parliamentary road to socialism was possible, and mostly they behaved as if they believed that socialism would eventually come by dint of winning enough resolutions in the Labour middle-class Tories, students (then an overwhelmingly conservative group) and the preit had 100,000 members.

88 Voluntary Service Committees were set up.

Party to demand the nationalisation top 200 monopolies.

In closer argument, however, they would refine the perspective. Some day, they would argue, under the pressure of the terrible crises of capitalism, the Labour Party would split between the right wing and a new "centrist" party (hovering between reform and revolution). Militant would gain leadership in the new left party and legislate socialism.

For a long time that perspective was used only to argue for continuing the routine propaganda in the Labour Party, waiting for the expected crisis, and in the meantime opposing any "premature" or "adventurist" acLiverpool shows not an exciting new departure for the left, but the inability of Militant to campaign seriously in the labour movement against purges."

tivity. Now Merseyside Militant supporters are telling us. that the long-awaited crisis is here.

If we dig back further into Ted Grant's history and Militant's pre-history, there is yet another dimension.

In the 1940s Grant led a faction in the British Trotskyist movement which sternly opposed involvement in the Labour Party, arguing that day-to-day recruitment from industrial battles would build a separate Trotskyist party strong enough to challenge Labour.

In 1949 Grant's faction collapsed and joined the Labour Party because continuing independently seemed hopeless. Grant was no more willing to learn from fiascos then than he is now, and long continued to argue that, even if life in the Labour Party was a practical necessity, politically it would be better to be outside. That thought, too, may now be reactivated.

Troops armed with gas were moved capital and the industrial centres.

Faced with all this, the TUC did little to prepare. The Samuel Commission Report, published in March 1926, proposed to cut wages of the miners, though not by as much as the mine owners wanted. It also, more tentatively, suggested longer working hours.

The miner' union rejected these proposals but the TUC continued to negotiate. JH Thomas, who was by then a Labour MP, commented:

*When the verbatim reports are written I suppose my usual critics will say that Thomas was almost grovelling, and it is true...I have never begged and pleaded like I begged and pleaded Thomas, who played a particularly treacherous role during the General Strike, later reassured the bosses: "I have never disguised that in a challenge to the Constitution, God help us unless the government won", insisting that the General Strike was no such challenge.

The Labour and TUC leadership was completely outwitted by the Tory government and the mine owners.

The lett trade union leaders, meanwhile, were involved in an 'Anglo-Russian Committee' set uf to build support for the beleagured USSR. For the young Communist Party (C), which was of course centrally involved, it was seen as a good opportunity to spread their influence.

Unfortunately, the pro-Russian stance of left union leaders was really a cheap way of getting radical credentials on faraway issues while they were selling out the workers at home. The CP's alliance with them on the Anglo-Russian Committee could not be allowed to outweigh the organisation of the rank and file in the General Strike.

Yet that is what happened. The labour leader sold out the General Strike, abandoning the miners despite growing support for the strike.

The left leaders were, at best, acquiescent. And the CP did not criticise the left too sharply for fear of splitting the Anglo-Russian Committee.

The General Strike was a very serious defeat.

The TUC General Council called it off without any guarantees for the miners. As Charles Duke of the Municipal Workers said: "Every day that the strike proceeded the control and authority e that dispute was passing out of the hands of responsible Executives into the hands of men who had no authority, no control, no responsibility and was wrecking the movement from one end to the other."

Be shall see. Militant has moved its cavity out of the Labour Party a great deal already in recent years, concentrating on anti-poll tax agitation.

Last year many Militant supporters in Glasgow wanted to stand their own anti-poll tax candidates against Labour in elections; they were restrained only with difficulty by more thoughtful comrades. It is not clear whether what's happening on Merseyside is another skirmish in the developing struggle among Militant supporters over their future, or a decisive victory in that struggle for those who want to go out of the Labour Party.

Either way the prospects are bleak. A local *alternative Labour Party" on Merseyside will soon fade away. An across-the-board split by Militant from Labour will only produce an SWP Mark 2.

And that SWP Mark 2 will have, if anything, worse politics than the SWP Mark Militant is an ossified Stalinoid sect. It supported the Soviet occupation of Afghanistan. It believes that Syria is a workers' state. It has an atrocious record with regard to the doubly oppressed (such as Blacks, women, lesbians and gays). It sat out the Gulf war on its backside.

It denounces all other left groups as *sects. on the fringes of the labour movement". It has never been prepared to do joint work with any other left group. It even went so far as to scab on Socialist Organiser by voting against a resolution tabled at a CPSA Broad Left conference last year which called for defence of this paper against the ban imposed by Labour's NEC. They would not affiliate to the 'End the Ban!' campaign because SO had dared to criticise them in articles like these.

In truth, the events in Liverpool show not an exciting new departure for the left, but the political inability of Militant to campaign seriously in the labour movement against bans and purges.

Scan page 13

Org

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 486

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →