Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Socialists should

Socialist Organiser no. 486, 17 May 1991 · scan p. 11 · about 978 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 11

Britain's major Public Service Union Struggles like the ambulance workers' can break the law successfully SWINTON HON SNUPE •KENNETH WERE 1LV.

BRIG

SAYS BOROSS IRPOR Marxist Mean Matgamna ended his (SO 4T7) Men weeks aga (SO 477) with "Up the Republic", saying that "clearcut republicanism is stil as rare as criticism of the Royal Family used to be. It should not be. Socialists and consistent democrats have to be republicans."

This is a statement that Republican Marxist heartily applauds and commends to all socialists. But we would like to add some observations.

Imagine if a socialist said that *it goes without saying that we are anti-racist, and therefore don' need to mention racism". We would all recognise immediately that such a view was adapting itself to the prevailing racism in society. It would be an excuse for accepting racism in practice and not fighting it.

Yet most British socialists say *that of course we are against the monarchy, it goes without saying, take it as read." Therefore we won't mention it. This is also not a genuine socialist view, but an adaptation to the prevailing monarchist ideas.

Despite all the extreme language and calls for world socialism immediately, at heart, British socialism is very conservative. We do want world socialism, but nobody wants to upset our cosy little world by even lifting a finger to get rid of the monarchy. Trotsky himself noticed this fact in his writings on Britain (Where is Britain going?).

The bourgeoisie would like us to think of capitalism, and the monarchy, as permanent, timeless institutions which it would be unthinkable to live without. But capitalism and the monarchy will only exist for a certain historical period. We can predict that one day there will be no monarchy.

The only point for socialists is whether it should be abolished now or later. Whether the bourgeoisie or the working class should decide. By reform or mass revolutionary action?

The best policy is that it is abolished now by working class revolutionary action. The worst is that it is abolished 100 years later by the bourgeoisie. Socialists base themselves on the best option, not the worst.

The bourgeois socialist says "leave it up to the bourgeoisie" The working class socialist says mobilise the working class so that the fate of the monarchy is in our hands.

If the working class can determine the fate of the monarchy then it is on the road to determining its own fate as a class.

It is vital to distinguish between the Monarch, the Royal Family, their titles, powers and privileges, and the Constitutional Monarchy as a system of political The Constitutional Monarchy is a total constitutional package. It includes the House of Lords, Northern Ireland, the relationship witl Scotland and Wales, Official Secrecy, the gentlemen's club known as the Commons. the corrupt electoral system, etc. To be against the Constitutional Monarchy is to be against the whole way in which politics is conducted in the United Kingdom.

Defenders of the system would like us to confine criticism to the person of the monarch. The issue is then personalised and depoliticised. Such politics is not much better than Sun-type shock horror stories. Then it would be asked — is it really worth getting out of our prams over one rich person when there are a load of other bastards to criticise?

This is to miss the point entirely. It is a new political system we need! This is summed up by the demand for a Republic, or as we would say a Federal Republic of England, Scotland, and Wales ano a United Ireland.

Among the working class, we can distinguish different attitudes. The most advanced view is republican. In the past such views were held by Chartists, Marx, Engels, Connolly and MacLean, to name but a few.

Sean says republicans are "rare". It is understandable to this as far as socialists are concerned. But if we think of the Irish working class, whether in Britain or Northerp Ireland, then republicanism is not as rare as one might suppose. There is also a much broader layer of antimonarchist sentiment. Many workers don't like the monarchy out of gut instinct, but would hardly consider themselves republicans.

Finally there is the most backward layer which supports monarchy and probably votes Tory.

mhe distinction between republicanism and antimonarchism is best illustrated by the anarchists.

They want to abolish the monarchy along with the state as. such. There is no need for a republic. Marxists, who agree with the ultimate abolition of the state, see the need to proceed to that goal through the development of higher forms of democracy. Republicanism is part of that historical development. This is why Marxists must not be merely against the monarchy but also positively republican.

Take the example of the SWP. It is anti-monarchist but not republican. Socialist Worker criticises the monarchy occasionally, but it has never made any republican demand. This tells us that the SWP dabbles in anarchism. It adapts itself to anarchist sentiments amongst the petty bourgeois youth and students.

Furthermore the SWP does not uphold the most advanced views within the class, but adapts to the average worker's anti-monarchist sentiments. For the SWP it is no more than sentiment. There is no attempt to mobilise working class opinion or action on a republican basis. This is classic economism. The SWP attitude to the monarchy expresses its total attitude to political struggle as such.

Sean ends his column by saying that "republicanism is slowly in ching its way back on to the political agenda in Britain. Forward to the Republic". And let add the hope that Socialist Organiser will be one of the papers in the vanguard of any "inching" that is going on, and helping to convert those inches into feet and miles.

----- pull-quotes -----

SOAPBOX By the editor of Republican

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 486

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →